Fourfold Plan

If you're reading this from Notifications, this was uploaded earlier than the previous chapter by mistake. Please read the previous chapter first. Thank you.

“Holy shit, Cass. You just made my argument for me!” Stella reacts.

“Baby, I can be a father at any age. If I could do it at 17, I could definitely do it when I’m 40.” You point out. “Besides, so what if I’m old enough to be our child’s grandfather? If I literally get Stella pregnant, I AM the kid’s grandfather… Oh God.” you continue, but you instantly realize how fucked up that sentence was and cringe at the thought.

Stella and Cassie chuckle at the idea of you finding that disgusting though, as you’re probably the only one left in the world that thinks that that’s disgusting for you specifically.

“What I’m saying is… we’re all on the same page on the ‘having children’ part. Just not the ‘when’.” You clarify. “So here’s my proposal. Stella, you can stop taking birth control.” You tell her to Stella and Cassie’s shock.

“WHAT!?”, “For real!?” Cassie and Stella react, respectively.

“If all you’re after is the thrill, then I will accommodate it for now. If it happens, it happens. We’ll address it when the time comes. Magically or otherwise, or maybe not address it at all and let it happen.” You start saying and the shock and fear in Cassie’s face is not lost on you.

“I completely disagree with that!” Cassie shouts, and it seems Stella knows the reason why as she starts taking Cassie’s side on it.

“Wait, as much as I love the idea you’re willing to compromise on that; Cassie and I talked about it and it’s not a risk I’m willing to take anymore if she has anxiety of being left behind if I get pregnant.” Stella tells you. You look at the clock and realize what time it is, and you point it out to Stella.

“I’ll talk to Cassie about it and see if we can find a compromise. You should get changed for your run and practice later so you can both stick to your schedules. We’ll tell you what we agree on afterwards.” You tell her, and she looks at the clock as well and decides that that’s not a bad idea. Stella gives you a peck on the cheek before going to her room.

You wait for Stella to close her bedroom door before Cassie breaks the silence between the two of you.

“You’re up to something.” Cassie states, and she would be correct.

“Yes. I want to ask if you’re willing to lie to Stella for the sake of compromising to allow what she wants?” You ask her.

“I’d hate lying to my best friend, and I’m pretty sure you hate that too. What’s the lie? I’m assuming it’s not a harmful one if you’re considering it.” Cassie asks you.

“There’s a trait here that’ll keep me infertile if I buy it. No risk of pregnancy for any of you. She gets the risk she’s looking for—” You explain to her, and Cassie immediately gets where you’re going.

“As long as we don’t tell her that you have that specific trait. A lie of omission.” Cassie finishes for you, and you nod that she understood perfectly.

“Would you be willing to do that?” You ask. Cassie thinks about it, considering the possible consequences of agreeing with your plan.

“Stella’s not stupid. She’s going to have questions eventually about why she’s not getting pregnant despite you cumming inside her all the time.” Cassie points out.

“I know. The idea is that I won’t cum inside her all the time. Unless she really forces it out of me.” You answer her.

“I bet she’d love that. The more accidental looking the better, if I get her kink right.” Cassie points out. “I’m game to do it. Tanya has to agree to it too though. Otherwise, I don’t think we push through with it. That goes for Brooke and Viv eventually too, but I guess we’ll get there when we get there, right?” Cassie answers.

“No. If we tell all of them, then we’re all lying to Stella. I don’t want to put them in that predicament. This stays between you and me, Cassie. I remember we agreed that we only do the unanimous voting stuff if it affects everyone; otherwise, those involved decide it on their own. If they get angry that we made this decision ourselves, we can always argue that those were the rules at the time we made this agreement. We can face the consequences from there.” You answer her.

Cassie thinks about the implication of that. She’s probably hesitant to lie to multiple people that she’s close to, and probably will be close to if you’re going to count Brooke and Viv already. She eventually agrees though. Probably thinking the same as you that it’s better for Stella to only have the two of you hide this plan from her, instead all of your girlfriends be co-conspirators and make Stella feel singled out.

“Okay, that’s part one. Part two addresses your concern.” You start telling her. “There’s a trait here called ‘Youth and Love’—” you say before reading the trait description for her. “If I understand it correctly, as long as I keep one of you girls in love with me, I’ll age much more slowly—” You begin to explain.

