Ahhhhh crap forgot about her.

You're stuck, you've been away for way longer than you'd intended and you don't even have any food to go back with. “Uh oh...”

You walk back in 45 minutes later with no food and Scarlett, who is still sitting in bed, looks confused. “Where'd you go?”

In your mind you have a choice, lie and try to get away with it or start being honest. Lying is just going to make everything worse in the long run so you bite the bullet and be honest.

“Well, I was washing my sheets. I... well...” For a normally confident girl you were floundering, and it was obvious.

“Rushing out of the room like that to wash your sheets aye? Sounds like a real emergency... It was one of your other girls wasn’t it?” Her voice stays even despite the accusation.

You suddenly feel very small. “Yeah, I sorta, well I just…” You aren’t sure how to explain exactly what happened in a way that doesn’t make you sound like a maniac.

She looks unimpressed, which is a lot milder of a reaction than you expected. “Sounds like you have some explaining to do. Were you just bored here with me?”

Ooft, that comment hits home and you know it might be painful but it's probably time to start being completely open. “There’s not any way to explain this in a way that doesn’t make me sound like a criminal but I may have forgotten I’d left a girl tied up, gagged and blindfolded in my room with a wand on her clit.

Her expression goes from unimpressed to shocked “How do you forget you have someone tied up in your room and how long did you leave her?”

“Umm look maybe 2-3 hours and I was just really enjoying being with you, I just kinda forgot about her.” Saying it out loud makes it sound worse than it was.

“Being cute is not going to dig you out of this. Honestly, I feel like I should be mad but for some reason, it's like I was prepared for you to stay something like this and I don't know how I feel about it. I know you were forthcoming with this I guess it's different when you're doing it in between hanging out with me.

Her statement just hangs in the air and you feel dreadful and a little confused as to why she doesn't seem angrier.

"Also why? Why leave her tied for hours that'd be ****? Why would she want that?”

You have a moment of clarity as she’s talking, this must be the effect of one of the perks you bought, the forgiveness one? You vaguely remember something and feel incredibly grateful because this conversation could've taken a very different turn otherwise.

“Yup… It would, she wanted sex and I decided I wasn’t happy with the way she was acting, soooooo I decided that she wasn’t going to get what she wanted.” You find it’s really hard to be open about it and not sound like a complete bitch.

“Wow.” Scarlett is also difficult to read and you would understand if at any point in the conversation she told you to get out but it doesn’t seem to be going that way. You’d almost describe her look as…curious.

You sit in silence, hopeful this will end positively.

She sits there for a moment like she's thinking about what you’ve said and then decides “So, tell me about her and I think you mentioned one other. I'm meeting both of them and if I decide I don't like them they're gone.”

“Yeah, you said something like that this morning. Has it been on your mind?” You aren’t sure how to start this conversation so you push it back to her.

“Honestly it’s a most of what I’ve thought about today. Weirdly, I don’t even care about Miho and I want you to put Ellen in her place but when I think about these two others that I’ve never met it’s different like I dunno, maybe it's just cause I don’t know them or the situation so tell me everything and maybe then I’ll stop thinking about it.”

Even though she’s not angry you still don’t feel great because even worse than making your girlfriend mad is making her insecure. So you sit down and try to explain.

“So, the girl this morning is named Chelsea, she’s one of the cheerleaders, she’s really nice and super passionate about cheerleading. She was being bullied a lot by another girl who I sorta helped her get rid of but then I came to realise that she seems to enjoy being dominated and now it’s a really weird situation between me and her where she tries to goad me into treating her a certain way and I’m not giving her what she wants. Especially after what happened before the dynamic is kinda strange.”

“So she wanted to be fucked and you didn’t and now she’s mad about it or she’s just mad that you left her tied up for hours, cause if it’s that I get it?”

“Uhh honestly I think she’s just mad that she didn’t get what she wanted, I may have also gone a bit overboard, I sorta took my sweaty gym panties and tied them over her nose and since her mouth was gagged she couldn’t umm…” You just bail out the whole explanation because you feel like you’re a psychopath when you say it aloud.

She just stares at you and you feel like you have to address the silence. “Say something you're making me fee-”

“Oh, my bad I'm just recovering from throwing up in my mouth! You **** your sweaty panties into a girl's nose and you're sitting here like 'Oh I wonder why she's mad?' Let me just make this very clear you ever do that to me and I'll do more than storm out.” And with that comment, you feel a lot of the tension in the room dissolve and can't help smiling a little.

