Meanwhile Downstairs

Authors note: I should have stopped the previous chapter "Cut Your Losses" when John went up the stairs and left the bathroom scene has a separate chapter. Sorry, my lack of experience. Onward.

===================================

Everyone just looked at the stairs where John had gone after Nicole.

"Alright!" says Tom rubbing his hands together. "Now those two goody-two-shoes are gone can we have some real fun!"

"Why don't we get something to drink and you know... calm down a bit." says Miranda with a wary look at Tom.

"That's a great idea!" chimes in Sarah. "I'll get a couple of bottles. I know where my dad has his stash. Meet you all in the kitchen. Oh! There's a service bathroom at the other end of the house if anyone needs it." says Sarah putting on her panties, bra and shoes, before leaving the room.

The other teens also just put their underwear on before going to the kitchen to wait for Sarah.

Sarah

Sarah walked quickly down the hall to her father's library mumbling to herself. "That stupid idiot! What the hell was she thinking, coming up with that stupid game with Tom here! She should have known better. Yea try to help John nail Miranda was a good idea. It would be a make it or break it deal for those two, but you should have given me a heads up. I could have helped you set them up and not get yourself in trouble."

Not that Miranda would have needed much encouragement to spread her legs. Sarah knew that Miranda was just has much a slut has herself but managed to keep things discrete. She knew there weren't many rumors were going around in school about her which could only mean that Miranda knew how to make the guys keep quiet. The fact that most of the guys were from out of town also helped.

Despite having very different sexual morals Sarah and Nicole had quite a few things in common, music, books, pets (dogs) and... respect. Many girls (and specially their parents) didn't like hanging out with her when she started to become the school slut unless, of course, they were... also sluts. But not Nicole. She didn't judge her on it and they continued being friends, this truly endeared Sarah to the point that she considered Nicole to be one of the few true friends she had.

Sarah often teased Nicole about her secret crush on John no matter how much she denied it. Sarah's favorite tease was to tell Nicole that she was happy Nicole had a longstanding boyfriend... it was just a shame that said boyfriend didn't know it yet. A yet a few times she told Nicole she should stop helping John get laid, smack him upside the head, open his eyes and tell him how she felt and, maybe, get some John-dick for herself.

Sarah reached her father's library and pulled out the magnetic key from its hiding place and opened the door. She always made sure this place was closed, locked and completely off limits during her little parties. Her father wasn't stupid and knew exactly when she raided his booze and what she took and has long has it was discrete, no problem. But, let people in here, his library and home office... he would kill her. She opened the liquor cabinet and pulled out a few bottles while she kept talking to herself.

"Oh Nicole" thought Sarah softly "This type of game is way over your head. Almost had me fooled that you could take it. You are sooo lucky John cares enough about you to pull you out just in the nick... of... time...."

She froze, almost dropping the bottles when it hit her. She put the bottles on the desk and sank into the chair has she smacked her head. "I AM SUCH AN IDIOT!" she yelled at herself.

"John cares enough about her to pull her out" Sarah repeated her thoughts.... "Oh John, you sweet, stupid, blind, lovable, thick-headed FOOL!!" She said has she left the library and ran down to the servant’s bathroom replaying the last moments in her head.

"Who would drop a threesome with the two hottest girls in school just to help a 'friend' avoid a 'crappy lay'? Oh No... Nobody does that." She knew guys that would literally kill to be in a threesome with her and Miranda. "John loves Nicole, and the fool just doesn't even know it! Why else would he spends months with a crush on Miranda and not ask her out?” John and Nicole were so alike they even lied to themselves the same way. “No John. You love her. You're just too blind and thick-headed to know it. I just hope you really meant what you said back there." Sarah talked to herself.

Reaching the bathroom, she put on a robe and looked into her secret stash, pulled out a pill for John. She thought about adding a condom and a morning-after pill but just said "fuck it, it would just kill the mood."

Sarah stopped off at the library for the bottles and to pick up a pair of keys before heading back to the kitchen hoping they hadn't left yet.

"Ok guys! I got some sweet stuff, Chocolate and strawberry liquor, vodka and some whiskey we can mix with the ice cream in the fridge." Chirped a happy Sarah. "Miranda dear would you serve it up please? I'm going to make sure John and Nicole leave... Don't want them sneaking a free show do we now?"

"Maybe I should go?" offered Matt.

