Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 26 by Cheesers123 Cheesers123

What does Sarah want to do with Matt?

Doggystyle (Sarah's sadistic scheme)

Matt's massive cock had filled her head with wonderfully dirty thoughts of fun things to try, but first and foremost on that list was something fairly simple. "You're a virgin, right?" She asked. Earlier it would have seemed like stating the obvious, but now she knew what he was packing it seemed like the alternative was a real possibility. With wide eyes, he quickly nodded his head. Those eyes had been wide and his cock had been hard pretty much constantly ever since she had stuffed a hand down his underwear.

"You know what doggystyle is though, don't ya?" She continued her questioning, grazing a long finger nail down the center of his mostly hairless chest. Once more, Matt nodded quickly, his eyes somehow becoming even wider so they completely filled the space behind his glasses. "Perfect," she purred, pushing herself off of him and ripping the blanket the rest of they way off of the both of them.

Turning her back on him, she tossed the velvet blanket over the arm of the chair, before crawling on top of the sturdy wooden coffee table. From experience, she knew that it was pretty much the perfect height to get fucked on, so long as she positioned herself face-down ass-up, which was exactly the position she wanted to be in right then.

Since she had taken her top off earlier, pretty much the only real clothes she still had on were her tiny mini-skirt and her skimpy black thong. The skirt she tugged up, showing off her bubble butt to Matt, whilst she pulled her miniscule thong to the side. Beneath it, her pretty pussy was pink and puffy with lust, drooling girlcum all over her tender thighs and practically dripping on to the table. Throwing her flowing red hair over her shoulder, she turned to look at him, or more specifically at his perfect cock, and nibbled her bottom lip seductively.

Even Matt couldn't miss a sign so obvious, and Sarah watched over her shoulder as he slowly got to his feet. It was clear from the way he moved that he was still awestruck by his crush posing like this for him, his arms and legs moved slowly as if he was in a dream. Despite his steady rate of motion, it only took a second before he was in position behind her, his fat cock sliding slowly up her left ass cheek as he stepped close to her.

An unsteady hand landed on her hip, eagerly caressing her silky skin, whilst she felt his cock slowly draw back off her ass. All she could do as she felt that hefty weight lift off her backside was grip the table and wait. She wasn't waiting long. Soon, she felt a shockingly girthy visitor between her legs, slapping against her thighs and smearing precum and her own spit all over her flat stomach.

"S-sorry," Matt whispered behind her, his cock rubbing teasingly against her tummy as he moved back to try again. After pulling back too far, his length popped free and rested between her ass cheeks instead, a meaty footlong hot dog between her fluffy white buns. "S-sorry," he muttered again, once more taking his unruly cock by the base and forcing it back between her legs, all while Sarah had to bite her knuckle to keep quiet.

She had been taken in this position countless times before, but it had never felt so intense. The size of Matt's monster cock combined with his clumsy handling of it made her feel like she was being mounted by a horny stallion. Every time his huge length slid against or overshot her tight opening, she felt the anticipation inside her grow, making her legs quiver, her breathing quicken, and her pussy drool, as her whole body begged to be penetrated.

When he hauled the unwieldly length up so that it bashed against her sensitive clit she let out a gasp of pleasure, and arched her back so much that the hard nipples of her titties bore holes into the hardwood while her ass remained raised in the air. This time, Matt slid it back against her wet slit in one long motion, rubbing her clit all the way until the thick helmet of his cock slipped up to nuzzle into her wet opening. Almost by accident, Matt had finally lined himself up with her pussy, and he had nearly worked her into a frenzy in the process.

A feeling of nervous excitement that Sarah never normally felt washed over her, as a cock like a baseball bat prodded inquisitively at her sensitive opening. With bated breath, she waited for the biggest cock she had ever seen to **** it's way inside her.

And waited.

And waited.

For what felt like an eternity, Sarah waited in the perfect position to get fucked, posing like a model for the Kama Sutra, all while the cock of her wettest dreams twitched behind her. She could tell it was still there, she could feel the very end of it's tip dipped into her hot watering hole. From the way it twitched and throbbed, almost snuffling at her pussy like a curious animal, she could tell that it wanted to fuck her too. The only problem was that, for some reason, it's owner wouldn't turn it loose.