“Making age literally just a number.” Cassie continues for you. Her eyes widen upon realizing how that addresses her particular concern. “That means we can wait until I’m ready!” Cassie says in excitement, and you nod, making her give you a hug and a kiss on the cheek. “That’s perfect!” Cassie reacts, not breaking the hug.

“I’m glad you think so.” you tell her, genuinely happy that she’s back to being happy. “Part three is discussing what we tell Stella. My idea is that we say you compromised as long as I bought the ‘Infertile’ trait for you, and that we’ll remove it once you’re ready to become a mother.” You explain to her, and she agrees to that proposal as well.

“Part four is us discussing—” You start before Cassie cuts you off.

“How many parts is this plan of yours?” Cassie teases.

“Almost done, I promise.” You answer, chuckling at her tease. “Anyway, we need to discuss when I’ll start buying those traits. The trait for infertility I can buy already without issue, but I’m saving up points so I can buy ‘Normalized Polyamory’. Are you willing to wait and let me age a few more days before I buy ‘Youth and Love’?” You ask her teasingly.

“Ugh! I thought part four was serious!” Cassie reacts, before kissing you on the cheek again. “Of course I’ll be fine with it.” She answers. “If you suddenly age horribly before buying it though, don’t blame me.” Cassie teases back.

“I’m willing to take that chance.” You tell her, before returning the kiss on the cheek.

“I’m guessing things turned out great?” Stella asks upon leaving her room and seeing you and Cassie hugging.

“Nah~, this is a break up hug. We’re breaking up. We’re now going to the bedroom for some break up sex. So you can practice on your own for now. I’ll catch up with you later.” Cassie teases her.

“Ha. Ha. You’re so~ funny!” Stella says, laying the sarcasm thick. “Seriously though, is everything good?” Stella asks.

“Couldn’t be better.” Cassie answers her, and you nod in agreement.

“So I could stop taking the pills then?” Stella asks. Before you can answer, Cassie does it for you; except, she gives one that’s different than what you talked about.

“I’ll answer it for you later. He said you and I get to decide if you take your pills or not, and that he doesn’t want to know the answer so it wouldn’t affect how he acts in bed. His assumption is that you’re still going to take the pills until we both finish college. Whether that will be true or not is up to our conversation later.” Cassie answers, and you don’t break and act like this is new to you and just nod, so that Stella doesn’t pick up that that wasn’t exactly what you two agreed on.

“That’s fair. I guess we do still need to talk about what could happen if I do get pregnant before graduating, and how we’ll address it without you feeling like I’m leaving you behind if we push through with it.” Stella says, and Cassie smiles at Stella’s understanding. Cassie then went on to get changed to her workout outfit.

“Shouldn’t you get changed too? Aren’t you coming with us for the morning run part?” Stella asks you.

“Oh, right.” You answer her before standing up to go to your room and get changed as well.

After getting dressed, you leave your apartment with the girls for your morning run. While locking up your apartment door, you see Maddy on the opposite side of the hall just leaving her grandparents’ apartment and making her way towards the three of you.

“Oh, are you guys going to the gym today? I thought that was on Wednesday?” Maddy asks.

“Nah. The three of us are just going on a morning run before Cassie and I go to the Sports Complex to get a few practice sets.” Stella answers her.

“Wanna come with?”

Author’s Note(s): Jay buys the Infertile Trait in between the end of this chapter and the start of the next.

Available points: 400 (-50) Friendship points / 200 Love points / 200 Lust points

The other trait that's being suggested for Cassie would be to buy the following trait for Stella(?) or one of his other girlfriends:

Cuckoldry (75 Lust Points): The person with this Trait becomes either a cuckold or a cuckquean. They enjoy and derive pleasure from watching their partner have sexual relationships with another person.

*NOTE: The way I portray this trait is ONLY as the desire of a person to watch their lover having sex with someone else. Other connotations of the fetish, such as humiliation and heartbreak are not present in any way.* - Fantasy

P.S. I really wanted for this chapter to be ambiguous whether or not he buys the trait, so that the preg-risk kink could be explored some more. However, since it's in his POV, I couldn't not mention it. However, at least it will make Stella think that she's risking pregnancy when they sleep with each other now, and I can make her act more openly about it. I hope this was an acceptable compromise.