"John!"

Three big shocks

Your name slips out of Nicole's parted lips so gently that you're not sure if you heard her right. If you did, and Nicole really is picturing someone else eating her pussy, Tom doesn't let it slow him down. He continues licking at her with wild abandon, treating her wet pussy like a quickly melting ice cream. His tongue makes her legs quiver around him and you see her eyes screw even tighter shut. "John!" she moans again, the syllables of your name inarguably escaping her lips in a pleasured exhalation, making your ears (and something else) prick up.

Although she said your name you know she’s not really talking to you. She’s talking to the idea of you that’s standing behind her, the hallucination she’s generated in her mind to eat her pussy instead of Tom. Clearly she dreams that it was you making her feel so good, something that you wholeheartedly agree with. You wish that you could be the one making her moan and quiver like that instead of just being a spectator to her pleasure. The fact that she’s thinking of you even in a position and situation like this is very charming and even if she's not really talking to you, you can’t resist answering her anyway.

"You can do it Nicole ! Hold on!" you cheer. Miranda might see you cheerleading for Nicole as you showing your hand, but that doesn't matter to you right now. She called for you, you can't not answer. Hearing your voice, a smile breaks across your friends face, only to be quickly replaced by a furrowed brow and blushing cheeks. "H-hearing your voice right now really isn't helping John!" she whines, screwing her eyes tighter shut. Those words and her pitiful tone put a cheeky grin on your face, reminding you of something from not so long ago.

"Yeah, now you know how it feels bitch!" you laugh, remembering how unhelpfully she'd whispered sweet nothings into your ear while Sarah polished your rod. "Oh fuck!" Nicole answers, remembering the same incident. It seems you have the perfect opportunity to get even with your little friend and make her struggle just the way you had. All you have to do is keep talking to her and you can get your payback while helping make her cute toes curl. A selfish part of you also really does want to see Nicole's O-face.

However, doing that would move her out of your reach, saddling her with Tom instead. You'd still have Miranda, the beautiful bombshell who you'd been doting on for months, but there was no way of telling when you'd spend any more time with Nicole tonight. She had seemed to warm to Tom somewhat after sucking his cock, but you know she usually dislikes him, do you really want to leave her sat next to him and his naked dick? Maybe you should ask her what she wants?

"Do you want me to shut up Nicole?" you ask, your voice as low and husky as you can make it. "Mmph, nooo," she groans, shaking her head and making her short blonde hair bounce. "Do you like when I talk to you like this?" your voice still gravelly as you continue. "F-fuck yes! I love it!" she gasps, sweetly biting her pink bottom lip. "Do you want me to help you cum?" you almost whisper. "Yesss! Shit! Please make me cum!" she shouts, pushing her body back against Tom's waiting face. Nicole's almost out of control now, maybe she really has convinced herself that you're the man making her feel so good. Regardless of what she thinks, it's clear that a few more well placed dirty words will be all that it takes to make her cum, and that she wouldn't mind if she did.

It seems the decision is up to you. Do you help make Nicole cum, giving her what she wants right now? Or do you keep quiet so that she might come back to your side, where you can whisper all the filth you want into her waiting ears?

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

If you enjoyed this chapter then the final, and more lighthearted, answer to the question of "What comes out of Nicole's mouth?" is already live on my Patreon, a week before it's available here. If you want to see it now or if you just enjoy my writing then please consider becoming a patron.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123