Finally, frustration got the better of her.

"What's taking so long?" She asked, her voice sounding **** instead of angry like she had intended. She felt Matt's hand jump on her hip in surprise.

"I-I'm sorry, you're just so tight," he stuttered, "I d-don't want to hurt you!" His hesitation might have been sweet, if Sarah wasn't **** to get dicked down.

"You won't," she said.

"He might," she thought.

Matt's dick was the biggest she had ever seen, even for an "experienced" woman such as herself taking it all might prove tricky. Still, she'd never let herself be intimidated by a dick before, and she wasn't about to start now. Putting her concerns to one side, she pushed her ass back against him and wiggled her back half like a bitch in heat. Either that movement, or her simple words, were enough to push Matt into giving her what she wanted.

Steeling himself with a grunt, he pushed his dick forward into her whilst doing his best to hold her in place with his other hand. It was a good thing that one of them was trying to maintain control. Sarah had felt her critical thinking go out the window the second his fat rod began stretching her tight hole. It was like trying to **** a hot dog into a wine bottle. The wetness of her pussy and her own spit for lube on his cock were the only reasons why it was even feasible, and Sarah still found herself screwing shut her eyes and pounding her palm against the table.

A wordless whine was shoved out of her mouth between her gritted teeth, and her feet petulantly kicked the air as they hung off the edge of the table. The sensation wasn't painful, so much as it was unusual and breathtaking. In a way, it really did feel like losing her virginity all over again. Matt, of course, was literally losing his virginity, and for him it couldn't have felt better.

His crush's velvet walls embraced his dick like an old friend, and her pussy was so sopping wet that even as he **** his way deeper into it he felt no grating friction. The view was incredible too.

Sarah's bubble butt that he had always admired, whether it was displayed in yoga pants or teased in short skirts, was completely and willfully exposed before his eyes. Above that ,was the sensual pale arc of her lithe back, leading down to where her face and ample chest were pressed against the table. There, drooling on the wood, was her pretty face in perfect profile, turned to look back towards him with one eye as she panted for him.

Her breathy little moans, tender noises he had never even pictured her making in his wildest dreams, were the thing that pushed him over the edge. Their slutty siren song drove him to take her hips with both hands, and shove his throbbing boner even deeper into her twitching cunt. Sarah pushed back against him too, trying to bring her fat ass to press against his pelvis, clearly rooting for him to succeed in burying his whole cock in her even whilst he rooted her.

Grabbing her tighter, he met her eye and smiled, before nodding his head at her to show how eager he was to please.

Sarah was used to looking back over her shoulder and seeing hot studs and older men, so looking at the dweeby figure of Matt as he smiled awkwardly at her was confusing to her, but her pussy was starting to feel far too good to care. Matt could only have been a little over halfway into her, but he was already starting to touch parts of herself that she didn't even know existed.

By the time Matt's hips were pressed against her own, she was sure that his dick was colliding against her cervix, or the back wall of her womb. Wherever it was, she apparently had a g-spot there, because Matt's cock just resting against it was making her pussy tremble and her toes curl. Just letting him soak in her pussy felt better than some lovers had, she needed to feel that incredible dick in motion before she came just from ambient excitement.

"Please, fuck me daddy," she moaned over her shoulder, wiggling her butt against him again for good measure. Never had she ever thought she would sincerely say those words to Matt, but the afterparty had proved to be full of surprises.

Matt's glasses were practically steaming up as he nodded his head at her again. "Y-yes. Yes ma'am," he muttered, bracing himself on her ass with both hands as he tried his best to heave his cock out of her. The grip of her pussy was so lovingly tight that it was almost like trying to draw the sword from the stone, but he eventually managed to pry himself free by rocking his hips back and forth.

Matt only pulled halfway back before he buried himself inside her again, a whimper of pleasure escaping his own lips. Clearly, he wasn't the only one **** for this, and Sarah felt his cock throb inside her as he pulled back for another thrust. His movements were rough, uncoordinated, unskilled, and they absolutely drove her wild. He was just holding her by the hips and slamming his cock back and forth, and Sarah's pussy was already trembling so badly that she thought she might squirt.

