He removed the words female and private.

Thinking the App would understand his preferred partner, he tried removing the word female from his wish. He was surprised that it was still too long, so he removed the word private as well on the next attempt, and that was all it took to get the wish granted with the genie’s eyes mischievously blinking on and off like a wink.

As soon as he finished saying his wish, he felt an immensely pleasurable and tight slickness covering his still flaccid shaft that he had never felt before that he assumed was what a vagina felt like. As he enjoyed the new feeling, the world flashed white and emitted a deafening sound as it changed, temporarily blinding and deafening him as he felt a slight headache. He closed his eyes in response to the pain before feeling himself lying on his back on top of a soft mattress. The excitement and anticipation of what’s to come overwhelmed the fear he felt from the side effects of the wish-changing reality.

“There, you’re all ready. I promise you’ll love this,” James heard a faint voice say with his recovering hearing, but he felt something was off about it.

After hearing the voice, he felt a warm and slick substance dribble onto his crotch that he thought was lube, but oddly he didn’t feel it reach his cock before it traveled down his groin and into his crack. Soon after it reached his crack, he felt a thick finger begin to play with the lube and tease his entrance before sliding into his ass. The entire time, he could barely hold in his moans from how good it felt while he was confused about what was happening. Shouldn’t he be fucking his dream girl right now, with them both loving every second of it? Why was she playing with his ass? He asked himself as he recovered.

James was still slightly blinded by the light and couldn’t see clearly, but he could make out the outline of a large person kneeling between his legs, and by now, he had recovered his hearing as the other person spoke again.

“Looks like you can already take a second finger, babe. Told you that you were meant to bottom. You’re already leaking like a faucet from me just fingering you,” the Man said as he inserted a second finger in James’ asshole and pressed down hard on something inside you, causing you to moan out loud, losing his care that it wasn’t a woman he was fucking.

That Man, James thought, wait, that’s Chris, my boyfriend of six years, as James thinks that two sets of memories appeared in his head, one from old James, a thirty-year-old who was poor, out of shape, and always wanted to get with a woman but had never even gotten a girlfriend and another of New James who was twenty-four-years-old that through the luck of winning the lottery and hard work became rich, and regularly worked out giving them a much better body, in their teens they got a girlfriend that made them realize they were not attracted to girls. Instead, they were attracted to guys, and with the winnings from the lottery, they had purchased a mansion with Chris that they just finished moving into today. They were celebrating by having sex for the first time after talking about what they wanted for so long. As the two memories settled into place inside James, Chris added a third finger to James’ ass, taming both sets of memories through the pleasure they felt from the body and excitement of their body as James’ cock strained against the tight cock cage they had asked to have put on as the memories merged.

“Looks like you’re ready to take my cock now,” Chris said as they finished playing with James’ ass noticing the continuous stream of pre from the cage.

Without any hesitation, Chris replaced his fingers with his cock, straining the virgin hole with pure pleasure.

“Fuck me!” James cried out, and Chris responded by burying his cock in James’ ass, slamming into James’ prostate as the two no longer spoke, devolving into moans and pants as the two repeatedly bucked into each other for hours, neither getting tired of just that. Eventually, Chris cummed hard straight into James’ prostate, the extra pressure triggering James’ orgasm as well despite his cage and lack of stimulation to his cock.

“See total … Bottom,” Chris muttered exhaustedly as they collapsed on top of James, his cock still twitching in James' ass before falling asleep, with James following suit.