… Another one opens

Tanya stops sitting on your face and falls prone on the bed next to you, on your left. You look to the other side and you see your naked daughter standing on the edge of the bed, her naked body’s curves being accented by candlelight, while she plays with herself as her eyes focus around your crotch area. You prop yourself up on your elbows and to no surprise to you, you see Cassie servicing your cock with her mouth.

It’s happening… It’s actually happening!

“Hey~” you greet them. “When did—” you begin to ask, but just like Tanya earlier, Stella places a finger on your lips to shush you. It looks like this is a ‘no questions asked’ situation, so you might as well go with what the girls had obviously planned in advance. It didn’t escape your notice the finger Stella used to shush you with is the same finger that was playing with her pussy, so you suck it.

“Naughty.” Stella remarks, before climbing on top of you.

Stella pulls you into a kiss as she lays on top of you while Cassie’s now jerking your fully erect cock with her hand. When Stella breaks the kiss, she directs your face to look to your left, where you see Tanya having a dazed look of satisfaction as she stares right into your eyes. Tanya inches her face closer before giving you a sweet peck on the lips. “You were amazing, papi.” she sweetly tells you.

“It did look amazing.” Stella concurred. “I kinda want to try what she did now. My ass, twerking on your face like I twerked on your cock last night.” Stella adds, and your cock noticeably twitches at the thought.

“Daddy liked that idea.” Cassie says, after she frees her mouth from sucking your cock.

Stella makes out with you once more, writhing her body on top of you. You notice after Cassie pops your dick out of her mouth once more that she directs the tip of your dick along Stella’s entrance, rubbing them against each other.

“Would you rather sit on his face, or sit on his dick?” Cassie asks Stella. Stella just moans into your mouth as she doesn’t break away from your kiss, while continuing to writhe in pleasure, almost as if she’s intentionally hitting your tip with her pussy lips as she does.

“Since I’m going to watch you this time, let’s do this in the same order. I’ll watch you fuck first while I play with myself, and then Jay can eat you out and I’ll interrupt you as soon as you start squirting on his face.” Cassie says teasingly, but from her next actions, you realize she was actually serious as she directs your cock to poke the inside of Stella’s pussy. You’re not sure if Stella did it on her own, or if Cassie directed her body to, but Stella lowers her ass down to take your cock inside her.

Stella sits up, breaking her make out session with you, as she moans in pleasure from having her Dad’s cock impaled inside her. Stella leans back and is now resting on Cassie’s body as she leans her head back to rest on Cassie’s shoulders. You can feel Cassie massage your balls from behind Stella, as Stella does grinding motions on your dick.

Cassie places two fingers into Stella’s open mouth, and Stella sucks on Cassie’s fingers instinctively. You see your daughter swirl her tongue around Cassie’s two fingers before sucking on them again. Once Cassie’s fingers are satisfactorily wet, Cassie does what she promised she’d do and starts rubbing her own clit with her now wet fingers while watching you and Stella fuck.

“I never thought watching you fuck another woman would be this hot.” Tanya whispers into your ear. “This isn’t my first time being with another woman, but this is my first time sharing a man with one. Let alone sharing a man with two other women.” Tanya adds before licking your earlobe. Stella’s riding your cock now, going up and down on your pole at a steady pace. Cassie’s hand that was massaging your balls wraps around Stella’s back and massages one of her tits and pinches her erect nipple. Stella moans at Cassie’s touch.

“It’s like a weird out of body experience for me. I know how good that feels. How good your cock must feel inside of her. A part of me imagines that it’s me you’re fucking; but seeing your daughter riding your cock like that, a lot of what I’m feeling is just happiness for both of you. Happiness in knowing she can experience the euphoria I feel when I’m with you.” she says before kissing and licking your chin. Stella’s picking up her pace, and you can see Cassie just looking at you as she speeds up her rubbing of her clit.

“That feeling of heaven. Penetrating. Deep. Inside. Her. Womb.” Tanya said seductively, every word with a pause and her warm breath hitting your ear.

“Oh fuck.” you groan as Tanya’s dirty talk heightened everything you're feeling now too. You hear Tanya moan now, as she was apparently playing with herself all this time too.

“Fuck your daugter good, papi.” she moans for you.

Her moans create symphony with the two other girls as Cassie’s biting her lower lip while her fingers rub her clit even faster. At the same time, Stella has gone into overdrive and has rested her hands on your chest while she twerks on your dick like last night.

“Yes Daddy! Fuckfuckfuckfuckfuck! Pound my pussy from below!” Stella shouts as she breaks from twerking to ride the wave of her orgasm.

