More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by DakotaDave DakotaDave

What's next?

Jason arrives.

Holly looked at herself in the mirror. The sweat pants and baggy T-shirt were about as frumpy and un-flattering an outfit as she could imagine. Her hair was up in a messy pony tail and she had taken off her makeup.

Holly looked about as plain as she could. She still was nervous. Jason had loved it when she dressed up, but he also said she looked good when she had the flu, when she was greasy-haired and puffy-faced. Holly hoped they could talk things over, end with Jason going back to Sarah and leaving her alone.

The doorbell rang. She took one more look at herself in the mirror, messed up her hair a little bit more then slipped on her fuzzy slippers and went to let Jason in.

“Holly, what the hell is going on?” Jason demanded from the hallway.

“What I told you.” Holly moved out of the doorway to let Jason enter.

“That you will do whatever I tell you, no matter what?” He clearly didn’t believe what she had told him.

“Jason, I don’t know what to say, it’s true.”

Jason walked to her kitchen counter, grabbed an apple and bit into it.

“Yeah, go ahead, help yourself.” Holly said sarcastically before she could catch herself.

“What, you offered me anything I want on the phone, but I can’t have an apple.”

“That’s not what I said. It’s a curse, you have to order me, I can’t refuse you.” Holly was a bit frustrated, Jason could be so pig-headed at times.

“Don’t play games with me Holly. You call me up on Sarah’s girl’s night and tell me you are cursed and have to do whatever I tell you to? You think I don’t see what is going on?”

“I. . . I don’t know what you are talking about.” He clearly didn’t believe her, what did he think was happening?

Jason moved close to her. “You don’t?”

His proximity, the curse. . . Holly couldn’t help it, she felt the blush creeping up her face.

“I know you haven’t dated anyone since we broke up.” He stepped into her space, put his hand on her arm, gripping her gently.

“I. . . I’ve been busy with school.” She tried to back up, stepped into the wall.

“If you are lonely, you could have just asked. Sarah would be okay with it, you know. She’s really cool like that.”

“That’s not why I called you.” Holly pushed herself back into the wall, she couldn’t get away from him.

“It isn’t?” He smirked and lets go of her arm. “You going to try and tell me you really are cursed and you decided to tell me about it now, with a random phone call, two months after we broke up?”

It did sound crazy, the curse itself was crazy and the timing even worse. It wasn't Holly's fault, Maisie **** her hand. But Jason didn’t know that. No wonder he didn’t believe her.

The realization hit her. Jason had already given her an order, it had worked. He was her master for as long as he lived, but if he didn’t believe that she was cursed. . .

“Okay, I admit it.” Holly lied. “It’s been. . . it’s been too long.” She says, her hand brushing over the lean muscles of his stomach. “I, I just don’t want to be alone right now.”

Jason smiled at her, he always had a great smile. “Good, got that out of the way. Now, does the offer still stand? You’ll do anything I want tonight?”

Holly didn’t know how else to proceed, so she nodded her submission to him.

His hands were on her in a flash, he picked her up and claimed her lips as Holly wrapped her legs around his waist. She was a bit surprised at how good it felt to be back in his arms. But he had always been a great kisser, and he was in good shape.

“Holly,” Jason said when they broke their kiss. “I want you to take my pants down, do it sexy.” He set her down and as she kneeled in front of him, he pulled out his phone.

“What are you doing?” Holly asked.

“I’m not going to cheat on Sarah, Holly, this is the arrangement.” She heard the ring of a video call.

“Hey J.” She heard a woman’s voice answer.

“Hey Sarah, I’ve got Holly here, just want to get your approval before she does anything.”

“Ooh, let me see.”

“Holly, say hi to Sarah.” Jason unwittingly commanded.

“Hi Sarah.” Holly said immediately.

“Wait, she dressed like that for a hookup?” The woman says. Holly fought back the urge to correct her, tell them that wasn’t what was happening. If she could just get through this evening. . .

“You want her to take it off?” Jason asked his girlfriend.

“Nah, I want to see her suck your dick. If she does that on camera she can fuck you.”

Holly almost choked. She wanted to watch?

“You heard her Holly, get to work, and put on a good show for Sarah.”

Damn it Jason, stop saying my name! Holly screamed internally as she pulled down his pants. She cupped her hands under Jason’s Balls and licked her lips at his phone's camera.

“Oh, damn, I like her already J.” Holly cringed at Sarah’s glee, but she continued to follow the command. She closed her eyes and licked up the length of Jason’s shaft, teasing the tip as she winked at Sarah through the phone.

“Fuck.” Sarah’s voice was heavy. “Hey girls, I need a trip to the ladies.”

“Damn, Holly, you keep this up, Sarah might want to come over and join us.” Jason said, he seemed less affected by the situation than his girlfriend.

Holly couldn’t even respond, she was too busy “putting on a show” for Sarah, moaning as she slow-fucked her face with Jason’s cock.

“You’d like that, wouldn’t you Holly, you’d fuck Sarah too if she was here right now.

Well, I would now you asshole. Holly thought. Unable to say anything with a mouth full of cock she had to settle for flipping him, and the camera, off.

“Oh god, Jason, I think I’m in love. You didn’t say she was bi.” The voice from the phone was back.

