Bethany, a pretty goth girl

The third door he tried opened. James let out a celebratory whoop and entered. His hands were shivering from the excitement.

Tits. Bare tits. That was what he saw when he turned around. The occupant of the door was taking a nap partially naked. Her face was obscured by a mop of messy black hair, but James recognized her identity just the same. She was Beth, a goth that he had quite the crush on.

Her blanket was tossed aside, revealing most of her slender body. Her body was all soft, modest curves, with breasts that were just big enough to fill his hands. James knew this because he was currently kneading them.

"Holy fuck, they're so soft and warm."

James especially loved her big pointy nipples and sucked on them like a baby for much longer than he cared to admit. He grabbed her breasts and rubbed his face between them until he was throughly satisfied. Beth, of course, was not just asleep but frozen in time, completely oblivious to what James was doing to her.

By this point his crotch was aching with need, so he paused his violation of the girl and stripped naked himself. His cock was throbbing with need. First he straddled her chest and squeezed it between her tits. After a few thrusts his curiosity of what a tit fuck was satisfied. Beth simply didn't have the breast size required to make it easy.

He brushed her hair out of her face and found her without makeup. James was surprised that her appearance was much cuter compared to her usual goth look.

Next, he moved on to the main dish. Beth was slim but she had some killer hips. The only scrap of clothing on her was her panties. James pulled that off her, revealing her cute slit that was surrounded by thin blonde hair. Guess he now knew her original hair color. He pried her lips open and was greeted to clean, pink folds.

James didn't think he would lose his virginity to a stunning beauty like Beth. He pressed his erection against her cunt, and with the help of some spit as lube, slowly penetrated her.

"Oh my god. It's so tight and warm."

He started out slow and worked up to a rhythm after finding a good angle. It didn't take long before he felt like cumming. He slammed his cock into her with all his might just as the first load of cum exploded from his balls. He held onto Beth's hips and pounded her until he was completely spent.

"That was amazing," he said. When he pulled out, a huge dollop of cum spilled out of her pussy.

"And now to undo my vile deed." James took out the pocket watch and rewound time for Beth. Everything he had done to her was played out in reverse until she was back in her untouched position on the bed. He didn't have to worry about knocking any girls up even if he creampied all of them.