New Fetish New Year, Pt. 4

Three days ago…

“Here we go.” Maddy says upon tapping ‘spin’ on the virtual wheel once more. Whoever the wheel lands on, will be the one that cucks the cuckold. Since your daughter, Stella, can’t be the cuckold, as that’s already one of her fetishes with Cassie. If this spin doesn’t land on her, that means she’ll take the last fetish that hasn’t been spun for yet — being a freeuse fucktoy.

“OH! It’s me! I’m the ‘cucker’!” Maddy reacts once the wheel stops on her name.

“OH! That means I’m the freeuse fucktoy too!” Stella reacts.

“The way we throw around the term ‘freeuse fucktoy’ like it’s a good thing should baffle me, but it doesn’t.” Brooke jokes.

“Can you imagine if M got that fetish?” Viv sets up her joke.

“Why? What do you think would happen if Maddy got that fetish?” Tanya asks, falling for Viv’s set-up.

“She’d be the only fucktoy that’ll get pissed she’s not being used more.” Viv says the punchline, making Stella laugh.

“Maddy’ll be like those Duolingo notifications that’ll constantly remind Dad to fuck her whenever he’s doing something else.” Stella piles on, making Viv laugh.

“Looks like you’re doing something else… when you should be doing me!” Viv continues the joke.

“Looks like you missed out on fucking me today. You know what happens now.” Stella continues, to her and Viv’s amusement.

“I’M SPINNING AGAIN!” Maddy shouts to cut Viv and Stella from continuing the joke, as she’s beginning to get red from embarrassment. Viv and Stella notice this too and give her the same side hug that Viv and Brooke gave Tanya earlier.

“So this spin is for the cuckold?” Becca asks.

“I DON’T CARE!” Maddy says with a raised voice, still irritated at being bullied for being the most obvious one with her lustfulness. “You guys decide what this is for, I just want Viv and Stella to stop teasing me!” Maddy answers Becca before immediately tapping spin.

“Might as well spin for who gets cuckolded.” Viv suggests while giving an affectionate cheek kiss to Maddy. Becca just shrugs in agreement.

“It’s Becca!” Viv announces.

“It seems I’ll be your cuckold, Maddy.” Becca addresses Maddy, and Maddy gives Becca an appreciative smile for not teasing her like Viv and Stella.

“Becks, if you ever need to speedrun getting cucked by Maddy, here’s a pro tip — the next time Maddy and Dad are alone together, just randomly pop up where they are. Chances are, you’ll be cucked immediately.” Stella teases Maddy again.

“If you two keep ganging up on Maddy, I might just have sex with everybody else instead during your turn.” You threaten Viv and Stella.

“Freeuse does mean that he gets to use you in whatever way he wants. I assume that includes not using you at all.” Becca points out.

“WHAT!?”, “That’s so unfair!” Stella and Viv shout simultaneously, to everybody else’s laughter. Most importantly, Maddy seemed to enjoy your threat a lot.

“What was it about me being the fucktoy that’ll get pissed she isn’t being used?” Maddy asks sarcastically.

“What’s that Office quote you like using a lot, Stella? How the turntables?” Cassie jokes.

“Can you imagine on their day it’s just the two of them outside Jay’s bedroom while he takes turns on the five of us?” Maddy jokes.

“I like your imagination, Maddy.” Tanya says in support of her.

“As long as Stella doesn’t get to watch.” Cassie points out.

“Yeah. Otherwise, it’s not much of a punishment since she’ll probably enjoy it.” Maddy finally finds the opportunity to fire back, getting Cassie and Brooke to laugh with her.

“Vivian might enjoy that too, to be honest.” Becca points out.

“Oh, yeah. Viv does like getting teased like that.” Brooke says in agreement.

“Okay!”, “We get it!” Stella and Viv shout on top of each other, to get your other girlfriends to stop from ganging up on them. “We’re just as horny as Maddy.” They add in unison, resulting in everyone laughing at being able to turn the tables on them.

“Well, I guess that’s it then.” Maddy says after the laughter dies down.

“I hope all of us enjoy these new fetishes we’re going to try out.”