Matt

"What's wrong with them!" thought an angry and frustrated Matt. "Nicole wouldn't let me cum with Sarah and she knows I want to hook up with her. She'll help John nail any girl but she won't help me with Sarah. BITCH! And then, when I'm about to cum with Nicole, John jumps in and cuts me off. FUCKER! I thought they were my friends! He has Nicole all over him, but he just ignores her, and won't let anyone else near her either." He huffs inside his head while he watches John get dressed, pick up Nicole's clothes and go upstairs. "So now she makes a scene and runs off and John goes off after her like a puppy. Good riddance both of them."

"Alright!" says Tom rubbing his hands together. "Now those two goody-two-shoes are gone can we have some real fun!"

"Why don't we get something to drink and you know... calm down a bit." says Miranda with a wary look at Tom.

"That's a great idea!" chimes in Sarah. "I'll get a couple of bottles. I know where my dad has his stash. Meet you all in the kitchen. Oh! There's a service bathroom at the other end of the house if anyone needs it." says Sarah putting on her panties, bra and shoes, before leaving the room.

Matt puts on his boxers and follows Tom and Miranda to the kitchen. He takes a couple of deep breaths while going over in is head what just happened.

Still, the image in his mind of John with Miranda and then adding in Sarah... "Aaarrggg! How could he do that to me! It's not fair! How can he be so selfish! He gets all the girls. Why can’t he share them with me, just one! He knows I want Sarah!"

Reaching the kitchen, Matt went to the nearest window and then the next. He was looking out to see if he had an angle on John's car. He wanted to see if they really left or not. Since he couldn't see the car, he moves over to sit near the door to wait for Sarah since he saw Miranda and Tom whispering to each other and didn't want to interrupt them.

He kept playing the scene over and over in his head. Frustrated at not being able to cum with the girls and jealous of John every time he pictured him with both Miranda and Sarah.

But it was Nicole's reaction that made him doubt "She looked shaken, like she was almost hysterical" he thought, remembering her face and her words. "She looked like she was about to start crying, holding on to John like he was some sort of life raft or something. Maybe John was right... maybe Tom was going to **** her? Maybe his did go too far..." completely ignoring his own part in the events. "Yes... he was right to get Nicole away from Tom." She always hated Tom, they all knew it, and all three of them were never comfortable with Tom around.

"I made a mistake." he suddenly realizes, "I've got to apologize to them, especially Nicole, before they leave."

"Before they leave..." he thought, the gears turning in his head. "If they leave... If they leave... I could have a better shot with Sarah. Tom is going for Miranda now and that would leave Sarah for me. I can show her that I am just has good or even better than all the other guys she's been with and... show those two that I was right."

John and Nicole had been trying to dissuade Matt from Sarah for some time. Pointing out her habit of jumping from one guy to another. They didn't want him to get his hopes up and then end up with a broken heart and told him so. And so, for the last 6 months, Matt had been going once a twice a month to a motel to met with a call girl, Tammy. It was the best way he could think of to get experience fast enough for when he hooked up with Sarah. He was sure that now, he was ready. He would be the best guy Sarah ever fucked. He'd prove it. Tammy said he was the best she had ever had, why would she lie.

Looking over he sees Tom running his finger up and down Miranda's chest and almost hear her sigh. Matt reasoned. "He's good, I've got to learn how he does it, how does a jerk like Tom get all the girls over and over."

"Ok guys! I got some sweet stuff, Chocolate and strawberry liquor, vodka and some whiskey we can mix with the ice cream in the fridge." Chirped a happy Sarah. "Miranda dear would you serve it up please? I'm going to make sure John and Nicole leave... Don't want them sneaking a free show do we now?"

"Maybe I should go?" offered Matt.

Miranda and Tom

Miranda walked over to the far end of the kitchen away from Matt and leans against the wall. Looking up she's not surprised to see that Tom had followed her. He leans in above her resting his forearm on the wall above Miranda, looking down and admiring Miranda's cleavage from above.

Miranda glances at Matt to make sure he can't hear before looking up and whispering harshly. "You screwed up!"

"What do mean I screwed up?" Tom whispered back. He tucks a strand of Miranda's hair behind her ear, dragging his finger lightly down and across her jawline. "You saw her, she was soaking wet, she was ready to get fucked when that wimp showed up. YOU! didn't distract him enough. YOU! screwed up."

