The Man Next Door

The Man Next Door

A Hookup Gone Wrong

Chapter 1 by tcorbett691 tcorbett691

"Amber! Amber!"

Amber was in the backseat of her boyfriend Ethan's car. Her shirt was pulled up and her bra was off giving Ethan access to her large breasts which he was grabbing with both hands. Her legs were wrapped around his waist as he enthusiastically thrust into her pussy. The car was parked in a spot in her winding driveway where the trees blocked the view from the road and her house.

"Amber!" Ethan thrust in once more and shot his load inside her. She held him as he shuttered on top of her. "That...was great, babe!"

"Yeah...."

This was how every date went ever since she gave him her virginity at prom. They would come back 10 minutes before her curfew and fuck in his car. Five minutes later, they would straighten up their clothes and he would drop her off on time.

That's right, five minutes. Every time, he only lasted five minutes. Amber had never been with anyone else but she had started to suspect that wasn't normal.

She enjoyed sex with Ethan. His four inch dick felt good inside her. She even liked it when he came inside her. She was on the pill so they didn't bother with condoms. The problem was that she had never had an orgasm.

Still, she had no personal experience to compare with. It wasn't until she started talking to some of her girlfriends about their experiences that she realized something wasn't right.

They talked about having sex for an hour or more. And about orgasms. She had masturbated before and had cum a couple times that way, but they told her sex was supposed to be better than that.

She came to the conclusion that the problem was one of three things. Either something was wrong with her, Ethan's dick was too small, or he just wasn't lasting long enough. Either way, she had to find out. But the only way to do that would be to have sex with someone else. She knew this would be a bad idea from the start. But her curiosity wouldn't let it go.

Introduction 2

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)