OBJECTION!

Shower with Miranda

Nicole was halfway to the hat when Sarah stopped her. "Hold up!" She shouted, one finger raised pointedly while a smug grin spread across her face. "Nicole, care to explain this?" She asked, turning her phone around to show everyone it's screen. There, in a years old Instagram post, was Nicole planting a friendly kiss on John's blushing cheek. The caption read: Happy 18th to the best friend in the world.

Nicole felt the bottom fall out of her stomach. She remembered that day well. You had looked so cute when she had embarrassed you like that, there was no way she would have ever forgotten it, but she'd taken the picture for posterity anyway. Nicole had snapped that cute shot right after giving you your gift and posted it innocently to Instagram. When it was taken all that time ago, there was no way for Nicole to know it would one day come back to haunt her. Even as she looked at it now, she could scarcely believe that Sarah had found it.

"That was what she was doing on her phone the whole time!" Nicole suddenly realized. "Sarah wasn't bored, she was looking for evidence." While Nicole stared at the image, mouth agape, Sarah laughed again. "Didn't think I'd catch you, did you?" She taunted the shocked blonde haired girl, like Sherlock Holmes catching out a suspect. As she spoke she raised her phone up, making sure to show the smoking gun to everyone. Miranda, Matt, and Tom laughed at Nicole's slip up, whilst John sighed empathetically. Obviously you had known that Nicole had kissed you at some point, but you didn't expect Sarah to have proof.

"Oh, come on Sarah! That was ages ago and it was barely a kiss!" Nicole argues weakly, pointing to her own lips barely brushing against your cheek. "I think I was pretty clear in my rules Nicole," Sarah gloats. "Didn't I say even a peck on the cheek counts, guys?" She asks her audience, tucking her phone back into her pocket now they've all seen her evidence. A chorus of agreement is her answer, and even you nod your head wordlessly. You would like to protect Nicole, but Sarah had made her stipulations too clear to argue with.

With her weak defense torn apart Nicole pauses in shock once again. "Why has she done this?" She thinks, taken completely off balance by Sarah's seeming vindictiveness. "Have I pissed her off and this is payback, or is this all just a game to her?" Glancing toward her tormentor Nicole only sees a mischievous smile on Sarah's face, a look that doesn't answer her question at all.

Sarah, meanwhile, has to restrain herself to keep her cheeky grin from growing even broader. She truly couldn't believe how well her luck had been going tonight. First with Nicole and Miranda being so helpfully forthcoming in the shower, then with Nicole having Tom strip his top off and making herself hornier in the process, now this extra power over Nicole was the icing on the cake. If her lucky streak kept up like this then she could probably have Nicole sucking on Tom's cock like it was the last dick on earth in three dares or less. Of course, that would still leave Miranda to deal with, but she would cross that bridge when she came to it.

"Hey," Matt interrupts their stand off, getting carefully to his feet. "Since it sounds like there's not gonna be a dare for a little while, is it cool if I go to the bathroom and clean up a little?" As he speaks he gestures to his crotch, his underwear still sticky from when Sarah made him shoot all over them. "Oh, sure. Go ahead," Sarah happily dismisses him. With his legs spread wide apart he shuffles out the door. You watch him go with a suppressed smile at his goofy walk, before everyone returns their attention to the matter at hand.

"What can I say, girl?" Sarah shrugs rhetorically, pretending that she felt at least a little bad for her victim. "I warned you and you pushed your luck, now you have to be a big girl and accept your punishment." Those condescending words rankle Nicole, and that (combined with the **** she'd been drinking) imbued the usually meek girl with an uncharacteristic vigor. "FINE! You can spank me and get it over with!" She yelled, getting to her feet and marching towards Sarah. She was practically shoving her toned ass toward Sarah when she laughed and stopped her.

"Wrong again," Sarah wagged a well manicured finger at Nicole. "I'm not getting my hands dirty. I have someone else to do my dirty work."

"Who?" Nicole asked, her stomach falling once more as she realized just who Sarah's henchmen might be.

XXXXXXXXXXX
I hope you enjoyed this chapter. If you want to see even more of Nicole getting flustered then check out my Patreon. This weeks chapter over there includes her being **** to say something that she never normally would. The Halloween adventure will be out here on Tuesday for those interested. It's a big chunk and publishing it all may take a while, so you might want to hold off on playing it until it's all up.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123