“No! You get that smile off your face cause that look means you're thinking about it. Also, I almost don't want to ask but I think I have to just so I can work out how much of a sociopath I'm dating... Is leaving her tied up for a long time the worst it's gonna get for her? Like I don't even know how to ask this question.”

“Umm, I don't know how to answer it either. I'm not too mean to her but I really enjoy her suffering. Just something about her bratty attitude makes me want to push her, also I think deep down she loves it.”

“She loves it... Sure doesn't sound like it. Also if I act like a brat does that mean you're going to try to punish me? You better not try it.” The mood isn't tense like it was earlier but you decide to go a little bit lighter with the teasing than you would normally.

You decide to take a chance and hop into bed with her putting your hand on her leg. “Oh, I wouldn't dream of punishing you.”

She again looks very unimpressed and removes your hand from her leg. “I've never seen a more brazen lie in my life. If I see your sweaty panties coming my way... Anyhow, so you're a bitch to **** number one what about **** number two?”

Suddenly you wish you hadn't jumped into bed next to her as you feel like what you've done to Adelaide sounds a lot worse than what you'd done to Chelsea.

So you start like any confident person in this situation, by backpedalling. “Look before I get started on her there's context involved here. She was not a nice girl and she was bullying Chelsea so in a way me doing this was pretty much karma.”

“Oh this'll be good.” You can actually feel the eye roll as she says it.

“So early on, like that first week or so you'd gotten under my skin and I couldn't get you out of my head.”

“Uh-huh.”

“So I was laying in bed thinking of all the things I'd like to do to you and I started getting carried away and before I knew what was happening I was cumming all over my bed.”

Her snarky look has been replaced with a bright red blush as you continue. “And cause I was so wound up I didn't notice that I'd left my door slightly open. And this bitch heard me and instead of shutting the door she fucking pulled out her phone and started recording me.”

“Because I was thinking of you I was all sorts of wound up, like I came so har-”

“Flattery will get you nowhere right now, just get on with it.” She sounds serious but her face is almost as red as her hair.

You giggle a little and press on. “Anyway, she decided to later on come and show me she had this recording and that unless I wanted to be an internet star I'd have to become her ****.”

“Oh my god! What a bitch” Her earlier timidness had disappeared and you could see Scarlett getting visibly upset (which was good considering where this story was going).

“Now I wasn't having this, so we got into a bit of a fight I pretty much held her down and fucked her that night. Then I stole her phone and kicked her out. Lo and behold, she'd done this to several other girls and had made a lot of videos.”

“She fucking what!?”

You tried to put a hand up to calm her down, she stopped talking but was still visibly angry. “So naturally I watched some of the videos just to get an idea of what she was doing, then blackmailer became the blackmailee.”

You continue as Scarlett alternates between angry and curious. “So the next day we had a bit of a chat about how she'd done the wrong thing and how sorry she was.”

“Uh-huh...I'll bet”

“Yeah, maybe that bit didn't happen. I watched the videos and the main thing she talked about was how amazing her pussy was. So I figured I'd take that away. So ever since then, I've been stretching her out with bigger and bigger toys. She takes the bitch breaker with ease now and last time was the first time I could fit my whole fist inside her. She seemed like she was in a fair bit of pain though so more training is needed.”

“You what!?” Scarlett's eyes widen.

You continue getting a bit lost in your recollection“Yeah, I also fucked her while she was on the phone with her dad, that was hot. Oh and thinking about it, now my favourite was when I found her graduation dress. She picked this nice dress out for graduation and I told her to get her make-up all done and she did, wanna see?”

Scarlett says nothing but you show her the photos anyway. “before, looking all nice and pretty aaaannnnnnnddddd after.”

“Holy fuck...” You hadn't seen this picture in a while and Scarlett's reaction pretty much summed it up. It was the face of a broken woman, mascara everywhere, her formerly perfect hair a mess, matted and covered with a mixture of spit and cum, the dress completely saturated and looking atrocious. And the feature to top it off was despite all this she was smiling.

“Um, just a question...” There's a tone in Scarlett's voice that has you a little worried.

“At this start, you and I didn't get along, umm if things hadn't turned out like this would I... umm were you gonna... Could this have been me?”

She looks a little bit worried and tries to keep the sentence going. “I mean fuck this bitch right, she's getting what she deserves, but...”

