Day 11: All Hallow's Eve [Love / Surprize]

Trembling like a leaf, Benjamin looked up at the twenty or so monster girls who admired their caught prize with hungry, **** eyes.
Each of the three races of monster girl had their own idea on how the elf should be restrained, and they weren't able to agree on any one of them.

The orcs had wanted his hands bound in mannacles, so he could be held on a chain like a leash.
The goblins had wanted him gagged and tightly wrapped from head to toe in a cocoon of rope.
The werewolves had simply wanted him locked in a small steel cage they found in the building.

In the end they settled on combining their ideas, so Benjamin was bound with mannacles behind his back, his arms tied tightly to his side with ropes and his legs and ankles bound together too, so that he would be unable to even flinch, even if he wasn't locked up in a cage for the ladies to behold him like an animal in a zoo.
"Relax, hun!" A particularly tall, curvy, busty orc with dark skin and long, wild hair oinked, "We're not gunna 'urt ya. We're gunna make ya feel really good!"
Benjamin shook his head frantically, and the orc leaned in towards him and said in his ear, "Yer gunna make us feel good too..."

All orcs laughed uproariously at this comment, but one of the goblins angrily stepped forward, "Hey!" She protested, "Just who do you mean when you say 'we'?"
"Why we of course! Us, the orcs. We all were lookin' for one of our packs to withdraw from the territory, right? So we're willin' to bite the bullet for the good of everyone, and take our lil **** 'ere to somewhere safe... and isolated."
"Slow down a bit, Pork Chops!" A ripped werewolf in a tomahawk haircut moved into the orc's space, who did not waiver, and looked her square in the eyes and growled, close enough that their boobs were infinitesimally close together, "We got our paws on him first, so if anything we should be the one to take him away!"
"Hey! Hey! Hey!" The goblin said, "Don't think you guys can push us around cause you're bigger than us! In fact everyone can tell this is a goblin-portioned husband!"
"Yeah!" Another goblin squealed, "Go pick a guy your own size!"
"Why ya lil..." One of the orcs raised her fist, but the large hand of her leader pushed it down.

"Girls, please..." the larger orc said, "we're finally makin' progress, let's not start squabblin' with each other again. There's only one way to settle this, ladies... we gotta compete for 'im, and 'oever wins gets to keep 'im as a prize."
The goblins looked between each other, towards the caged up elf, then towards the rest of the monster girls; "All right!" One of them said as she jumped excitedly with each other, "I love games!"
"You're on!" The werewolf in the tomahawk grinned as she pointed dramatically towards the orc leader, "I'm gonna enjoy pulverizing you."

While the monster girls were determining the specifics of the challenge, Benjamin couldn't help but feel the anxiety take grip in his chest.
These were all attractive women, well beyond his league even, and he never had any idea any of them would have the slightest interest in a guy like him. He had even less idea that women like these would view him like prey that needs to be conquered. He only ever learned this when he was already trapped in their grabby arms, to be made into a living pleasure toy at the mercy of their depraved lusts.
At first he had thought he could get away if he could just explain he didn't want this, so he had haplessly tried to throw off his restraints. This had only excited the girls more, who loved seeing the poor, helpless elf squirm in their bondage.

He wondered what Hailey was doing. The last thing she would have seen would be him getting pulled into the building, before the door was shut. She must be terrified considering how nice these girls had been to her, only to go completely feral when they spotted Benjamin.
Was she getting help? Or at least finding out what happened to him?

Once the preparations for the contest were done, the leader of the orcs, the leader of the werewolves and the leader of the goblins; a ditzy, green woman as short as the other goblins but with astronomically large breasts for her size, were making themselves ready.

The door to the entrance of the building opened, and who should enter at that moment but Hailey?
"Why look ‘ere, girls!" One of the orcs grunted, "If it isn't the one who ‘elped us lure our little prize ‘ere!"
Benjamin looked at her with shock and revulsion. This was the first he had heard of his friend and companion having conspired with the monster girls. Turns out it was her fault he got into this predicament to begin with. He screamed in protest, but the words were caught in his gag.
"Uh, yeah... about that." Hailey avoided eye contact with Benjamin, so as to avoid seeing the consequences of her actions while also avoiding his disappointed gaze, "I was thinking... this probably wasn't as good an idea as I first thought. I'm not the only one thinking like that, right? We're all on the same page about this, right?"
"Why, we're happier than we could've imagined!" One of the goblins clasped her hands, fawning over Benjamin as she shot him a glance, "We never saw a trace of a man for months, and all of a sudden we have one falling right on to our laps, and he happens to be everything a girl could dream of! That's like hitting the jackpot just after you learn what a slot machine is!"
"Yeah, only problem's ‘es too good, and now we cannae decide who get to keep 'im." One of the orcs said.
"Ah," Hailey cleared her throat, "So... you're gonna let him pick who he wants to stay with?"