You do as she says and pound her from, and your moans are getting more and more frequent now too. Stella starts twerking on your cock once again, matching your pace from below her. You warn Stella that you’re getting close, but Stella doesn’t relent.

“Baby, I’m getting close. Are you on pills?” you say quickly, as you try to hold on before she answers.

“Baby!” you shout, but Stella’s in a whole other world right now with her eyes closed, as her lust has taken her over, while you’re inching ever closer to climax as she keeps moving her butt up and down your cock.

“Fuck! Baby!” you’re about to bust inside your daughter if she doesn’t stop moving.

“Stella!” you suddenly hear Cassie shout making Stella wake up from her trance and hop off your dick. Once your cock is free from the warm and moist embrace of Stella’s pussy, you see no reason to hold it in any longer and explode.

“AAAAGH!” you groan out loud… but Stella wasn’t done with you. She immediately covers your face with her pussy.

“I was so close to another one, Daddy! Please make me cum some more!” Stella shouts from above you, as she starts grinding her walls on your mouth.

“I wonder who she got that greedy streak from?” Tanya asks teasingly with a smirk on her face. You begin to work your daughter’s incredibly wet pussy with your tongue, like you did Tanya earlier, but you hear Cassie admonish her friend for her recklessness.

“He almost came inside you! Are you insane!?” Cassie asks her in disbelief. Stella just moans in pleasure. “I know you’re not on pills like I am—” Cassie started saying but you and Stella basically cut her off with your respective reactions.

“WHAT!?” you try to shout upon hearing this information, but it’s muffled by her pussy grinding on your tongue. Simultaneously, Stella was about to ask something before she orgasms on top of you once again, “So whaaa~AAAAAAAAH!” she shouts before squirting her fluids on your open mouth, and a lot of it hitting the majority of your face.

Stella holds the headboard for support to keep herself sitting up, but you know her body just wants to collapse on the bed next to you after her intense orgasm. Tanya frees up the space next to you by sitting up and letting Stella lie next to you on the bed. Both Cassie and Tanya are now watching you and your daughter breathing heavily after that intense session… but a mix of parental concern and concern as her boyfriend kicks in immediately.

“You’re not on contraception!?” you ask your daughter in panic and confusion. Cassie was right, has she gone fucking insane!?

“I’m sorry, Daddy. I was just... so~ close. I couldn’t stop myself” Stella replies in between deep breaths.

“Baby…” you wanted to lecture her, but Tanya made a joke before you could, “Wow, the amount of self-control you two have. It’s like you’re related or something.” Tanya jokes, making all four of you laugh a little.

“I’m sorry Daddy. I’ll be more careful next time.” she says after cuddling next to you and kissing you on the cheek.

“Being ‘more careful’ means you were careful in the first place.” Cassie corrects her.

“Jeez. It’s not like he did cum inside me. Relax.” Stella retorts, making Cassie just roll her eyes.

“We should drop by the clinic tomorrow and get you on birth control.” You tell your daughter.

“Okay~” Stella replies. “A part of me just really wanted you to fill me up though. Didn’t you feel an adrenaline rush from it? Some form of excitement?” Stella asks you.

Before you can answer, Tanya answers Stella for you. “Take it from a woman who’s had to suffer the consequences, your papi can fill you up all you want when you’re on birth control sweetie. You’re still in college and you’re on a varsity team. Don’t waste the opportunities you’ve worked so hard for.” Tanya advises your daughter.

“I agree with Tanya, baby; but I do know that excitement you’re talking about. Last time I couldn’t control myself from that excitement, your mother and I had you. I wouldn’t change any of that, so don’t get me wrong, but I also know I was incredibly lucky to have been able to raise you and go to college with the help of my parents. Your mother, on the other hand, had to pause her life and take care of you while you were a baby.” you tell her.

“Yeah, yeah; and she only finished up her studies once you got a stable enough job. I remember the story.” Stella says dismissing a story she’s heard before. “Got it. No getting pregnant until graduation.” Stella replies.

“That’s not…” you wanted to clarify what you meant further, but you honestly think what she said isn’t something you want to argue against for now.

“All this talk about your ex-wife is really getting me horny.” Tanya says sarcastically, making all of you chuckle again. “Sorry about that.” you apologize to them.

“Let’s get you excited again, shall we?” Tanya says seductively. Surprisingly, she didn’t jump on you or even make a move in your general direction which is what you assumed she meant. Instead, she goes after Cassie. “Maybe we should show them what we were up to last night?” Tanya asks Cassie. Cassie blushes from Tanya being flirty with her. “Oh, come now, chica. You weren’t shy last night.” Tanya teases her.