“I don’t know if she is, babe, she wasn’t like this when we dated.” It was starting to piss Holly off that Jason was paying more attention to Sarah on his phone than what she was doing for him.

“Have her take it all, J. I want to see her gag on my man’s cock.”

“You heard her, Holly.”

It wasn’t a command; Holly didn’t have to do it. But if she resisted him when he didn’t phrase it right, he might figure out what was really going on.

“Oh shit! She’s a trooper, J. No wonder you were so broken up.” Sarah gleefully cried as Holly coughed and gagged on Jason’s dick. She’d never tried to deep-throat him, their relationship was so much more vanilla than this.

“Babe, please, don’t bring that up.” Jason begged.

“Sorry, J. Oh baby I’m close, fuck her face hard J, I want to cum together.”

“Fuck, Sarah, that’s fucking hot.” Jason said as he picked up the pace, slamming the head of his raging erection into the back of her throat. She was coughing, her mouth filling with her own spit. She tried to push him back, she couldn’t stop gagging.

“Fuck yeah, Holly,” Jason yelled “take it all!”

Holly stopped pushing on his legs, she felt her throat relax, she stopped gagging and she felt his shaft slide past her tongue, into her throat. She couldn’t help but swallow, it hurt and the reflex hit again but the curse, the command had her pushing into his crotch, unwilling to let any of his shaft leave her mouth, taking every inch of him.

“Fuck J!” The voice on the phone cried, “I’m cumming.”

“Me too babe.” Jason growled. Holly felt the pulsing in his shaft, felt the warmth of his ejaculation in her throat.

He pulled out and Holly coughed, her throat sore, spit and cum dripping out of her mouth.

“You good babe?” Jason said to the phone.

“Yeah, J. Tell her she's a fucking champ. You can fuck her all you want.” Sarah’s voice was dreamy, half out of it.

There was a sound of someone in the background over the phone.

“Fuck you, frigid bitch. I’ll do what I want!” Sarah’s voice yelled over the phone. “I better go, J. the girls will be wondering what I was doing.”

“See you babe, have fun.” Jason said, then hung up the phone.

“You alright, Holly?” He said, helping her up.

“No.” Holly answered, “That fucking hurt.” Holly said as she leaned on the table, grabbed a paper towel to clean her face.

“I’m sorry, you didn’t have to do it.” Jason looked confused. Understandably so. As far as he knew, Holly was doing this because she wanted to.

“Yeah, I know. I pushed myself too far. I just need some water.” Holly said as she rested against her kitchen table, looked at the mess collected on the towel. Jason grabbed a glass from her cupboard, filled it half-full with water and brought it to her.

“Holly, you didn’t have to go that far, really.” Being the nice guy, worried he pushed too hard.

“You told me to put on a show for your girlfriend.” Holly didn’t tell him he made her do it, that she didn’t have a choice. God, she had to keep him convinced she chose that.

“Hell of a show too, Holly. That was crazy. If you ever want a three-way she’ll definitely be down.” Jason said with a smile.

Holly sighed.

“Hey, Holly, seriously,” Jason put his hand on her shoulder, the concern was obvious in his voice. “Are you okay?”

“You’re not my boyfriend.” Holly reminded him, she’d rather keep this to a quick one-night stand. Hit it and forget it already, Jason. she thought in his direction.

“Okay, okay.”

“Are we going to fuck now?” Holly asked him, wanting more than anything to get the night over with.

“If you really want to, Holly, I’m okay with stopping here, though.”

“Really?” she asked him.

“Yeah, you called me, remember.”

“But Sarah. . .”

“Look, Holly, I love Sarah, she’s awesome. But she’s also a bit above my level, if you know what I mean.” Holly understood, she and Jason had been a very vanilla couple, a far cry from what happened tonight.

“I want to keep her happy, and believe me, I’m not complaining about anything. I mean, tonight was awesome. But it doesn’t feel the same when she’s not watching. If Sarah was here, I’d be all about it, but I don’t know, it just doesn’t feel right doing it without her.”

Holly smiled. Jason was still the same guy she had dated. Maybe she had screwed up ending it like she did. Not that it mattered now, he was her master, the best thing would be to get him out of here and back to Sarah, let him enjoy his crazy bi girlfriend and let Holly be safe from the curse.

“Okay, I release you, Jason. Thanks for coming over, though.”

“No problem. Are you really okay, Holly? I know we aren’t a couple, but I still care, you know?” Jason was too nice. Annoyingly nice. Holly started to remember why she broke up with him.

“Yeah, I’m good.” She answered. Walk out the door already! She yelled inside.

“Alright, I’ll see you around, unless. . .” Jason stopped, the door open, he was almost out.

Just get out. Holly would shove him out the door if she could get away with it.

“Holly, you want me to bring Sarah over sometime?”

FUCKING FUCK YOU FUCKER! Holly screamed inside, but her mouth said, “Actually, yeah I would like that.”

BECAUSE YOU JUST COMMANDED ME TO WANT IT YOU IDIOT!

Jason smiled, that fantastic smile of his. “Cool.” He turned and walked out the door. “See you later Holly.”

Not out of the woods yet. . .

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)