"NO, she wasn't ready, she wasn't begging for it and you know it." Miranda's harsh whisper came back. "She tried to break out..." She paused a bit before adding "But yea, she was close. Damm it! You should have waited for me to get it on with John. You. Moved. Too. Fast!"

"Christ! I don't know why you go through all this drama just to get laid." Tom whispers. He twirls a finger lightly around a lock of hair near her neck before lightly tracing a line from her neck to her shoulder and down the strap of her bra. "That wimp had a crush on you. All you had to do was spread your legs and you'd have him begging for more. But Nooo you needed to get that runt involved... though she was better than I thought she would be." Tom let his finger run down the strap of her bra, half on the strap, half on her skin. When he reached the bra, he flipped his finger under the strap for the upward stroke running his nail over her skin. "Jesus. A hot girl like you can get anyone she wants whenever she wants." he said with real admiration.

"You don't think I know that!" Miranda answered Tom. "I get laid enough ok. Sometimes... I just want something more." Now she pouted her lips thinking what she lost while Tom continues to trace his fingers on her neck and shoulder and down to her bra. Her breath now, just slightly shallower.

Truth was, Miranda did get around a bit being has she was, Sarah's accomplice and wingman. She still hooked up almost has much has Sarah. But where Sarah was more flamboyant, Miranda was low key and knew how to keep the guys from talking. But there was also another side to her. Miranda liked a challenge and she liked to hunt. And she liked to hunt guys that were taken. She loved seducing guys with girlfriends. Having them think it was all their idea was a big turn on for Miranda. Make them dump their girlfriend for her and then dump them in return was exquisite. She had already broken up three couples this year without anyone even noticing. She almost got the Science teacher too, but he chickened out. At least she got all the test answers and a straight A+ grade out of it. And in all those elaborate adventures Tom had been her partner in crime.

When Miranda got back from New York she noticed John for the first time, vaguely remembering him has a skinny nerdy type who had... somehow... filled out, not a hot alpha type like Tom, but no longer your typical skinny zit-faced nerd but a pretty decent, well-built guy with good taste in cloths (thanks to Nicole helping him chose what to wear). She could instantly see that Nicole was really into John. For a time, Miranda was convinced that Nicole was his girlfriend until Sarah swore to her that they weren't a couple. Even so... She was always with him, always talking about him, how great he was, how 'John did this', and 'John did that' and 'John took me to see... whatever' movie or band was playing. Uuuugggg! John was the only thing she talked about and that really grated on her nerves. Nicole sounded like a sweet girl who just got new boyfriend and wouldn't shut up, just... gushing with happiness. Damm it, what would she be like when she finally did hookup with someone. She hated have to play friends with her but most of all she loathed Nicole.

Tonight was not just about seducing John, but also breaking Nicole. It should have been easy since they weren't a couple. She wanted to show that innocent Nicole that her dream boy John wasn't half has perfect has she thought and, in the process, break her with Tom. She wanted Tom to fuck her silly, turn her into a slut and then dump her, all in front of John. Break them both in one go.

Problem was... it hadn't worked... and on top of it all… she was still horny.

She felt Tom's warm fingers lightly caressing down the strap of her bra and trace the outside edge of her bra, it felt nice. She knew he was enjoying the view of her tits but when did he start touching her? "Damm, he is good." She thought and quickly caught herself has she sensed her hand slowly drifting to Tom's short before bringing it back to her side.

Her **** offer to John for a threesome with Nicole almost worked. Have him fuck Nicole, with her... push Nicole off to Tom... finish with John and then dump him while Tom ruins Nicole... might have gone with that angle to start with... too late now and no idea how to stop them from leaving.

Miranda let out a sigh that Tom took as a sign to go up a notch. He traced his finger up her neck and across her jawline to her chin and tilt her face to him. Seeing the expression on her face he saw she wasn't quite there yet and so giving her a wink and he moved his hand back to her shoulder to once again run it down across the strap of her bra and start to trace the outside of the cup again. 'she's warming up to it' he thought.

Just then Sarah came into the kitchen wearing a robe and with 4 bottles in her hands.

"Ok guys! I got some sweet stuff, Chocolate and strawberry liquor, vodka and some whiskey we can mix with the ice cream in the fridge." Chirped a happy Sarah. "Miranda dear, would you serve it up please? I'm going to make sure John and Nicole leave... Don't want them sneaking a free show do we now?"

"Maybe I should go?" offered Matt.