Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by saktongmanyak saktongmanyak

Day 2...

Jingle Bell Rock

“I missed you!”

Cassie and Stella shout in unison after loud shrieks of excitement, and before going in to hug each other. Cassie just arrived back from the airport after spending a week with her mother after their holiday break in college started. She negotiated with her mom, Sylvie, that she wants to be back with you guys right after Christmas Day, to which Sylvie agreed.

After Stella and Cassie’s hug, you immediately go in for a hug of your own with your girlfriend.

“I missed you even more.” Cassie says as both of you tightly hug each other.

“HEY!” Stella reacts in fake offense, making both you and Cassie laugh.

You and Cassie give each other sweet kisses before fully breaking away from your hug. As she leaves the warmth of your body and effects of ‘Magic Touch’, Cassie realizes something different about your apartment.

“It’s freezing in here!” Cassie shouts in reaction. You look at Cassie’s outfit and realize why she would be freezing.

Please log in to view the image

“Did you not notice I’m wearing pants indoors? Indoors, Cassie! Indoors!” Stella dramatically points out.

“Why is it so cold? Is the heater broken?” Cassie asks.

“Nope. Dad’s just being a scrooge and doesn’t want to turn the heater on.” Stella jokes.

“Oh my God! I’ll pay for it! Let’s just turn it on!” Cassie suggests.

“With what money?” Stella asks her the same question you asked her yesterday.

“I’ll just be Becca’s sub for a day. I’m sure—” Cassie answers with a serious tone, but Stella immediately laughs out loud and cuts her off by making her laugh too.

“I made the same joke!” Stella tells her.

“Wait, so you’ve been freezing your buns off this entire time?” Cassie asks.

“He turns the heater on if you’re fucking him.” Stella jokes.

“HEY!” You react to your daughter’s crude joke.

“That can be arranged.” Cassie teasingly says, looking at you sultrily while biting her finger.

“It’s not my fault you girls keep wearing shorts and crop tops during winter!” You say defensively.

“You know the climate back at mom’s place! It doesn’t snow there, so I left all my winter clothes here.” Cassie explains.

“Fine. We’ll turn the heater on.” You finally concede.

Stella and Cassie proceed to jointly hug you before Cassie assures you that they’ll make it worth your while.

“Are we doing that already?” Stella asks Cassie.

“I’m already up for it if you are.” Cassie answers her, and Stella just shrugs to tell Cassie that she’s up for whatever.

“Okay, you turn the heater on, grab some eggnog, sit on the couch, and we’ll be right back.” Cassie commands you.

“Yes, Ma’am.” You answer with an amused smile, before the two girls head off into Stella’s room.


You wait patiently for your girlfriends on the couch and sipping some alcoholic eggnog as Cassie suggested, slowly feeling the heater work its magic as well as the **** from your drink spread through your body. You take your sweater off once the heat reaches a comfortable enough level and put your feet up on the couch as the girls are taking much longer than you expected.

After a few minutes, you’re snapped out of your daydream when the Smart TV turns on.

*VIDEO STARTS PLAYING*

It starts playing a clip from the movie Mean Girls. You look behind you from the couch and see Cassie and Stella wearing similar outfits, with considerably shorter skirts and exposed midriffs, as the Mean Girls in the video. Cassie and Stella don’t appreciate you ‘peeking behind the curtain’ so to speak, and gesture for you to look at the TV. You do as they say and watch as the Mean Girls discuss their positioning, and hear the footsteps of your daughter and Cassie as they time their entrance similar to when the Mean Girls hit the stage.

Cassie and Stella walk sultrily in front of the television as you continue to sit on the couch. Your girlfriends assume poses similar to the Mean Girls behind them on the TV. The music begins to play and your girlfriends copy the routine of the Mean Girls. They walk sultrily towards you, and gyrate their hips, before sexily bending their knees…

Are they not wearing underwear!?

Your girlfriends continue the routine and bend their knees again with their legs much more spread, slapping their thighs in time with the video; confirming what you thought was just a trick of your eyes. They’re definitely not wearing panties underneath their skirts. Cassie seems to notice your discovery and gives you a wink. Your girlfriends continue the routine until the video reaches the part of the movie where the music is broken up.

