I just want some new bodies

Dawn expected that after the talking-to Morgana received, she wouldn’t have to deal with any bad dreams when she went to sleep.

She was quite wrong.

Oh, it wasn’t like she had another fantasy dream where she was **** to use the boobs she didn’t have to get Nick off, no, at least that wasn’t the problem. No, in Dawn’s dream, she was struggling to breathe. She was being buried in a giant marshmallow. She struggled and tried to move, but it was pushing into her from all sides, and even her face was submerged.

Can’t… can’t breathe… need… oxygen…! Dawn was trying her hardest. Most people thought that the root cause of suffocation was the lungs. That your lungs wouldn’t receive the oxygen they needed, and you would die. But what was really at risk was the brain. If oxygen couldn’t get to the brain, then serious damage might be done. That was almost a scarier thought than dying.

She was about to black out… and then she wasn’t. She snapped awake instead, and realized she was still being suffocated.

“Mmgh…” Marley had her arms wrapped tightly around Dawn, using the small cat girl as a body pillow. Her huge breasts were mashed into Dawn’s face, and that was what was cutting off her oxygen.

Dawn tried to squirm free, only to feel another set of boobs pushing into her from behind. Carly and Marley were double-teaming her, and at this rate she’d be in big trouble!

Drowning in boobs might be one of Nick’s fantasies, but it sure as hell isn’t mine! Dawn squirmed, trying to pull herself free, and then had a brilliant idea. Those always seemed to come when you’re on ****’s door.

She reached up and began tweaking Marley’s nipples. Good thing both sisters slept naked.

“Hyaahn!” Marley squeaked, turning red and squirming under Dawn’s fingers. She pulled Dawn even tighter into her chest, but the more Dawn twisted and pulled the more she came, and the more she came the more her grip weakened.

“HAH! HAH! You… fucking bitches…” Dawn rasped, finally freeing herself from marshmallow hell. Oxygen, sweet oxygen, she’d never wanted it more! Air flowed into her lungs and she could finally think straight again. She just laid flat on her mattress, letting the strength return to her body.

A few minutes later both girls woke up to one very pissed-off kitten.

“Good morning, Dawn!” Carly greeted her with a smile. “Did you… sleep…”

Her voice trailed off as she registered the ominous aura emanating from the small girl standing over the bed.

“…Dawn?” Marley squeaked.

Dawn flicked Marley on the forehead. Then she walked around the bed and flicked Carly on the forehead for good measure.

“Sleeping with Gina was better than you two!” She chastised them. “You two nearly smothered me in my sleep!”

The twins shared guilty look.

“Sorry Dawn…” They apologized in unison.

“I-I guess I was so excited to sleep with you that I got all cuddly,” Carly said somberly.

“I felt lonely last night,” Marley glumly nodded in agreement. “It just sorta… happened.”

Dawn’s tail drooped. Great, now she was feeling bad.

“Well… it’s fine,” she muttered. “No harm done. But… hands to yourselves, okay? I’m not your… cuddle kitten!”

The twins sniggered with glee and Dawn’s face turned red. She stormed into the bathroom and took an angry shower while the naked girls got ready for their day.

“You still feel lonely?” Carly turned to her sister, surprised to hear her say that.

Marley nodded. “Yeah…” She held her hand over her heart. “I don’t really know why… I guess it’s left over from when I was… Mimi.”

Mimi. The word hung over their heads like a rain cloud.

“We didn’t really ever talk about it,” Carly said quietly. “You know… about how you’re not really my sister?”

“I am your sister,” Marley said adamantly. “I remember mom and dad raising us clear as day.”

“I know, I know, and I do, too,” Carly agreed. “But… they didn’t. You know that, right? In reality, I was an only child.”

Marley didn’t say anything. She just nodded.

“Look, that doesn’t mean you aren’t my sister!” Carly quickly scooted over to comfort the other girl. “Of course you’re my sister, and I love you!”

“But… I’m Mimi, too,” Marley said. “I have her memories in there. It’s only a week’s worth, but…”

Her frown deepened. Those memories felt so much more precious and real.

“Can I ask you something?” Carly was dreading the answer to her question, but she needed to know. She needed to put aside the doubt budding in her heart. Until she did, she might not ever be able to truly accept Marley as her sister.

Marley nodded.

“Are you Mimi? I know you’re Marley, but are you still… Mimi, too?”

Marley stared at her for a long time, mulling that over.

Finally, she responded with “Can I ask you something back?”

“Uh… what?” Carly noticed a playful gleam in her sister’s eye, and she squirmed a little.