The present…

“Good morning, baby.” You greet your daughter, kissing her as she begins to stir in her sleep.

The two of you are on Viv’s bed, having slept here last night with Viv to separate you from the rest of your girlfriends. Today’s the last day of the New Year where your girlfriends are trying out the new fetishes they spun for. The final fetish, the one you suggested as something new to try, is for your last two girlfriends to be freeuse fucktoys.

As agreed upon last night before you all went to bed, the fetish is applicable the moment you wake up, up until the end of the day.

Now that you’re awake, and this being something you’ve been looking forward to, you are not going to waste time and make the most of it.

“Good morning, Daddy.” Stella greets you with a smile, before immediately glancing down at your crotch area. Stella seems to understand the situation you’re putting her in, and just gives you a devious smile. She pulls down the waistband of your underwear without even asking and licks her palm, stroking your morning wood right after.

“Where’s Viv?” Stella asks you nonchalantly, as she strokes your cock.

“I’m not sure, actually. She wasn’t here when I woke up.” You answer her, as she shifts her position on the bed, getting her face nearer to your cock.

“Have you had breakfast yet?” Stella asks you, before using her lips to wrap around your cockhead, and using the tip of her tongue to tease your urethra.

“No. Not yet. I didn’t want to go out with a tent in my boxers.” You answer her, and Stella chuckles while your cock is still in her mouth. She may have taken your answer as a signal that you want her to service you to completion, as she takes more of your cock into her mouth right after.

Stella begins to move her head up and down on your cock while she lays on her back on the bed. One of her hands goes down to her own crotch underneath her shorts to play with herself while sucking you off. You grab the arm that went underneath her shorts to stop her from continuing.

“You're my plaything today, baby. Focus on me.” You tell your daughter. Your statement brings out a fire in her eyes, feeling challenged by it. Surprisingly though, she stops sucking on your cock and jerking you off with her other hand entirely. Stella shifts her position on the bed, so that her head is hanging on the edge of it.

“I’m your plaything, Daddy.” Stella confirms for you. “So use me.” Stella adds on, before opening her mouth wide. You realize what she wants you to do, and you place your hand on the back of her head, before slowly penetrating her mouth with your cock.

Once you feel resistance, you start pulling back slowly, before immediately pushing back in. The more you repeat this push and pull motion, you notice your daughter being able to take more and more of your cock into her mouth. It doesn’t take long before Stella’s deepthroating you, and your balls are hitting her nose. You look at the indentation of your cock on her neck, before Stella taps you on the thigh to signal that you need to take it out of her soon.

You let Stella recover for a bit, lifting her shirt up and fondling her breasts while she takes deep breaths. Once she stops breathing heavily, and you hear the sound she makes with her open mouth, you begin to slowly facefuck her once more.

You start speeding up your facefucking. Once you feel how much Stella can take, you try not to go beyond it so you can do this pace continuously. The wet and warm feeling around your cock, as well as watching her tits bounce with every motion you do, is getting you close to orgasm quickly. Not needing to hold back though, as they are your playthings for today, you speed up a little more to get you over the edge as quickly as possible. Playing into the role that she’s your fucktoy, you don’t warn her that you’re getting close to cumming. Instead, you just speed up some more until you feel the first spurts of your cum leave your body, and you go balls deep into your daughter’s mouth before releasing all of your cum down her throat.

You watch as Stella noticeably gulps down all of the cum you’re releasing down her throat, before taking your cock out of her mouth. Stella takes a deep breath, before sticking her tongue out, showing you that there’s not a single trace of your cum in her mouth.

“Okay. Time to get up, baby. It’s time for breakfast.” You tell your daughter, acting as if the most normal thing happened between you two just now.

“I’m pretty sure I just had breakfast.” Stella jokes.

A few hours later...

“Where have you been?” Stella asks Viv, as she enters her apartment, carrying a bag of groceries.

“Really?” Viv asks Stella rhetorically, as she looks at the bag of groceries she’s carrying to answer Stella.

“Oh. Right.” Stella says with an awkward smile. “You need help with that?” Stella then asks her.

“Yeah, actually. Can you take these out of the bag, put the chicken and the buttermilk in the fridge, and the rest you can just place on the counter. I’ll just go get changed.” Viv answers Stella, as she leaves the bag of groceries on her kitchen island.

