In full favor of Chris’s suggestion

“Yes, YES!!! Snap that useless key in two and make me yours forever. Lock my useless dick up forever however you want, and then we can turn the remains of the key into a cock ring for you or maybe part of your wedding band, or just anything that will signify that you have that part of me,” James moaned desperately, convinced of his cock’s place in this pretty little cage permanently while imagining the wedding and all the thing he wanted Chris to do to him with his soon to be permanent cage.

“I LOVE YOU!” Chris and James yelled together, but the snap of the key in James’s Chastity cage was even louder and drove the two over the brink of orgasm together this time, while Chris imagined what he’d use the broken and spare key for, thinking up what would normally be a pipe dream, while cupping his lover’s caged dick.

Chris’s voluminous seed filled James bowels again, while James’s seed violently shot out of the cage into Chris’s hand some of it spilling due to the quantity with his ass milking the last of Chis’s seed.

“That was hot. Too bad you can only break a key in a cage once,” James said winded from exhaustion while still clamping down on Chris’s cock.

“I’m sure we can find something else as exhilarating,” Chris said still slowly pistoning his cock as he brought his palm filled with James’s seed infront of their faces and seductively licked his hand clean while James watched getting aroused again especially as he saw the remainder of the key slowly revealing itself as Chris ate his cum cementing what they had done in his mind.

“That was also hot but not in the same vein,” James said but the exhaustion was quickly catching up to them as they moved further into bed dragging Chris with them.

“It was; it was also delicious. Maybe I should drink it straight from the source as I press the magic button back here that makes so much come out,” Chris said playfully as he got into the big spoon position and pushed his slowly softening cock into James’s prostate lightly.

“Good night,” James and Chris said to each other as they drifted off to sleep, spooning each other with Chris cupping James’s now permanent cage with his hand, the remainder of the keys still in the same hand while his other rested on James’s pec.

The Jinn’s magic was coming back into play now that no one’s free will was going to be permanently affected, and it began altering things according to Chris’s whims, excited for what was to come itself. First, it made the key remaining in the chastity cage warp and change beyond a mere break, making any attempt to remove it impossible as it fused the lock, cage, and ring into one, transferring the excess material for the use of Chris’s memento. Then it made the cage change to be perfect for permanent wear and indestructible while making its wearer even more disposed to bottoming by heightening the prostate and anal nerves’ pleasure response while keeping James’s erection fully contained and the cage’s base firmly against his body.

Done with the cage, it was obligated to make Chris’s ‘pipe’ dream come true, and it was looking forward to it. The Jinn took the waste material and made a cock ring that he would permanently wear that could control his partner’s cage’s size, shape, design, color, additional effect, and even superimpose his cock over James’s cage to make “go fuck yourself” something he could really do with consent. Finished with the design, the Jinn transferred it onto Chris’s cock and balls before permanently affixing it there with magic while granting Chris a bit more size as thanks for the idea. With the installation done, the Jinn instilled the information of their new permanent wear into their minds, getting an expected response of their tools twitching with arousal.