Play it off (Sarah's sadistic scheme)

Sarah felt like she'd been caught with her hand in the cookie jar as she silently met everyone else's gaze for an uncomfortably long time. It was only when Matt's cock twitched in her grasp that her mind finally rebooted. Pushing his straining erection with one hand and wiping her mouth with the other, Sarah dropped the blanket down in his lap and sat up with a haughty laugh.

"Hah, just like I thought, nothing to see!" She declared, scoffing at Matt as she pushed the blanket down in his lap and made sure to squash his raging erection flat. "Oh, hey guys," she added as she looked towards the group again, desperately pretending that she had only just noticed them. "Nicole finish her dare yet?"

The expressions on the others faces, ranging from pleased surprise to near disgust, suggested that they weren't buying it, but Sarah saw no other option but to lie. They couldn't know the truth, that she had been drooling over and worshipping Matt's ridiculously big cock. "If Nicole and Miranda knew about it, they might want to take it from me~ I mean, they might want to make fun of me!" She thought, her head still spinning with desire.

"Yep, done," Nicole quietly replied, holding up her phone as proof, but it was obvious that her interest was not on her own completed dare. "Would you mind filling us in on what exactly it was you were doing under the blanket just now, Sarah?" Her eyes flicked from Sarah's mouth, where the lipstick was still smeared at the corners, to Matt's crotch. Despite him holding the blanket down, now that his monster cock was out of his boxers, it left a noticeable rise.

"Just thought I'd take a quick peek," Sarah shrugged, "maybe try and get ahead of the game a little, y'know?"

"Oh, really?" Nicole chuckled. "And what did you find?"

"Nothing interesting," Sarah snapped back, surprised by her own defensiveness. It had only been a couple of minutes since she'd had her first taste of that horse-cock, but she already felt possessive of it. Every last, thick, inch should belong to her, as far as Sarah was concerned. She was his crush, after all.

"I'm sure," Nicole muttered, one blonde eyebrow twitching as she struggled to keep a straight face.

That expression filled Sarah with unexpected dread, her blood chilling in her veins. "Does she know?" She thought, her eyes tracing down to the twitching corner of the short girl's lips. Nicole seemed like a total prude, but she was obviously close with Matt and John. It was a possibility that she'd caught a glimpse of what was in Matt's pants at some point, and if she knew that, then she knew exactly why Sarah was so flustered.

"Anyway, it's your turn isn't it?" Sarah wiped a stray strand of red hair off her face as she spoke. "Stop wasting time and draw a name already!" She added, hauling the blanket up to cover her chest again.

"Whatever you say," Nicole shrugged, "you're the host." Without another word, she picked up the hat from the table and put one delicate hand into it. Despite their conversation being over, Sarah still felt several eyes drilling into her. It was even worse than when she had been sitting there with her boobs practically hanging out, with only a tiny layer of tape to provide her any modesty.

An arm wrapped around her shoulders again, and she instinctively huddled into it's embrace for safety, before she remembered who that arm belonged to. Cuddling up to Matt like she was his girlfriend was not going to help her claim that she had just been innocently nosing around in his boxers. Putting one hand on his knee, she pushed herself upright and slightly away from him, but when her pinky finger brushed against his cock through just the thin material of the blanket, she felt her resolve waver.

"I've gotta have that dick," she thought, "but I can't let them know that I want to fuck Matt. He's such a dork, it would kill my reputation for sure." As Sarah puzzled over how she could possibly have her cake and eat it too, Nicole dug a name out of the hat.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Thank you for reading, I hope you enjoyed this chapter. If you want to see what Nicole draws a week in advance, then please join my Patreon. There, you will get early access to everything I post, in addition to monthly polls to decide what I'll be writing next. Today, I just uploaded a lengthy chapter about Nicole, Miranda, and Sarah having some fun with some unexpectedly meaty members. If you want to read that right now, please subscribe!

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123