Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by ErstwhileFool ErstwhileFool

Who do we follow? Kurt and Gavin? Hannah, Taylor, and Lisa? Brandon, Ashley, and Heather? Zack, Victoria, and Madison? Or Chloe?

Kurt and Gavin

Gavin followed Kurt as the blond boy made his way out onto the deck and down the stairs. Once at the bottom the older boy turned and made his way to a green door which stood behind the stairs. Unlocking the door, he opened it and went inside with Gavin still following behind.

"So," said Gavin once they were inside the storage room. "I assume you are going to make me take a cot so you can take the other bed?" He had wracked his brain trying to figure out what the other boy could have brought him along for, but this was the only thing that had come to his mind.

"Nah, you can have the other bed," Kurt replied. "My goal is to share a bed with a different girl every night we are here. I'll take a cot just for appearances, but I have no intention of using it."

This statement left Gavin confused. Sure, 3 cots and an air mattress might be a bit much to carry by oneself, but Kurt had practically **** him to come down here. "Then, why did I have to come with you?" Gavin finally asked.

"Because we needed to talk, and not in front of our roommate," was the reply. "Look, with 8 girls versus 4 guys, and one them with a girlfriend, we've got pretty great odds on this trip. At the same time, those odds also make it much easier for the girls to play prevent defense against us, and so we might need someone else to run interference. I think we should pair up to achieve our goals."

Gavin frowned. "Why me? Why should I help you sleep with my friends?"

"Simple," Kurt answered. "We ended up sharing a room, which makes it easier to coordinate, plus from what my cousin told me you don't a girlfriend, ex-girlfriend, or sister on this trip to get in the way. As for why you should help, you can't tell me you have been hanging out with all these hotties and aren't interested in at least one of them. You help me and I'll help you."

Gavin blushed a little at the thought. For sure, the girls in their friend group were all attractive, enough that Gavin was usually unable to speak when they were all together. Besides Chloe, Victoria and Lisa were the only ones he seemed to be able to talk with freely. And then there were Taylor and Hannah, his first crush and her best friend. Gavin tried to avoid Hannah during those times the older girls deigned to hang out with their siblings' friends, since she inevitably left him tongue-tied, but his long association with Taylor had slowly immunized him to the effect she had on him, and he now found he could speak with her as easily as Chloe.

"You in or out, man?" Kurt inquired. "Just let me know who you are after and I will help set you up."

"Uhh…," Gavin hedged. A brief thought of hooking up with Taylor crossed his mind, but that was an old dream. Recently, he had found his eyes wandering to Heather when their group got together. Her personality, so seemingly opposite his own, attracted him, and of course she was unquestionably one of the most attractive girls in town. But was telling that to her cousin whom he barely knew really such a good idea? "There … is?" he finally replied.

"Is it the shy redhead? Or the blonde with the great ass?" Kurt inquired. "Maybe my cousin with her big tits?"

The blush that crossed Gavin's face immediately gave away the answer.

"Ha, see, I knew you were a good choice. I can hook you up with my cousin, and you can help me get the other girls."

"I don't know," Gavin replied hesitantly.

"Just think about it, my cousin baring her huge tits just for you, maybe giving you a tit-job or going down on you. Do you really want to pass that up?"

Gavin could easily imagine the scenes Kurt was describing. At the same time, he could easily imagine his own lack of experience completely messing things up and ruining his chances with Heather forever. "But... what if I screw up?" he finally asked. "Not sure I want to take that chance."

Kurt grinned. "Ah, the virgin problem. Honestly, I doubt you should worry about it that much, but if it really bothers you, you can always start with someone else before you go after Heather. She's not going to mind. Pretty sure at least a couple of these girls are virgins, they won't know the difference if you screw up." "And will make the comparison that much better in my favor," Kurt thought to himself. While Kurt would prefer keeping all the virgins for himself, if Gavin was going to help him he would do his best to return it, and if that meant giving up one of them to give this nerd some confidence, he could live with it. Out loud though, he asked, "What do you think are our options for hooking you up with a virgin girl? Pretty sure the redhead is, but what about the others?"

Gavin was a little nervous about the direction the conversation was taking. Talking about his friends this way felt wrong to him, but the image in his head of Heather accepting him really did intrigue him. He finally replied, "Uhh… Victoria is, I know that. Probably Madison too, since Brandon chases all the boys who go after her away."

"Alright, so I guess those are your options. Who do you want to go after first, the redhead, the blonde, or the jock's sister?"

Gavin thought about it. The idea of hooking up with Chloe just felt weird, and using her a stepping stone felt wrong. On the other hand he would be more comfortable with her than the others. Victoria was cute, and he could talk with her, but he couldn't do that to Zack. As for Madison, he hadn't really paid much attention to her, since he wasn't interested in having go through Brandon. But should he really go through with this plan at all?

What does Gavin decide? Does he go with Chloe, Victoria, or Madison? Or does he back out of the plan?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)