Tanya sidles up behind Cassie, wrapping her arms around her waist, while one of her hands is dangerously close to Cassie’s pubis.

“I don’t remember this position from last night.” Cassie says, as she looks to her side and raises an arm to stroke Tanya’s hair.

“Maybe not this position, but this definitely happened last night.” Tanya says before pressing her lips to Cassie’s, in a slow passionate kiss.

You prop up and rest your back on the headboard, and Stella follows suit, resting her head on your shoulder. One of Stella’s hands rubbing your chest and sometimes switching it up by caressing you with her fingertips. You and your daughter both watch Tanya and Cassie make out passionately, while Tanya also explores Cassie’s body with her hands. Tanya pinches both of Cassie’s erect nipples making her moan in pleasure, breaking the kiss from Tanya.

Stella has now lowered her hand from your chest to your soft dick, caressing it with her palm. Her palm gets slick from the mixture of your own cum that trickled down from your own orgasm, as well as the juices from her own pussy. As it grows in her hand, she begins to jerk your slowly growing cock, while you watch Tanya switch positions so she and Cassie are now face-to-face, and hers and Cassie’s breasts press against each other.

Your cock twitches in Stella’s hands as you imagine what it would feel like to have your dick in between those soft mounds. Stella positions herself so that she’s sitting next to you instead of cuddling you, so that your hand can have access to her pussy. She spreads her legs and your hands instinctively rub her pussy while she continues to jerk you off.

“Maybe you should do what Viv could only lie about earlier.” Tanya tells Cassie in between kisses with Cassie. Cassie immediately understands what she means and places her hand to rub Tanya’s outer walls before penetrating them with her fingers. Tanya moans in pleasure from Cassie’s fingering, before Tanya returns the favor and fingers Cassie as well.

You and Stella each match the pace that you can see Cassie and Tanya have, as all four of you assist each other in group masturbation. Tanya lowers her head and sucks on Cassie’s erect nipple, giving it a nibble making Cassie groan in pleasure. As Tanya releases Cassie’s nipple from her mouth, she asks you, “Do we excite you, papi?”

You can only nod as the sloshing noises of three wet pussies being fingered surround the room.

“What about you, Stella? Are you enjoying watching me with someone else this time?” Cassie asks her best friend with a naughty giggle. Tanya goes back to fingering Cassie even more fervently, and the wet noises it creates brings you to a full on erection.

“That’s what good pussy sounds like.” Stella moans under her breath, and you can’t disagree with her assessment as the sounds reverberate around you. Tanya pushes Cassie down on the bed where Cassie is laying on her back, legs spread, while Tanya goes on top of her at an angle where you and Stella have a perfect view of both their pussies which are just on top of each other.

Tanya and Cassie continue making out in this position but stop fingering each other, and you bet you have an idea why. The two of them don’t need to say it. You excuse yourself from Stella and she doesn’t seem to mind as she moves with you to position herself beside Tanya and Cassie, while you position yourself behind them. With your dick slick with a mix of different fluids already, you easily slide your cock in between the space of both their pussies, rubbing your shaft along their pubes, hitting both their clits simultaneously.

“Who are you going to fuck first Daddy?” Stella asks you, teasing the two girls who are giddy in anticipation as you see Tanya shake her ass to entice you to fuck her, while Cassie writhes beneath her, tempting you to do the same, stimulating your sandwiched cock. You take out your cock from in between their pubes to tease Tanya’s pussy with the tip of your dick, feeling how wet she still is from Cassie’s fingering.

However, you make the executive decision and start with the woman whose pussy you haven’t touched tonight. Even more than that, you haven’t even touched her at all during all this, so it’s time for you to correct that. You penetrate Cassie’s pussy with the head of your cock and she immediately responds with a loud “Yes!”, before going back to making out with Tanya. You look to your side and you see Stella playing with herself, as she watches you fuck Cassie while Tanya’s on top of her.

You penetrate Tanya’s entrance with two fingers, but not pushing the entire length of your fingers in.

“More papi!” Tanya shouts, and you oblige and simultaneously penetrate them both. With your elbow resting on your belly, you let your body motions push your fingers inside Tanya.

“I meant more, papi! ¡Usa más dedos!” Tanya shouts.

“She said use more fingers.” Cassie translates in between moans.

“Oh.” you say aloud, before adding another finger in.

“Ay papi! Si! Que rico!” Tanya shouts in pleasure.

“Care to translate for us Duo?” Stella teasingly asks.