The monster girls looked between one another, then towards Hailey... and laughed uproariously.
"Ahahaha! What!?" A werewolf said, "He didn't help catching himself, so why would he get to make the choice? That doesn't make any sense!"
"Yeah!" One of the orcs brushed away a tear, "And 'ed probably just choose 'is freedom anyway!"
"Well, isn't that sort of part of the problem?" Hailey said, "Look, I'll give back the candy you gave me. Let's just let him go, and we'll forget this whole thing ever happened. “
The monsters laughed even louder. The leader orc walked up to Hailey and patted her on the head, "Keep yer candy to yerself, lass. All the treats we need're right here." She gestured towards the cage.
"Or you could just compete for him like everyone else if you want him so bad," The leader of the werewolves crossed her arms as she grinned condescendingly at Hailey.
"No need to be mean to the lass." The orc leader said.
"It's only fair isn't it? She helped us get him, so she should get a chance to claim him too!"
"...I'll do it." Hailey earned glances from the monster girls, "I'll do it... whatever it takes to get him back, I'll do it. I'm... I'm ready for it."
"You... you sure about that?" The werewolf leader asked, "We're not gonna go easy on ya, you know?"
"Yeah..." Hailey took a deep breath, "Bring it on."
"Heh..." The werewolf leader shot her toothy smile to Hailey, "You got gumption, at least. I like that! All right... get ready, we've got another contestor!"
Hailey gulped. What has she gotten herself into now?

Accepting a challenge without even knowing what that challenge is... that's like signing a blank cheque of ass-whooping. Likely it was going to be a martial arts contest without safety gear. What the hell was an untrained Christmas elf supposed to do against natural huntresses nearly twice her size?
In that case they might as well play football with her as the ball.
Then again, it's not certain that it would be a fight, just because Hailey would suck at it.

Maybe the contest would involve having sex with Benjamin.
Oh shit!
That would be just as bad as the fight. Worse, actually since Hailey didn't actually have any intention of having her way with the guy she came to save! He’d probably have a few choice words if she ended up forcing herself on him after she reacted so strongly because of a simple kiss. Not to mention she had no experience forcing herself on a tied up guy who probably didn't find her attractive. She had some ideas, and she would be lying if she said she wasn't curious to try them out, but any confidence of outcompeting against these horny animal-women in sex was out the window.
Whatever the challenge would turn out to be, Hailey was sure this was going to be something that would push her to her physical and mental limitations... and likely she wouldn't have a chance to win anyhow.

Even so... she was not going to leave Benjamin to his devices. She was done doing that.
He deserved better than that... he deserved a chance at freedom.

Hailey, along with the muscular wolf girl in tomahawk haircut, the large orc leader, and the very busty goblin girl, took a seat at a blanket-covered table each. Four goblins pulled the blankets off the tables in a dramatic flourish, revealing two dozen pies in forms on each of the tables stacked in huge piles on top of each other.
"...the hell?" Hailey looked up at the stacks of pie on the table which towered over her.
"You know the rules!" One of the goblins said, "First one to eat every single piece of every single pie on their table is the winner, and get to go home with their very own elf hunk!"
The monster girl leaders each entered a martial arts stance getting themselves ready.
This wasn't a fight, nor was it any kind of sex contest. But somehow Hailey seemed less equipped to compete against than either of those. Between the pig women and the wolf girls, her opponents sure seemed to have proverbial appetites. Not to mention the goblin leader; although just as tall as Hailey, she was not to be underestimated. Not if she metabolized nutrients as quickly and efficiently as her massive chest would suggest.
Meanwhile Hailey was just a normal, petite christmas elf, with an elf-sized stomach.

She took a deep breath, closed her eyes... and got herself focused on the task at hand.
She might not be a pig, or a wolf... but she was gonna eat the cr... crust out of these pies.

"Everyone ready!?" The goblin judge yelled out with undue excitement, "Set.... GO!!"