You watch her start to wind herself up and you decide to but her off. “Slow down. Adelaide looks like this because she wants to. Maybe it's not what she wanted 4 months ago but now if I walk into her room she will stop whatever she's doing and beg me to fuck her with the largest dildo she can find. I don't particularly want to **** someone who isn't into it. But then again if they threaten me,”

“Hmmm and Miho last night?”

“Haha, Miho. She's in a slightly different position. Last night she played the game and she lost. If she'd played it better then I'd be the one sitting here unable to walk When you play the game you know the consequences and she knew exactly what she's getting into and I think that deep down she wanted it.”

“And what about me? would I be sitting here unable to walk?” She's back to looking pouty as she asks.

You take her hand and give her a big warm smile. “Yup, you were fucked either way. You too played the game last night and you lost. I'm so happy you tried to play though.”

She pulls her hand away looking indignant. “Bitch what!? I was just trying to set up a sexy evening with a little S&M and I asked Miho for a little advice and suddenly I'm laying in bed unable to walk what the fuck is that.”

You giggle as she starts her rant, “You missed the bit about you how changed the terms of the punishment and the bit about how you begged me to fuck your ass and how much you loved it. Don't get pouty you played the game and you loved it even though it didn't go to plan.”

She narrows her eyes at you, “Next time... Also It's been killing me, how'd you get out of the belt?”

“Oh, I'm so proud of myself I've been watching youtube videos of Lockpicking lawyer and I even ordered some of his stuff so I can open locked doors as well.”

“You learned to pick a padlock from youtube videos? How long have you been doing this?”

“Just this week, Thursday I think. If you'd put a better quality lock on it I'd have been in all sorts.”

“You learned how to pick a lock in an afternoon... Bitch fuck you, I used the lock that came with the belt. Ugh, that's so annoying. Ugh... Get off me.”

You hug her as she groans and she tries in vain to push you away but you hold on tightly and she gives up with a huff.

“Since it's all a game next fucking time I'm going to win and you are going to suffer. Fucking lock picking...”

“See I knew you'd come around. I do need to practice picking a locked door though. I still have plans for Ellen.”

You relax your hug and she stops trying to push you away. “Oh yeah one more thing, earlier you said you had plans to, uh, bring more ladies into the fold so to speak, anyone I know?”

“First you wanna play the game now you want to hear about my plans awww.” You squeeze her again and this time she doesn't even fight.

“Well... Big plans, first and most importantly, Flick. She wants it bad and you've already been in on it anyway. She's been a good girl and focusing on her studies all year, she needs some fun and I think we are the perfect two ladies so remind her what it's like to have some fun. She's just gotta ask for it... maybe beg for it depending on what mood I'm in.”

“Geez you're such a bitch sometimes I don't know how I even started liking you. But I really like harassing Flick, the way she complains makes me think she likes it. I swear she almost moaned the other day when I spanked her.”

“Haha she actually loves it and I know that for a fact, Bec told me.” You lie.

“Okay, maybe I'm kind of on board with this, she is a lot of fun to tease.” She's fighting a little smile as she admits it.

“See, next time just **** her face into your enormous rack.” You give her chest another squeeze for emphasis.

She bats your grabby hands away but can't stop a small giggle. “So what happens if I start liking this so much that I want to dominate someone without you? What happens if I become the dom?”

“Let's not get ahead of ourselves, if there comes a time when you want to then we will talk about it.” you reign her in before you get down that rabbit hole, although the idea of Scarlett dominating someone on her own is a little hot.

“That's fair, I guess that's about everything then...” She trails off giving you the impression there's still something she isn't comfortable about.

“You still sound worried, what's wrong.”

“Well, I dunno, I just... When it's you going all vigilante justice on someone I'm all for it, a big part of me wants to watch you punish Ellen, but something about this other girl has me a bit worried. It just sits differently because she wants it when everyone else... well you made them want it. You are treating her horribly and she's still coming back.”

“Yeah, I understand. Is there anything I can do to make you more comfortable here?”

“I- I want to meet her, I want to talk with her, I want to be comfortable she's not trying to steal you.”

You let out a little sigh and give her a squeezy hug “Awww, I'm yours and happy to be. But how's Monday night? We can all talk here and everything is out in the open.” You were worried that this would be the most awkward interaction ever but if it made her comfortable then sure. The awkwardness might be worth it.

She takes a moment to think about it before nodding. “Okay, Monday night.”

“Good now I'm going back to lockpicking videos cause there's a locked door preventing me from getting to Ellen on Tuesday that I need to be able to pick.”

A/note: happy easter