Stella immediately gets up from the couch where the two of you were watching television to go do what Viv asked her to, while Viv went to her room. You stand up from the couch too, and help your daughter with the groceries. You lay out the stuff Viv bought, while Stella put the chicken and the buttermilk in the refrigerator. You take out a packet from the paper bag and immediately realize what Viv is cooking for lunch.

“Viv’s making sinigang.” You tell Stella, as you hold the Knorr Sinigang mix in your hand.

“Oh! Marybeth’s specialty!?” Stella asks in excitement.

“Yep!” You hear Viv answer, not glancing at her just yet.

“Gah dayum!” Stella reacts, making you look at what made Stella react that way.

“What?” Viv asks, as she walks towards you and your daughter completely naked.

“Nothing.” Stella answers, waving off Viv’s question as your mouth hangs open in surprise. Viv grabs her apron and puts it on, weirdly enhancing her sex appeal by putting more clothes on. Viv takes out her big pot and pours water into it, while she asks Stella to open the stove. Viv places the pot of water on top of the flame and covers it with a lid. She glances at you with a sly smile, as you continue to watch her naked backside while prepping your lunch. After she cuts the onions and the tomatoes into quarters, she goes back to the pot and lifts the lid.

“Stella? Can you tell me if the water’s boiling? I’ll just prep the rice.” Viv asks your daughter.

“Sure.” Stella answers, and Viv begins to wash the rice before placing them onto her rice cooker. She puts her finger inside the rice cooker before pouring water into it. Afterwards, she just turns on the rice cooker and puts the lid on it to cook.

“So~, how’s your day been so far?” Viv asks, now that she’s basically just waiting for water to boil.

“It’s been pretty chill.” Stella answers her, and the two of them start a conversation that you tune out immediately, as you continue to watch Viv’s butt bounce around as she intentionally shifts her weight in place.

Unable to hold yourself back any longer, you lower yourself onto your knees, with Viv’s butt right in front of you. You spread her asscheeks to reveal her cute little butthole, and her inviting pussy. You stick your tongue out and begin to lick the walls of her labia.

“Daddy~, you’ll ruin your appetite.” Viv teasingly tells you, as she shakes her rump on your face.

“Water’s boiling.” Stella informs Viv.

“Cool. Can you dump the tomatoes and the onions inside it, please?” Viv asks Stella, who you assume does what Viv requested her to do, as Viv remains in place while you wet her slit with your tongue. Viv tries to stifle a moan while she and Stella continue their conversation from earlier.

You eat Viv’s pussy for a few more minutes. You feel her legs shake from a mini orgasm, and the entirety of your mouth is coated with a mixture of your saliva and her juices. Seeing that she’s sufficiently wet, based on what your tongue can feel; you stand up behind her and pull your pants and underwear down in one go, before placing your cock towards her entrance.

“You need help with anything else, by the way?” Stella asks her.

“Oh, um~, can you dump the pork belly inside the pot as well?” Viv asks your daughter, as you plunge your cock deep inside her. Viv immediately moans from pleasure, unable to hold back her reaction after you go balls-deep inside her without warning.

“Do I have to cut this down?” Stella asks Viv, as she opens the brown paper wrapping from the butcher.

“Nah. I already got the butcher to cut it into pieces. It’ll shrink once it’s cooked so you don’t have to cut it down some more.” Viv tells her before stifling another moan, as you continue to go in and out of her at a slow pace, savoring the feeling of her pussy on your cock.

“Oh. Cool. So, I’ll just dump this in?” Stella asks her to confirm. You shift your pace to go out of her slowly, but go back inside her much quicker in a hard pounding motion.

“Yup. Just… ugh… dump… oh fuck… it in.” Viv answers her, unable to control her reactions to the hard pounding you’re giving her.

“What next?” Stella asks her, basically allowing Viv to not move from her spot as you fuck her from behind.

“Ugh~, can you, ugh~, peel the taro and cut it into pieces?” Viv asks you daughter.

“Is this the taro?” Stella asks her, while holding up the taro in her hand.

