Nicole

Ask questions

Matt cocks an eyebrow as he looks from the slip to Nicole and back. Glancing at the others his eyes rest on you and Sarah, his crush, still so close together and a lightbulb seems to go on in his head. "Nicole, I want you to take over leading John." He announces with a broad smile while Nicole furrows her brow. Matt knew she’d have some choice words for him, if she was able to speak, but right now he was safe from her verbal wrath. While Nicole can't voice any reaction to this dare the others can, and they all show approval in a round of laughter.

"The dumb leading the blind, good idea Matt," Sarah giggles, gaining herself another angry look from Nicole. She knew that Sarah meant dumb in the old fashioned sense, but Nicole still felt like she was the butt of too many jokes tonight. "Hey, Nicole's not dumb!" You stick up for her angrily, reminding Nicole of one of the reasons she likes you so much. Your caring and protective personality. "I mean dumb like, 'can't talk' y'know?" Sarah explains herself, making your defensiveness crumble into confusion. "Nicole can't talk?" You reply, your eyebrows furrowing just above your blindfold. "No, she's been wearing a sort of gag since she spoke during your dare. Did you not notice she was being quiet?" Matt asks, forcing you to be quiet for a moment.

"I thought she was just being shy," you eventually mumble, making everyone else laugh again. That reminds Nicole of oanther reason she likes you, how charmingly oblivious you could be. She wanted to join in mocking you too, but right now all she could do was roll her eyes. If Nicole is gagged then you see the point of Matt's dare, even if you don't actually see anything. Your first thought was just that it was a petty attempt to put some distance between you and his extra flirtatious crush, but this changes things.

To some degree you’d been relying on Sarah to describe things for you, even if her descriptions weren’t always honest. With Nicole unable to speak and you unable to read anything she were to write, you’d be completely blind. Before you can fully understand how you're going to get anywhereSarah's hand slips out of yours, leaving you blind and floundering. "See you later John," she purrs, planting her lips gently on your cheek. With that final touch she's gone, and you feel completely alone in the dark. Not for long though. Soon a delicate hand that can only be Nicole's gently takes your own, and you quietly breathe a sigh of relief. Nicole might not be able to tell you where to go, but at least you trust her not to lead you astray.

Nicole felt a surprising rush of nerves as she gripped your hand, all her earlier thoughts from when you'd groped her and slipped your tongue inside her rushing back. Part of her wished that they'd allowed you to believe it was still Sarah leading you, so Nicole could shamelessly flirt and tease you as she had been doing. "Promise not to lead me into a lamppost Nicole?" You ask, feeling her squeeze your hand twice in response. Before you get moving again Nicole leans her body against you, your heart skipping a beat as you remember that she's mostly naked beneath her borrowed coat. You shouldn't be thinking about her nude, petite body, you shouldn't be thinking about the taste of her pussy on your tongue when you were **** to lick her, and you really shouldn't be thinking about exploring her body with your hands and mouth until she's a quivering mess that needs that gag to hold back her moans. You shouldn't be thinking about any of that, but as her body weighs on yours you do anyway.

Unaware of your lewd thoughts that are shockingly similar to her own, Nicole takes a second to look at the other pairings of the group. Sarah was already cuddling up to Matt like a stray cat looking for a new home, and he looked plenty happy about it. Meanwhile Miranda continues to blush under Tom's arm that wraps around her shoulders like a python. "It could certainly be worse," Nicole thinks as Miranda has to swat Tom's hand away from her 36C breasts again. "Maybe it could be a lot better," an evil part of her whispers as her eyes trace to the bulge running down Tom's thigh and the trickle of girl cum running down Miranda's. Pushing away such disgusting thoughts she turns to Matt and gestures for the hat.

"Has Nicole given a dare since she put the gag on?" Miranda asks. "I don't think so," Matt replies, "how does that work?" There's a moments pause as everyone (everyone but you) looks to Sarah. As the host she's the de facto leader and games master. "Hmm," Sarah scratches her chin for a moment before answering. "I think she can take the gag off long enough to give a dare but it has to go straight back on afterwards. And if you try to say anything else other than the name and the dare then you get another punishment," Sarah rules, and Nicole nearly stamped her foot in frustration. She'd hoped that her embarrassing punishment was going to end, not just that she was going to get a temporary respite. Despite her annoyance, everyone else seems content with Sarah's decision so Nicole has little choice but to go along with it. It's not like she could argue her case anyway.

With Sarah's decision seemingly being final Nicole paws through the hat as Matt holds it out for her, preparing to say her first words in what felt like hours.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
I've decided to revisit this thread after a comment reminded me that it existed. This week's Patreon upload sees Tom putting Miranda to work making Sarah more "comfortable". If you're interested in that, or in seeing any of my work early, then please subscribe to my Patreon.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123