“Oh, Daddy! Yes! Delicious!” Cassie moans as you pick up your pace.

“I give you a B for not using context clues, chica.” Tanya jokes, and you realize Cassie was just translating Tanya’s dirty talk and not really moaning from your movements. You ramp your pace up even further to try and persuade her to use her own words when she moans.

“OH FUCK!” Cassie immediately obliges your inner desire. “YES DADDY! KEEP FUCKING ME JUST LIKE THAT!” Cassie continues to moan, as you piston your cock in and out of her pussy, shaking the entire bed.

Tanya starts moaning louder now too as your fingering of her is at the same pace as your fucking of Cassie. “Dámelo papi!” Tanya shouts, while Cassie lets out a “HNNNNNG!!” from her climax. You keep fucking her, not letting her come down from the height of her orgasm. Every one of your thrusts just results in an “UH!” from Cassie before she repeatedly taps Tanya’s ass. You say tap since it doesn’t seem like she’s spanking it, but more like tapping out.

As you pull out of her, she immediately lets out a long drawn out groan while her body shakes further. As soon as you were completely out of her pussy though, you immediately removed your fingers from Tanya’s and replaced it with your dick.

“That’s way fucking better than your fingers!” Tanya immediately reacts. Since you’ve been prepping her for the same pace with your fingers, you didn’t change the pace from when you were fucking Cassie and just pistoned in and out of Tanya too.

As soon as Cassie’s breathing has gone back to normally paced deep breaths, you know she’s come down from her orgasm, so you decided to do something that you’ve been tempted to do since you saw them in this position. You alternate between Tanya’s pussy with Cassie’s after every few strokes. It results in you going slower since you had to get used to the angle changes, but you soon build a steady rhythm.

“Oh fuck, that’s hot!” Stella moans beside them as she aggressively rubs her pussy with her fingers as she watches you alternate between Tanya and Cassie’s pussies.

“Come here, sweetie.” Tanya tells her, and Stella follows her order and inches her face closer to Tanya’s. “No, not with me. I don’t want your first kiss with a girl to be with your neighbor. It should be more special than that.” Tanya tells her. Cassie and Stella look at each other, and start playing gay chicken with their lips.

You start focusing on fucking Tanya’s pussy for now, and not alternating, as you anticipate watching your daughter make out with her best friend. You don’t know why that’s just as hot for you to watch as Tanya and Cassie fingering and making out with each other, but Tanya has a point. There’s history between them, and if they do this, they’ll cross that line too… or at least you tell yourself. Jesus Christ, they’re both fucking you at the same time. How much more special can a kiss be, really?

The two best friends kiss. A soft, sweet, testing the waters, kind of kiss. However, it only takes a few minutes before the two of them completely let go of their inhibitions and start making out completely and sloppily, their tongues wrestling each other’s outside of their mouths. You asked yourself ‘how much more special can a kiss be?’; well, your dick seems to think it’s really fucking special since that seems to be the thing to get you over the edge.

“Fuuuuuuck!” you groan out before you speed up on Tanya’s pussy, aiming to reach your climax.

“Dámelo, papi! Give me your cum! Fill me with your cum!” Tanya shouts, which seems to trigger something in Stella as she starts rubbing and fingering herself faster now too, breaking away from making out with Cassie. Cassie doesn’t seem to want to be left behind and she’s rubbing her clit and fingering herself now too.

“I’m cumming Tanya!” you shout, “Si Papi! Dámelo!”, and with her words of encouragement, you bust your nut all inside Tanya’s pussy. Your groan of pleasure seems to set off a chain reaction between the girls as Tanya cums from being filled up by your seed, before Stella follows her after a few seconds, while Cassie continues to play with herself until she eventually cums as well.

After your climax, you take your dick out of Tanya and you see your cum overflow out of her pussy. Some of your cum even drips down Cassie’s dripping wet pussy too. The visual is just too much for you and you fall on your back on the bed, dead tired from having had to overexert yourself with this foursome.

All your girlfriends seem to be of the same mind and are exhausted too, and they all sluggishly move to cuddle next to you. Coincidentally, they seem to have taken the same positions as they did last night — with your daughter Stella to your left, with Cassie hugging her on her left, while Tanya is to your right.

You’d want to ask them if this was planned, with the candles and the rose petals, and Cassie and Stella suggesting you should go here after Celeste went to bed. Did they know Celeste wasn’t going to work out?

You’d want to ask them, but you’re exhausted. You can save it for tomorrow. Right now, all you want to do is close your eyes and have a dreamless sleep.

No dream is going to beat reality right now.