“Yep— OH FUCK!” Viv answers, before you speed up your pace to fuck her more properly.

“Woof. Good thing I’m keeping myself busy.” Stella says with a chuckle.

“Oh~ right.” Viv chuckles too. “Is that why you’re being so helpful?” Viv asks her.

“Guilty.” Stella answers her, as she begins to peel the taro.

You start building up speed, holding onto Viv’s hips as you do. You look at your daughter who is trying her best to focus on what she’s doing. Try as she might, you can see her biting her lip and glancing every once in a while at your direction. The sound of your skin slapping onto Viv’s, as well as the wet sounds coming from her pussy fill the room.

“Okay, I’ve cut these. Do I dump them in too?” Stella asks.

“No. Mmmhh… not yet. We need to wait… fuck… for the pork to cook. Maybe another… ungh… 20 minutes or so.” Viv answers Stella in between moans.

“Oh, wow. You really planned ahead, huh?” Stella asks her, impressed.

“I chose a one pot meal for a reason.” Viv answers her, confirming Stella’s assumption.

“You hear that, Daddy? She doesn’t have to do any meal prepping for another twenty minutes.” Stella points out to you.

Hearing that from your daughter, you take Viv’s arms and pull them backwards, as Viv continues to lean forward to give you leverage; before starting to pound her pussy at a fast pace.

“You’re not using me right now, so that means I can play with myself, right?” Stella asks you, as she begins to pinch her hardening nipples through her shirt. You don’t bother answering Stella, and just let her do what she wants to do. She begins to rub her pussy underneath her shorts as she watches you pound Viv hard.

Viv is beginning to moan in cadences with your pace, and you’re beginning to feel your orgasm coming as well. You let go of Viv’s hands and pull her ponytail, as you go for one final burst of speed in and out of her.

“Stella-aah-aaaah?” Viv calls out to your daughter?

“Yeah?” Stella responds, as she continues to furiously rub herself while watching you fuck Viv in front of her.

“Don’t forget to wash your hands before touching the food again, okay?” Viv reminds her, getting Stella and herself to chuckle, before she lets out a long groan of pleasure from another orgasm. You let go of Viv’s hair as she’s orgasming, and she falls forward onto her kitchen counter. You’re not far behind and go balls deep inside her one last time, before exploding inside her.

“Fuck! I’m cumming too!” Stella shouts as she furiously fingers herself.

You allow all three of you to bask in your post climax bliss, before instructing Stella to do one more thing.

“Baby? I wouldn’t want Viv to slip on the floor when she’s cooking. Can you take care of the leak coming out of her for me?” You instruct your daughter.

Stella immediately kneels behind Viv. Stella licks her thighs which have already gotten moist with her own cum, before moving upwards and sucking the cum out of Viv’s pussy.

“Good girl.” You compliment her.

“I’m cooking fried chicken tonight, by the way. If you don’t want us to get messy, maybe use Stella instead of me while I’m cooking that one.” Viv jokes.

A few more hours after that...

It’s been a few hours since you, Stella, and Viv had your fried chicken dinner. You, Stella, and Viv dropped by your own apartment just to quickly catch up with your other girlfriends. Viv and Stella went back to Viv’s earlier while you stayed behind to catch up with your other girlfriends some more. After some time, you said your ‘good nights’ to your other girlfriends before going back to Viv’s apartment next door. You enter Viv’s bedroom where you see Viv and Stella laying on the bed together. Stella’s in her underwear watching a movie on her laptop with headphones on, while Viv is reading a book in a dark green one piece .

You begin to undress before you even make it near the bed where they are. Stella and Viv glance as you enter, but don’t acknowledge your presence vocally, but their sly smiles indicate they know what’s about to happen once you make it to the bed. Completely naked by the time you get to them, you straddle Viv’s thighs, with your cock resting in between her buttcheeks.

“What are you reading?” You ask Viv, as you try to slide her one piece to the side, only to notice there’s a clasp that connects the crotch area together.

“Pride and Prejudice.” Viv answers you playfully, as you unclasp the thing that’s keeping the crotch pieces together, revealing her awaiting pussy to you.