You think the routine is over since Stella and Cassie just remain in their poses, so you started giving them a standing ovation. Cassie walks towards you and pushes you back to sit on the couch. As soon as your butt lands on the couch, she straddles you with her back towards you.

“Show’s not over yet.” Cassie playfully tells you.

As soon as Cady from Mean Girls starts singing, Cassie and Stella sing too.

“What a bright time~, it’s the right time~, to rock the night away.” Cassie and Stella sing. Stella continues the routine, while Cassie basically gives you a lapdance on the couch as she gyrates her hips, and grinds on your crotch.

The girls continue to sing the rest of the song like this, with Cassie’s grinding helping to quickly build your erection. Until finally, the performance of the Mean Girls ends, and so does Stella’s and Cassie’s.

“Now, I want to see that standing ovation.” Cassie playfully says as she stands up while bending forward, showing you her exposed pussy. She tugs on your sweatpants, and signals you to slide them down. You lift your ass up from the couch and slide down your sweatpants, to show your girlfriends your now erect dick.

“There it is.” Cassie says naughtily. Cassie begins stroking your cock as Stella just watches while she continues the pose. “Time for part two, Stella.” Cassie tells her. Stella gets her phone from the coffee table and proceeds to play another song.

*MUSIC BEGINS TO PLAY*

Stella plays the version of Jingle Bell Rock you’re more familiar with and begins to dance again. Stella’s doing an obviously different routine, since this one is definitely way more playful, but also way more sexual, than what the Mean Girls did. Cassie isn’t too far behind as she begins to push the shaft of your dick against her pussy lips. She rubs her clit up and down your shaft in rhythm to the song.

“Do you like how your babies dance for you, Daddy?” Cassie asks you, while she rests her back on your chest and you’re both cheek to cheek.

“I love it, baby.” You answer her.

“Which dance do you like better? Stella’s…?” Cassie asks, pausing to allow you to watch Stella do the same knee bent leg spread move that exposes her pussy for you to view, before Cassie continues her question, “... or mine?” before she inserts your cock into her pussy.

You groan in pleasure as your only response.

“I take it you like my dance better?” Cassie teasingly asks you.

“Um~” You start fumbling. You want to say yes, because of course you would. You literally have your dick inside Cassie right now while she gyrates on it, and it feels amazing. You just don’t want Stella to take it the wrong way because she really is putting in a lot of effort with her dance.

“Don’t worry. You don’t need to answer. We’re not actually going to compete against each other.” Cassie tells you, right before Stella turns around to show you her backside, and bends her knees with her legs spread again, and her hands rest on her thighs. “Stella and I are a team.” Cassie adds, before she copies Stella’s pose while your dick was still inside her.

“We’re still doing the same moves.” Cassie tells you.

It seemed they timed this moment to the song as the new verse of ‘Jingle bell, jingle bell, jingle bell rock’ directed the rhythm of their twerk movement. Up when it’s ‘jingle’, down when it’sbell’, and they slap their thighs on ‘rock’. They follow that rhythm for the next few verses before shaking their ass during the flourish in the line ‘in the frosty air’.

You watch as Stella twerks in front of you while Cassie does the exact same, except with the added bonus that your cock is inside her.

Once ‘what a bright time’ hits, Stella and Cassie are moving their hips side to side as they lower their stance, but return to the pounding twerking motion when ‘to rock the night away’ hits. They repeat these movements until ‘glidin in a one horse sleigh’ passes.

They then spank their own backsides for the line ‘giddy up jingle horse’ line, and you take the initiative to rub the ass cheek Cassie spanked during ‘jingle around the clock’, only to—

Mix—’ *SPANK*

‘And a mingle—’ *SPANK*

‘In the jingu—’ *SPANK*

‘—lin feet*SPANK*

And you continue to play the rhythm with your spanks during the three ‘that’s the jingle bell’-s, until you go full on bongos on both Cassie’s ass cheeks during the flourished ‘rock’ at the end of the song. Before one hard spank for the last guitar note.

