Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by Tonyrolo Tonyrolo

What's next?

Maisie's Sister

Somehow, you made it through the afternoon without using your power over Maisie at all. She now thinks that business is all over and she is in the clear, no doubt. But that isn't quite the case. You were out in public, down by the river on a nice sunny day where there were lots of other people around. It wasn't exactly the prime spot to start living out your most debauched sexual fantasies. You have this power for as long as you and Maisie are both alive. There is no harm in biding your time.

Still, it was tough staying patient right now. knowing Maisie was on a date, probably doing all the things to some other guy she could instead be doing to you if it wasn't for your stupid conscience. You need something to take your mind off things, so it is quite timely that you receive a phone call from your buddy Josh, who wants to shoot the shit. Josh isn't everyone's cup of tea. Women in particular seem to find him disgusting. He has more or less made a decision not to bother getting a girlfriend and has instead become a connoisseur of some of the most depraved hardcore porn imaginable. His attitude towards women does kind of suck. But he is pretty funny, and you were both outcasts at school so naturally gravitated towards each other. Despite his flaws the friendship just stuck.

You have to confide in someone about what happened today, so you tell Josh everything. Very few people would have believed you, but he is incredibly open minded to most things so there is only one part of your story that truly shocks him.

"Dude? You did nothing? What's wrong with you?"

"We were out in public and she is my close friend. She trusted me!"

"Yeah man, but...."

Josh then takes some time to tell you in explicit detail just a few of the things he would have done to Maisie had she made the insane decision to have entrusted him with her secret instead of you. He then comes up with another plan for you.

"What about Holly? The curse affects all of 'em right? And you're not friends with her. So go and grab a piece of that!"

Holly is Maisie's sister. She is also beautiful, with pretty hazel eyes, dark hair, longer and straighter than her sisters, with bigger boobs and a curvier figure. She is a few years older than Maisie - maybe 24 now? She was actually your first crush, before Maisie started to really develop into a woman. You don't know her that well. She has always seemed pleasant enough, if a little distant. And she is very serious and career focused, unlike Maisie. The two of them do have a very close relationship though.

You have not seen her recently, though there is a photo of her posing a little awkwardly in the Petersen lounge.

Please log in to view the image

"I can't, I've already got Maisie. You can't control more than one person"

"Oh man, you are just going to have to get past this friendship thing and have your fun with her. Just command her to like it or forget about it afterwards or something"

Strangely enough, those aren't the worst couple of ideas you have heard.


The next day, all you can think about is Maisie's curse. Non stop. Running it over and over in your head , looking for scenarios where you can use it to do all the things you want to without becoming a monster in the process. Your train of thought is interrupted by the lady herself, who is calling you. That's very unusual, she nearly always texts.

"Hry Maise, what's up"

"JOSH!" she shouts down the phone at you "I told you not to tell anyone and you told FUCKING JOSH!"

"Relax Maisie! He can't do anything to you, only I can, right?"

"Yes, but Holly had been keeping the curse a secret until now because she didn't trust anyone enough to tell them which means.."

"That I was the first to find out?" you realise. This isn't sounding good,

"Yes, but since you already have me YOU DON'T FUCKING COUNT! So the first valid person to find out about Holly's curse was FUCKING JOSH!!!"

Your stomach drops. You feel like you could have legitimately ruined someone's life here.

"Josh is dumb, he will never figure that out" you tell her hopefully.

"He has ALREADY FIGURED IT OUT!" Maisie screams down the phone at you "So you had better come down here and tell your buddy to stop doing disgusting things to my sister, and to stop threatening to expose my cousins to his loser roommate!"

"How does he even know about your cousins?"

"Because, genius, HOLLY HAD TO TELL HIM!"

Okay, this is bad. Really bad. You aren't sure how you are going to talk Josh out of this, but there has to be a way. And one thing is for sure, you need to get to Maisie's place immediately.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)