“Remember when we were in fourth grade, and you kissed Danny Moss after I told you I had a crush on him, and I said I didn’t want to be your twin anymore?”

Carly winced. “You aren’t still holding that against me, are you? I told you, he kissed me!”

“Not my point. I said I didn’t want to be your twin, so you cut your hair and asked mom if you could start calling yourself Jennifer, remember?”

“Oh, god, don’t remind me,” Carly groaned. “It took forever for my hair to grow back after that!”

Marley rolled her eyes and laughed. “Well, you COULD have waited until the weekend and gotten mom to take you to the barber, but no, you were so sure you could do it yourself.”

“Gyaah, this is why I hate having a sister!” Carly wailed, burying her face in her hands. “Stop digging up my shameful past!”

“It’s okay, I’m just trying to make a point.” Marley placed her hand on her sister’s shoulder. “You changed back after I forgave you, remember? It was only a week or so, but you went back to being Carly instead of Jennifer.”

Carly looked up at her sister, not sure what her point was.

“Yeah?”

“So it would be fair to say you’re not Jennifer anymore, right? And for that matter, you aren’t the Carly who was a fourth grader. You’re a new Carly. Heck, you’re not the Carly you were yesterday, either, are you?”

“I… I guess not?”

“Well, it’s the same for me,” Marley said, a whimsical yet sad smile crossing her lips. “I’m not the me I was when I was Mimi. I’m Marley. And I’m not the Marley of yesterday, either, or Marley when I was in fourth grade, or whatever other fake memories Sylvia put in my head. I’m… just me. Changing a little every day.”

She shrugged awkwardly. “That’s the best answer I can give, I guess.”

Carly looked at her in awe. “Aww, when did my baby sister get so smart!?” She cooed, pulling Marley in for a hug.

“We’re the same age!” Marley laughed, pushing her away. The two girls rolled around on the bed together.

“Man, if Nick could see you now.”

They looked up to see Dawn walk in with a towel wrapped around her petite frame and a smug look on her face.

“Hey, Dawn.” Marley got off her sister and walked over with a contrite smile on her face. She held out her arms. “Hug and make up?”

Dawn sighed. “Sure, why not?” She let Marley hug her again, even though she knew it would just end with the life being squeezed out of her.

Some people would kill for their faces to be at boob height, but for Dawn it was a walking reminder of her lack of assets.

“You feel better after that shower?” Carly went to go find her costume for today. It wasn’t of a character she recognized. She could see pieces of a maid outfit, and a cat ear headband.

“Yeah,” Dawn managed to answer when Marley finally let her go. “Sorry I took things out on you, by the way.”

Carly waved her hand dismissively as she tried on her new clothes. “Don’t worry about it. And hey, anyway, you’re sleeping with Nick tonight, right?”

Dawn gasped. She’d completely forgotten. “That’s right!”

“Well, I guess that means we can assume you don’t have anything planned,” Carly snickered.

“That’s a shame… you had a really good thing going with him last round…” Marley sighed. “Getting to spend the whole day with Nick… must have been romantic.”

Carly and Dawn shared a look.

“Wait, Marley… do you like Nick?” Carly asked, genuinely surprised.

Marley turned red. “N-No!” She exclaimed.

“Oh, so you’re saying you just cuddled with him that last night when you were Mimi, eh?” Carly smirked, stroking her chin thoughtfully. “Nothing else?”

“Um…”

“We never did figure out what Mimi did to get all those points,” Dawn said, narrowing her eyes. Her tail wagged from side to side like she was excited.

“I don’t like him!” Marley wailed. “Mimi was… I was just curious, because I didn’t know about boys or sex! But now that I doI would never do something like that! He’s… I mean, I know you have feelings for him, so…”

She was starting to babble.

“Hey, come on, you really think I care about that?” Carly laughed. “It’s not like we’re married! I don’t say anything when he sleeps with Gina or Dakota, or even Dawn here, you think I’m gonna care that my sister wants a taste?”

Marley’s eyes bulged and her face turned red as she considered the possibilities.

“B-But… no! It’s still wrong! I don’t like him and I never did!”

Dawn was no scholar on the human condition, but even she could see how obvious Marley’s feelings were.

“L-Let’s just go eat!” Marley hastily rushed her sister out of the bedroom as Dawn got changed and followed after them.

The truth was, even without her past as Mimi, Marley had developed a crush on Nick naturally. But she’d always kept those feelings locked away in her heart, not wanting to make a move on the man Carly had feelings for. Then when Carly got pregnant, there were more important things than love, and Marley had let her crush on Nick silently disappear.

