Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 40
by
Cheesers123
What does Sarah draw?
Matt (Sarah's Sadistic Scheme)
Sarah sat side-saddle in Matt's lap, so she could get an eyeful of his bitter pout. Seeing him sulking like that gave her life, and nearly began to make up for all the nights where he had annoyed her with his constant presence. Nearly. He would have to endure a lot more than just that to pay her back for suffering through hanging out with him.
Turning her attention back to the game, she quickly sifted through the hat for a scrap of paper. What she drew from it was a perfect sign for Matt to start repaying his debt to her, and she had something big in mind for him. Before doing that, however, there was something else she needed first.
"Okay, timeout for a sec," she announced, taking the scrap of paper she had drawn out of the hat and putting it down on the arm of the chair. "That's the name I've drawn, but before I read it out, Nicole can I ask your permission for something?" She gave the petite nerd puppy dog eyes as she spoke, only to be met by an irritated frown. Apparently, the blonde haired girl still wasn't over Sarah grinding on her man.
"That would depend what you want permission for," Nicole answered coldly, her eyes dipping down to glare at Sarah's bare and voluptuous breasts, that put her modest boobs to shame.
"I just want to go grab my hairbrush, my hair's getting kinda knotty and annoying me. Can I stop touching Matt to run and go grab it?" There were sighs at the revelation of the reason for Sarah's timeout, but no one verbally complained. As much as they wanted the game to go on, she was still the party host.
". . . Fine," Nicole eventually huffed, nostrils flaring in irritation, although it wasn't clear if that was from the delay to the game or if she was still upset about Sarah's previous dare.
"Yay, thanks Nicole!" Sarah shouted, beaming at the jealous, little, nerd as she shot to her feet. "I promise I'll be quick," she added, padding quickly across the room and out the door. For the first few steps she kept that frenetic pace, but once she was halfway up the stairs, she slowed down. She wasn't actually in any rush, and she didn't really care what Nicole thought of her punctuality, she'd just put on the act so no one would have suspected she'd be up to anything untoward.
Taking the rest of the journey much more leisurely, she soon sauntered into her bedroom yet again. The last time she had been in here, Matt had been in tow, and she was reminded just how tiny his little dick was as she crossed the spot where she'd put her lips around it. "And he really thinks I want that little nub?" She thought as she crossed the room towards her bedside table.
"Dumbest nerd I've ever met," she muttered under her breath, relishing the feeling of badmouthing him after playing nice for so long. It had been stifling having to act so sweet to a person that she couldn't stand, but fortunately for her, she wouldn't have to do it for much longer.
That was the real reason she'd excused herself. Her hairbrush was going to play a vital role in one of her last deceptions, and soon after that, Matt would be out of her life for good.
Opening the top drawer of her bedside cabinet, she reached for the small, wood-handled, hairbrush that she knew was inside, only to stop when something else caught her eye.
It was her box of condoms, or her latest box of condoms, to be precise. It was a twenty pack of four different sizes, originally containing five of each size. It had been opened since, so now it contained only around half it's original number. The distribution of those that remained hinted pretty strongly at Sarah's average taste in lovers. Only one extra-large remained, two large, four medium, and all five small.
The sight of those packages of latex gave Sarah an idea, one even more mischievous than the one she had came up there with.
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Thank you for reading, I hope you enjoyed these two chapters.
Which condoms does Sarah hide?
The Afterparty
Six friends continue the party with a naughty game.
A group of friends gets closer than ever.
Updated on Jan 16, 2026
by Cheesers123
Created on Aug 28, 2014
by Cloontang1
You can customize this story. Simply enter the following details about the main characters.
- 51,520 Likes
- 19,204,953 Views
- 4,162 Favorites
- 9,747 Bookmarks
- 3,243 Chapters
- 106 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments
