Gavin has a hard choice to make

While still kissing a girl’s soft lips for the first time, Taylor opened up her right eye and saw it was Gavin fondling her ass, which almost made her giggle, he really had stepped up his confidence game. That gave the older girl an idea to push him even further. She barely spared a thought about everything else when she briefly broke the kiss with Hannah to address him.

“Gavin, truth or dare?” she whispered.

His hazel eyes were almost burning as he stared at her. “Dare,” he knew Taylor wouldn’t hurt him.

Her blue eyes slightly lowered to his crotch as she shoved two fingers into Hannah’s mouth to keep her occupied. “Free up your penis.”

What the hell?! was the first question that crossed his mind, but then Gavin took a deep breath. When he had a hand on Taylor’s ass and another on Heather’s tit, he figured they were well past the point of being shy around each other. With the hand that was caressing his friend’s older sister’s ass, he hooked his fingers on the waistband of his shorts and pulled it down, baring his rampant cock to his best friend’s girlfriend as Taylor smiled and went back to kissing Hannah.

Heather’s eyes almost bugged out of her skull at the sight of the first dick other than Zack’s that she saw ever since she began dating him. Upon first inspection, Zack was a bit longer, but she estimated Gavin’s to be a little thicker, especially the helmet. I shouldn’t be looking at it, she thought, but the sight of it coupled with the sensation of Gavin and Hannah’s hands on her breasts made the busty brunette even hotter, her pussy more than a little wet by now.

Gavin stared into Heather’s eyes, his cock twitching as they panted and he gulped. Aside from some liberties they took, such as Zack taking off Hannah’s top and himself feeling up Taylor’s ass, the game seemed to be locked and moved by the dares, he thought as his thumb and forefinger pinched his friend’s girlfriend’s left nipple, causing her to moan. He looked down at his throbbing, needy and unattended cock, then into Heather’s eyes again, and lastly, at Taylor’s tongue twirling around Hannah’s, wondering if he dared to speak out loud the dare that just flashed through his head.