But in her new memories, she’d been brought onto the show as her sister’s supporter, and those feelings had flared back up. She remembered doing all sorts of things with Nick as Mimi, but as Marley? How could she?

Whatever she tried, Nick would just compare the two of them. And she was more than just a twin, damn it!

When they arrived at the banquet hall, Marley looked around hoping that Kim was here. She’d missed her chance to talk to the other girl, to let her know that there were no hard feelings. Making amends with the tomboy version of her didn’t quite feel the same. But Kim and Morgana weren’t here yet, and Dakota was probably off enjoying her morning with Nick. It was just the other two teams at the moment.

To her relief, Kim came by a few minutes later, looking oddly refreshed but also very embarrassed. She wasn’t the only one here who was embarrassed, though. Mary looked like she’d left this plain of reality entirely. Her boobs were smaller, which was good, but her eyes were sunken-in and hollow, and she refused to look at Gina. Marley felt a tug telling her to go comfort the farm girl who had done so much for her back when she was Mimi, but working things out with Kim took priority.

“Everyone, I have an announcement to make.” Kim called everyone to attention before Marley could even get halfway across the room to her. The schoolgirl turned to Morgana, who held her head up with pride. “Last night, you’ll notice that you didn’t get any dreams about doing stuff with Nick.”

“Speak for yourself,” Gina called, earning her an eye roll.

“I mean, compelled dreams due to Morgana’s transformation,” Kim clarified, gesturing to the goth. “The reason for that is because Morgana upgraded her transformation.”

“Upgraded how?” Dani narrowed her eyes suspiciously.

“I-I can now… choose who gets my fantasies,” Morgana said, gulping a little and baulking at Dani’s fierce glare. “So… don’t worry. I have to write every night, but… if I don’t put your name next to it, you won’t get the fantasy.”

“Okay, but if you DO write our names, then we WILL get a fantasy?” Gina clarified, already smiling with anticipation.

“…Yes, that’s right,” Morgana nodded. “And… I feel very bad about the stuff I made you guys go through, sorry.”

Dani sighed. “…Whatever. It’s fine,” she grumbled. “No hard feelings I guess.”

Finally, Marley could go talk to Kim! She practically had to drag Carly over to her, but she could finally- and Kim was gone.

Not gone in the sense that she’d been popped over to the lingerie store, just that she’d gone over to Dani to speak with her, first.

Marley sighed. How hard was it to talk to one girl?

“Dani, can I talk to you for a second?” Kim asked the tomboy.

Dani’s lips pinched into a thin smirk. “That depends. You gonna go sell some underwear in the middle of it again?”

Kim blushed with shame and shook her head. “I just… I wanted to apologize.”

“…Huh? For what?” Dani blinked, not sure what she meant. Kim’s blush deepened.

“You know, for… what I said yesterday. Because of my transformation, I said some really insensitive stuff to you, making it seem like it wasn’t a big deal that you were **** to give Nick a blowjob. I’m… really sorry I said that stuff.”

Dani blinked. “Uh… dude, it’s okay. I didn’t even care.”

“…You didn’t? But… wait, if you’re trying to let me off the hook because that was a transformation, don’t,” Kim protested. “I really did feel that way! I never would have said it out loud directly normally, but that’s how I felt!”

Dani waved her hand. “Who cares? Look, stuff like that doesn’t bother me. The dream itself? Yeah, that pissed me off. But you’re not wrong, compared to having sex with him, a blowjob isn’t as big of a deal.” She shivered at the thought. Then her face hardened.

“But you did have it a little easier since you actually wanted to have sex with him.”

Kim winced. “I-I know, and that’s why-”

“But still. We’re good.” Dani clapped her on the shoulder and smiled. “Don’t worry about it! Just try not to do it again, okay?”

Kim couldn’t believe they were good. “W-Wait!” She stopped Dani before the other girl could slip away. “Actually…”

“Hmm?”

“Can you… help me with something?” Kim asked shyly.

“Help you with what?” Dani narrowed her eyes. “If you’re gonna try to rope me into selling lingerie or taking part in one of those strip shows-”

“No, it’s nothing like that!” Kim frantically shook her head. “I was wondering, if you could help me… get in shape.”

Dani’s face lit up. “Wait, for real?”

Kim nodded. “Yeah, I, uh… I keep thinking about how I looked, back when I was… you know. And yeah, I’ve gone on a nature walk or two, but when it comes to being in actual good shape…”

“What, no part-time job at a gym as a personal trainer?” Dani joked, lightly punching Kim in the arm. But “light” from Dani still stung quite a bit.

Kim rubbed her arm and sighed. “No, I just worked the reception desk… look, can you help me? I really want to trim off some of this flab.”

She lifted her blouse slightly to show off some of her chub. Dani gave her an appraising eye.

“Well, Kim, I gotta say, you’re not really in that bad of shape. But if you want me to help, I’ll be happy to! Let’s just get you a nice, protein-filled breakfast, and we can work out together!”

Dani was thrilled to finally have a work-out buddy. She would have forgiven Kim for a double homicide.

After stuffing Kim to bursting with healthy food, Dani was ready to get started. But there was something she wanted to do first.

Dakota was the last one to come down for breakfast. She almost seemed to glide in, her face sunny with contentment. Kim figured she must have had a pretty good night with Nick.

Then she remembered her own “night” with Nick, where she helped Morgana service him through her fantasy, and turned red.

They stopped her in the hall, not wanting to do this in front of everybody.

“Hey, Dakota, can you do me a huge favor?” Dani approached her fellow tomboy looking more resolute than Kim had ever seen her.

Dakota smirked. “I was wondering when you were going to ask. I almost felt like a wallflower at the ball, who nobody wanted to dance with.”

“Will you do it, though?” Dani asked.

Dakota tapped her chin thoughtfully. “Well… I could…”

“Do what?” Kim had no idea where she was going with this.

“…Sure, why not?” Dakota’s lips curled up in a smile, and before either woman could react she crossed the short distance between herself and Dani and kissed her like their lives depended on it.

“Unghf!” Dani clearly wasn’t expecting her to be so fast, or so forward. And Kim was just shocked in general.

“What? What?!” She asked, looking at the two of them and being bathed in second-hand embarrassment.

After about a minute Dakota pulled away, grinning and wiping her lips. Kim thought she could see them flash for a second.

But that didn’t compare to the change in front of her.

Dani’s body began to grow. And shrink. It depended how you looked at it. She grew taller and taller, till she passed six feet in height, and other parts of her hardened and grew bulkier. At the same time, other parts of her body, her breasts, hips, and ass, shrank and tightened up. Most of all, though, her hair retracted, crawling back into her scalp until it reached a length more suited for a boy.

“Aaaaah…” A gasp escaped the transformed woman’s lips that sounded almost orgasmic.

Kim couldn’t believe her eyes. Dani had gotten her original body back! Of course, her clothes didn’t quite fit her anymore. The sleeves of her off-shoulder top now taut against her muscular arms while the rest remained loose, cupping breasts that were much smaller, and her jean skirt was simultaneously slipping down her waist while bearing her toned thighs through their slit.

Most of all, she was happy. She looked honestly happy.

“I got my muscles back!” She cheered, punching the air.

“I hope you enjoy them while they last,” Dakota chuckled, strolling away. She ran her fingers across her lips. Kim noted as the dark-haired girl left that she hadn’t absorbed Dani’s transformation into herself.

Meanwhile, down the hall, Marley was trying to convince Carly and Dawn to come with her.

“Please?” She begged. “I can’t go anywhere without you, sis! I want to go to the garden today! They’ve got so many interesting plants there! Please?”

Carly sighed. “Okay, sure, if that’s what you want!” Marley would turn into a puddle of slime if Carly ever got too far away from her. Knowing that made the cosplayer more willing to listen to her twin’s requests.

“Do I really have to come, though?” Dawn asked.

“Yes! Please!” Marley nodded adamantly. “I can tell you all about the plants! Think of it as my way of making it up to you that I almost suffocated you!”

Dawn sighed. That sounded like a pretty miserable apology to anyone else… but Dawn was fine with a lesson or two. She liked learning, after all.

And she still felt bad about what had happened to Mimi. She could at least try and have a nice day with her.

Dakota had other plans. She sauntered over to the three of them with a gleam in her eye.

“Dawn, I believe tonight is your night with Nick, isn’t that right?” She cooed.

“…Yeah, why?” Dawn asked, cautious of the other woman’s intentions.

“I was wondering if you might be interested in something that could make the night more… enjoyable for you both?” Dakota mused.

“Well, what did you have in mind?” In spite of her nonchalance, Dawn’s tail flicked behind her, showing how eager she was. Her twitching ears did the same.

“How about I show you?”

Before Dawn could get a word in, Dakota leaned down and pressed her lips against hers. The kiss lasted for a minute as Dawn struggled to breathe again, before Dakota finally pulled back.

Then Dawn started to change.