Throwing her head back, long streaks of red hair landing across her white back, Sarah looked forward only to be greeted by a most unexpected sight. She had chosen this position for the ease of penetration it provided, she had had no idea she would be getting a show too.

Right in front of her, John was still sat back in the chair, but now Nicole was sat on top of him, her soft thighs wrapped tightly around his tree trunk sized cock as she leant back against him. The new skirt length that Sarah had **** her to adhere to was now benefitting the petite nerd, as it allowed John's dick to spear between her legs unimpeded, doubtlessly rubbing against her virgin pussy on the way past.

Between Sarah and the pair of them, Miranda knelt. All Sarah could really see of her was the back of her brown haired head, but she could tell form where her friend knelt and how she moved up and down, that she was tittyfucking John's thick rod. Whatever of his length poked through Nicole's virginial thighs was wrapped up in Miranda's squishy 36C tits, as she pumped her whole body up and down to massage every inch she could.

She didn't know if this compromise was because neither of them wanted to fuck him yet, neither of them could, or if the two girls had just bickered about who would get to fuck him first. Whatever their reasoning was, it just made Sarah more grateful that she had Matt's perfect prick all to herself. The next time Matt thrusted into her, she rewarded him for his monogamous loyalty by moaning his name and slapping her ass back against him.

"Crap Sarah, you're so tight," he grunted, his hands shifting down from her hips to grab two handfuls of her thick ass.

"Mmph, thank you daddy," Sarah moaned, toes curling as Matt bottomed out inside her again. Now that he had gotten some momentum up, his heavy balls swung around to clap against her sensitive clit at the apex of every thrust. That, combined with his cock filling her, meant her orgasm was drawing closer with every second. Laying her head on the table, she closed her eyes and got ready to enjoy it.

"I-I think I'm gonna cum," Matt suddenly warned her, his fingers tightening on her hips as he desperately tried to prolong the moment.

Sarah's eyes flew open at his words, and she whipped her head around to look at him again. "W-wait!" She shouted, moving her hips faster to try and eke out her own orgasm first. "Just a little more, please!" She cried, in a desperately erotic tone of voice that only hastened Matt's inevitable ejaculation. One of Sarah's hands went from being sprawled on the table beside her face to between her legs, hurriedly assaulting her hard clit to **** her own climax out in time.

"Oh please, oh please, ohpleaseohpleaseohplease," she mewled, frigging her clit as fast as she could. Matt's cock throbbed tellingly inside her, confirming that he was telling the truth, but to Sarah that was just another pleasant sensation. He was mostly stationary now, whilst Sarah's rocking hips provided all the motion, working that poor virgins cock like it was her favorite dildo.

"F-fuck, I-I need to pull out!" Matt shouted, like a fighter pilot who was out of his depth, but Sarah wouldn't let him.

"Just a little more, just a little more!" She repeated, slamming her pussy rapidly up and down the last inch of his enormous dick. Those quick movements kept him bashing against her g-spot from the inside, whilst her fingers worked over her clit on the outside. An incredibly intense feeling boiled in her stomach, a growing pressure like a rapidly inflating water balloon that promised that she would cum like she had never before.

"No - condom!" Matt groaned to her through gritted teeth, but Sarah didn't even acknowledge him. He could empty those huge balls right into her fertile womb for all she cared, she just had to get her full orgasm from his dick right now. As her own pussy began to convulse, Sarah felt his mammoth dick throb so hard it was like it was trying to buck her off, and she knew her partners orgasm wasn't far behind her own.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Thank you for reading, I hope you liked this chapter. The culmination of this thread about Matt and his miraculous dong is already available on my Patreon for paying members. Please join up if that interests you. The poll from my last upload has just closed, and it has decided that for my next upload we will be going back in this thread to where Sarah stuck her hand down Matt's pants, so that she can find something different.

If you want to have a say in future polls, please join my Patreon so you can vote and make your voice heard. Polls occur at least once a month.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123

Where does Matt cum?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)