Stella couldn’t help but laugh after she turns around once the song ends, after hearing all the unchoreographed slapping sounds you did on Cassie’s asscheeks.

“Someone got into it.” Stella jokes.

“Oh, he definitely did.” Cassie says teasingly and you notice her do the pitter-patter motions with her hands like she was playing bongos. It makes her and Stella laugh a little too loud. You just don’t like the implication that she’s laughing at you and not with you. So you buck your hips to remind her that your dick is still inside her. She immediately leans back to give you a kiss on the cheek to apologize after that.

“I liked it, Daddy. Don’t worry.” Cassie assures you, before you turn towards her to give her a kiss on the lips. You taste her strawberry lip gloss before your lips part. You stare into each other's eyes afterwards, and you try to convey your hunger for her as much as she is conveying her hunger for you.

“Fuck me the way you’re going to fuck Stella, Daddy. Show her what you’re going to do to her after you’re done with me.” Cassie talks to you with a pleading voice, and you just give her a naughty smile in return before you start moving your hips from below her and start fucking her properly.

Cassie moans in pleasure as she continues to stare into your eyes while she matches your rhythm, lowering her hips when you’re raising yours; making loud slapping noises whenever your skins slap against each other. Both of you then turn to look at Stella who is rubbing herself while watching the show you and Cassie are now performing for her.

Cassie does a ‘come hither’ motion with her finger, directing Stella to come closer.

“Come to Daddy, baby.” Cassie says in a naughty tone to Stella, making you raise an eyebrow in curiosity. Stella stands in front of you and Cassie while Cassie continues to jump up and down on your dick and as you match her pace below her. Your two girlfriends are just staring at each other. Cassie places her hand on your chest and leans back a little. She looks back at you with a hunger in her eyes.

“Fuck me, Daddy. Fuck me so hard Stella feels it just by watching.” Cassie encourages you. You give her a slight nod before grabbing her hips with your hands to steady her, before you move your dick in and out of her as fast as you can. Cassie immediately moans in pleasure from the sudden pace change.

“I said come to Daddy, baby.” Cassie repeats to Stella, and Stella finally closes the gap between the two of them by straddling your knees. Their faces are inches away from each other now. They then simultaneously take their Santa hats and tops off.

“Kiss me. Talk dirty to me. Do to me what you want to do to Daddy. Tell me all the dirty things you want him to do to you.” Cassie orders Stella. Stella immediately obliges and makes out passionately with Cassie.

“Faster, Daddy. Fuck your baby faster. Your baby wants all that cum deep inside her.” Stella says naughtily. Stella then begins to plant kisses on Cassie’s neck and shoulders, and she starts to grope Cassie’s tits. Cassie is beginning to moan louder and louder with every one of your thrusts.

“Your baby’s so close, Daddy. Don’t stop.” Stella continues to say naughtily, before Cassie shouts at the top of her lungs, “YES! DON’T FUCKING STOP!”, before letting out a long groan of pleasure.

“She wants more, Daddy! Give her everything you’ve got!” Stella shouts to encourage you, and you push yourself to go as fast as you possibly can in and out of Cassie. You can feel Stella’s hands rubbing your balls, enticing you to release all your cum inside Cassie. You can also feel her fingers start to rub Cassie’s clit while you fuck her.

“OH GOD! I’M CUMMING AHH~GAIN~!” Cassie shouts as her pleasure senses overload. The sound of her cumming one more time, and her pussy just clenching tightly on your dick is all you needed, and you splurt all your cum inside Cassie.

The arm that Cassie was using to prop herself upright falters and Cassie falls back towards you. She’s breathing heavily while her body rests on your chest, and you can feel the sweat of her back on your chest… or is the sweat of your chest you feel hitting her back? You’re not entirely sure.

“Now I’m feeling hot.” Cassie says in between deep breaths. “I think we need to turn off the heater.” She says, trying to laugh, but it comes out labored from exhaustion.

“Later.” Stella immediately replies.

“I haven’t had my turn yet.”


Author's Plug: I'm doing a survey for what you guys would like to see for the New Year's part of the Special, would really appreciate your feedback. Click the link for the survey. Thanks!

Day 3...

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)