“I see you’re familiar with two sins.” You start to say, in your best impression of Don Draper you can manage. “How ‘bout a third?” You continue the line before rubbing the entrance of her pussy with your fingers.

“Oh, ~Abed.” Viv reacts with a laugh, familiar with the reference, making you laugh too.

“Seriously though, what’re you reading?” You ask her.

“It’s the autobiography of Grant Achatz.” She answers you, as you try to make her wet with your fingers as much as you can.

“Who’s that?” You ask her, genuinely curious.

“He’s a brilliant chef who got tongue cancer. Tongue cancer! For a chef! Couldn’t taste anything properly while running a restaurant, and still creating groundbreaking dishes. I can’t even imagine.” Viv tells you enthusiastically. Her enthusiasm gives you pause, as it makes you realize that you might actually be bothering her by doing what you’re doing to her right now, while she’s reading something that she’s genuinely interested in. Viv seems to feel your hesitation as she takes you by the wrist, and pulls your fingers deeper into her pussy.

“This is like my fourth or fifth time reading this.” Viv informs you, assuring you that you should continue doing what you’re doing.

“Stella? Can you lay down next to Viv, please?” You ask your daughter, before realizing she didn’t hear you with headphones on. Viv snaps at her to get her attention though, and she takes the headphones off.

“Yup?” Stella asks with some enthusiasm.

“Can you lay down next to Viv, please?” You repeat your request. Stella immediately shifts her body to lie next to Viv, her butt also towards you. You slide her panties to the side, only to notice that there’s something above her pussy you didn’t expect. You pull her panty down to confirm what you thought you saw.

“Interesting.” You comment, seeing the buttplug inside Stella asshole.

“What is?” Stella asks you teasingly, knowing full well what it is you’re commenting on.

“Nothing. Just admiring the view.” You answer her, and she turns her hips from side to side to entice you to play with her ass.

“Bedside table by the way.” Viv points out, making you look at her bedside table. You see a lube dispenser on top of it. “Just in case you feel like you need to put on more.” Viv adds. You pause what you’re doing to grab the lube and put it on the bed, to make it easier for you to get a hold of later.

You restart fingering Viv once more, until you feel how wet Viv’s pussy is with your fingers, and feel that she’s ready to take your cock inside her. You press the tip of your cock on her entrance, as she lays prone on the bed, before pushing your cock in slowly. Letting you and her savor the pleasure you’re giving each other.

“Taste this for me, baby.” You instruct your daughter, as you show her your fingers that are slick with Viv’s juices. Stella immediately uses her lips and tongue to get a taste of Viv’s pussy, and Viv joins her to do the same thing, essentially making out with your two fingers in between their makeout session.

You retract your fingers, and just watch your girlfriends continue to make out with each other. You begin to play with Stella’s pussy with your other hand, while also speeding up your pace in prone boning Viv. You hear both of them moan as they continue to make out with each other, and your dick can’t help but twitch inside Viv as the sensations you're experiencing are truly magical.

Once you feel Stella’s sufficiently wet as well, you instruct Viv to lay on her back and that Stella should go on top of her. You take Stella’s panties completely off, and stare at the vision before you. Your two girlfriends’ pussies, one on top of the other, both soaking wet and ready to be penetrated, while Stella’s asshole tempts you with a buttplug inside it that she’s moving by puckering her asshole.

Instead of choosing between either pussy, you use the slickness from Viv’s pussy that’s coating your cock, and squeeze your dick in the space in between their pussies. You push Stella’s ass down with your hands to form a tight feel around your cock, and begin repeatedly sliding your cock in and out. Your two girlfriends begin to grind their hips, trying to get their clits to rub against your shaft as much as they can while they sandwich your cock.

Feeling like the slipperiness of your cock is rubbing off, you insert your cock inside Stella’s awaiting wet pussy to feel that warm wetness around your cock once more. You don’t waste time and fuck Stella at an increased pace immediately. Stella and Viv continue to make out in front of you, while Viv continues to grind on Stella as you pump in and out of your daughter.

