Decisions, Decisions

‘Who am I fucking first?’ You silently ask yourself. ‘Good question.’

You stare at the lineup of exposed pussies in front of you and all you can think of is how much of an erotic fantasy you’re living right now… and that yes, your life is weird. Whatever issues and problems you were worrying about before the night turned into this seems such a long time ago at this moment. You know you’ll have to deal with it eventually, but with four of your girlfriends exposing themselves to you in such a way, there’s never been an easier time for you to decide that ‘that’s a problem for tomorrow’.

Your problem now is A LOT MORE FUN.

Do you pick Tanya to fuck first? She was the one who instigated the others into this orgy after all. Getting picked to be first could be a suitable reward. Not to mention, you get to reward yourself with the biggest ass you’ve ever had the pleasure of seeing too.

You caress Tanya’s ass with your hand, groping and squeezing it in giddy consideration.

“Looks like you’ve made your choice, papi.” Tanya teases the other girls, making it seem you’ve fully committed.

“Relax, girls. I haven’t chosen yet.” You assure the others.

“Well, maybe I can persuade you.” Tanya teases you this time, before she starts twerking her huge butt, causing her asscheeks to make clapping noises.

“I don’t think I can persuade you like that.” Maddy comments, just as amazed as you are at Tanya’s display, as she’s the one right next to her.

“I don’t think any of us can persuade Daddy like that.” Stella corrects Maddy from the other end of the couch, with just as much amazement in her voice.

“Mmmpppfffmpfpf.” Viv mutters something under her duct tape gag.

“Let me guess, you’d ask what’s going on but you can hear Tanya’s ass cheeks clapping.” Cassie jokes, from between Stella and Maddy, and Viv gives an excited squeal while nodding her head that confirms that was exactly what she wanted to say.

*SPANK*

“Ay!” Tanya reacts, after getting spanked on her ass.

“Dad’s really good at spanking ass, isn’t he?” Stella humorously comments. “It’s always loud. It never sounds flat.” Stella adds.

“Probably years of practice from spanking you.” Cassie jokes.

“That’s the thing, he never spanked me. So I’m not sure how he got so good.” Stella replies.

“Are you sure you want an answer to that question, baby?” You ask suggestively, getting Stella’s eyes to widen in recognition.

“Ew. Yeah. Don’t even say it.” Stella says, waving the thought from her head. “Please fuck me already so I can wash my mind clean.” Stella tells you.

You walk away from standing behind Tanya, and stand behind Stella on the other end of the couch instead. Her pussy is so perfectly level and centimeters away from your erect dick that a light breeze is enough to push you inside her. The proximity causes Stella to look at you expectantly. When you give her a smile back, it’s enough for her to give the others boastful looks.

Despite her expectations, should you fuck Stella first? Finally reward her after all the teasing that you and the others piled on her earlier? Then again, maybe you should prolong the teasing even more? Let her keep building it up inside her until she can’t wait any longer.

That’s what you ultimately decide to do, and move away from her to approach Maddy instead. Your other girlfriends can’t hold in their laughter, joking how easily Stella fumbled the bag, so to speak. You stand behind Maddy just like you did with Stella, and just the tip of your penis touching her pussy lips slightly sends shivers down her spine.

What about choosing Maddy to go first? You and her can definitely continue what you both started earlier. She definitely deserves a reward after all that effort she put into pleasuring your cock earlier.

Before you make a final decision, you glance towards Cassie, and you see the longing look on her face that’s almost unfair to the others how much it convinces you. She and Stella probably have had the most on their minds today, but there’s no denying that Cassie even surpasses your daughter in that regard. From her relationship issues with Stella, to her father’s family threatening your relationships again, and even Becca’s threat to leave — it’s easy to see that she definitely had a lot on her mind today.

Without Cassie even saying a word to entice you, she makes the choice clear.

You move away from Maddy and walk towards Cassie, your erect cock sways from side to side for a bit, after your cockhead seems to have met some resistance from Maddy’s pussy lips. Maddy lets out a groan of disappointment from you seemingly choosing not to fuck her first.

“Sorry, Maddy.” You apologize to her, not intentionally wanting to tease her like you did Stella.

“It’s okay, Jay.” Maddy assures you with an understanding smile, but you can still tell that she’s a bit disappointed. As a compromise, you decide to give her somewhat of a consolation prize. You direct your dick towards Cassie’s entrance with your left hand, letting the tip of your penis part her pussy lips, while you do the same to Maddy’s with your right. Immediately, the two girls moan out in pleasure, while the other two moan out in envy, and Viv lets out something muffled underneath her gag after hearing all four of them.

You finally penetrate Cassie, making your decision clear, and the three other girls can only watch patiently as you fuck Cassie in front of them. With how wet Cassie is already, getting into a steady rhythm doesn’t take long at all, giving you time to let your hand find a comfortable position to finger fuck Maddy at the same time.

You do this for a few minutes, before realizing that your left hand is awfully free to wander too. You instinctively reach out towards Stella’s pussy with your left hand, only to feel that someone else got there ahead of you. You look towards that direction, and confirm that Cassie’s already doing to Stella what you planned to do to her. You can only smile as Cassie’s forewarning of ‘you snooze, you lose’ plays in your head. But, since your left hand is still idle, you decide to do something else with it to reward Cassie’s naughtiness.

*PLONK*

“Oof!” Cassie grunts in pain, as your attempted spanking smacks Cassie’s ass cheek flat with the hard bottom part of your hand hitting it instead of your palm. The thud and the subsequent reaction from Cassie immediately gets a laugh out of Tanya.

“Stella jinxed it.” Tanya comments. “You’re no longer batting a hundred on perfect spankings, papi.” She explains, getting you to chuckle too.

“Fuck, my ass.” Cassie says, while rubbing the spot that you unintentionally whacked with her hand. Before you can even apologize to Cassie for hurting her, Tanya already beats you with a quip.

“Was that a request?” Tanya asks, in unison to Viv’s muffled mouthings from behind, making it clear Viv had the exact same question.

“No!” Cassie answers in panic, getting you and the others to laugh. “I mean, not right now. Or… I don’t know. Let’s just stick to ‘traditional’ for now, please.” Cassie clarifies, getting another muffled comment from Viv.

“Yeah, yeah. None of what’s happening right now is even close to ‘traditional’, but you get what I mean.” Cassie replies to what she thought Viv said.

“Well,” You interject, leaning forward so your mouth is near her ear, but also holding onto her hips with both hands and pulling your dick out of her to tease her. Cassie’s focus immediately forgets about Viv and is now directed solely at you. “Since you asked nicely.” You whisper into her ear, before leaning backwards, pulling her towards you through her hips, and thrusting your own hips in one fluid motion.

“Oh, fuck!” Cassie moans, as your full length goes inside her.

“You were a crosse-eye away from an ahegao there, Cass.” Stella jokes.

“What?” Tanya and Maddy both ask Stella in total confusion. Meanwhile you and Cassie are in a world of your own, as you start pushing Cassie’s myriad of troubles to the back of her mind with every thrust of your dick inside her.

The conversation between Stella, Tanya, and Maddy become just background noise as you place all your focus on pleasuring Cassie. Her vaginal muscles contracting, expanding, and sucking you in like it’s been **** for your cum throughout the entire day.

Eventually, the buzz from the others’ conversation is completely gone, and you realize they’re all just watching you pound Cassie vigorously. Cassie’s moans, the pounding of flesh, and the squelches of your dick sliding in and out of Cassie being the only sounds inside the room now.

Cassie goes upright and leans her back on your chest, forcing you to change the angle of your penetration, slowing you down. You initially think that this is her way of asking you for a break, but the next thing she whispers into your ear proves that assumption wrong immediately.

“Pick me up, daddy.” Cassie whispers. Without hesitation, you pick her up, hook your arms underneath her thighs, spreading her legs wide so that the point where your dick connects to her pussy is in clear view to the rest of your girlfriends on the couch. Once you’ve done this, the girls turn around from their doggy positions and sit back, watching you display Cassie like a trophy.

Once you and Cassie find your balance, you start moving your hips again, thrusting in and out of her for the rest of your girlfriends to see. Cassie leans her head back, resting her head on your shoulder, as the pleasure seems to bring her closer and closer to orgasm. The girls on the couch, unable to control themselves from the lewd sight you’re presenting them, begin to play with themselves. Stella, most noticeably rubbing her clit more vigorously than the other two.

The muffled sound of Viv muttering something forces you to turn around, Cassie’s legs almost hitting Viv in the process. Thankfully, nothing happened, and you proceed to go even bolder and move Cassie’s crotch as near as you can get it to Viv’s face. You start fucking Cassie again and Viv starts squirming in her seat, the vision in front of her becoming obvious despite the blindfold. She may not know what it looks like exactly, but you can bet her imagination is driving her wild. Viv even goes so far as sniffing the aroma of Cassie’s currently being fucked pussy, that being the only other sense available to her other than the noises coming from your crotches. Whatever aroma enters Viv's nostrils, her fidgeting goes into overdrive because of it. Making you realize that she’s not actually fidgeting, she’s trying to rub her clit on the base of the chair as much as she can.

“I’m gonna come.” Cassie warns you. You shift her weight around one more time to get yourself more comfortable for what you’re about to do next, and Cassie seems to realize your intentions too, making a request before you do — “Stella.”

“Show me to Stella.” Cassie whispers into your ear, and you have no reason not to oblige her.

You turn around one more time, and stand directly in front of Stella this time. With Stella’s legs spread so wide and her being leaned all the way back, you can stand right in between her legs. So much so that Cassie’s crotch, and your dick, are directly in front of her face.

“Go, Daddy. Make her cum.” Stella tells you, and she doesn’t need to tell you twice.

You begin pistoning in and out of Cassie, right in front of Stella, and you can hear Stella trying to match your pace with her hands rubbing her clit. Cassie digs her nails into your flesh, her grunts are a constant buzz. She’s trying to hold on as long as she can to her sanity. But the intensity is too much for her, and Cassie finally surrenders herself to pleasure.

“FUUUUUU~AAAAAH~!” Cassie moans, exhales, grunts, shouts, screams, and belts into a high not all in one breath as an outward explosion of liquid showers Stella.

The intense orgasm takes everything out of Cassie, and without energy to keep herself upright, she falls forward on top of Stella. Thankfully, you were able to catch her so that her fall was still somewhat gentle, but you can tell that Cassie’s out cold for the moment.

With Stella stuck beneath a lifeless Cassie, you look towards Tanya and Maddy to ask them a question, but you pause for a moment after seeing the looks on their faces. A mixture of awe, fear, lust… and anticipation.

You can’t help but smile knowing the night’s just beginning.

“Who’s next?”