You play with the buttplug in Stella’s asshole while you fuck her, twisting it in place, pulling it back ever so slightly, before pushing it back in. Feeling a little more adventurous, you slow down your pace and pull out of Stella only to immediately plunge your cock into Viv, taking Viv by surprise. Viv immediately moans, muffled by having Stella’s mouth on hers. You start alternating between your girlfriends’ pussies slowly at first, but begin to build your rhythm as you do it more and more. You even start doing multiple random strokes into one pussy, before immediately switching to the other, mixing their juices together with your cock.

You finally pull out Stella’s buttplug, and see the gaping hole it leaves as she puckers it to tempt you. You can see her asshole is already lubed up, but you coat your fingers with more lube just in case, before penetrating your daughter’s asshole with your fingers. You stick to fucking Viv’s pussy now, no longer switching between the two of them, as your fingers are stuck inside Stella’s tight asshole. You begin to speed up, and you fingerfuck Stella’s asshole with the same pace you’re fucking Viv. The two of them can barely contain the noises of pleasure you’re eliciting from them.

You hear Viv let out a loud groan as her body begins to shake from her orgasm. You pause fingerfucking Stella, and grab onto Viv’s hips, so you can piston even faster into Viv’s pussy while she is cumming. Her moans begin to go on an undulating wave that’s being caused by your rapid fucking of her. Without warning you feel like you’re cumming inside Viv. You let out your initial spurt inside her pussy, but immediately pull out only to switch to Stella’s waiting asshole.

You remember to go in slowly, as this is the first time you’ll be fucking your daughter’s asshole. You were still actually coming, so penetrating her with your tip meant that you were coating the inside of her asshole with your warm cum already. Thankfully, you have the ‘Steadfast Lover’ trait already, so you know you won’t go soft even after cumming already.

After you spurt your remaining cum inside Stella’s asshole, you slowly push inside Stella more and more. You eventually get a couple of inches inside Stella before she moans in a mixture of pleasure and pain, tightening her anal walls around your cockhead. Viv takes Stella’s hands in hers, crossing their fingers. Viv lets Stella grip her hands to help Stella endure the pain that she’s not used to yet, as your cock is definitely thicker than just your two fingers.

You grind on Stella’s asshole like this for a few more minutes, until you feel her asshole has adjusted to you more and more, and allowing you to go in deeper with your cock.

“FUUUUUCK!” Stella groans in bated breath as you finally go balls deep inside her, directly followed by a squirting orgasm that falls right onto Viv’s pussy. You let her ride out her orgasm, before you start moving your hips some more. Every inch of movement gets a moaning ‘fuck’ out of Stella.

It doesn’t take you more than a few minutes of this before you cum inside Stella too. Her tightness, and the sensitivity of your cock from just having cum, expediting the speed of your second orgasm. Stella came a few more times too, her head falling forward in exhaustion. Viv lets go of her hands and hugs Stella, placing one of her hands on the back of Stella’s head.

“You did great, baby.” Viv assures her, but you realize Stella might be passed out from her intense orgasms. You pull out of Stella, and she uncontrollably farts some of your cum out of her asshole. It gets Viv to laugh though.

“You’re paying for my laundry this week, Junior.”

Poll Results:

Yep, Maddy was actually the second place vote getter for this fetish as well. I guess it's a testament to Maddy's popularity that she got voted for multiple fetishes. In fairness to Viv, if I only counted the unique votes for this fetish, she would actually be the lead vote getter as a lot of the votes for the others are also from people that voted for them in other fetishes as well.

Author's Message: Sorry for the late upload on this one. Contracted a fever (thankfully nothing serious like COVID since I'm already recovering - EDIT [1/11/2022]: Apparently, IT IS COVID XD) a couple of days ago, and only just started to not be groggy yesterday. I was only about a quarter done with this before my fever. Felt good enough to start writing in parts yesterday, and actually felt energetic enough to finish it today. I may have missed some stuff in my proofreading due to still being kinda drowsy from the meds, so I'd appreciate it if you can comment any errors I may have made on this one.

This is the last of the "Twelve Days of Christmas Special"! I hope you all enjoyed it!

Thanks again to Valent, Niallish, Akhara, and my anonymous donor for making this Holiday Special possible. I'll see you all when I get back to writing the main storyline after my break. Cheers!