Author's Notes

I wasn't thrilled with this story. I loved the idea I had for the prompt, but felt my execution was lacking. I tried to do a different format with it just being the characters talking/thinking about the past instead of actually writing those scenes. There are some stories that have taken that approach that I've loved, but it wasn't one I've ever really tried before.

Part of the issue is that I had a couple of things come up while writing this story that really distracted me from the writing process. These prompts stories I feel work out a lot better when I jump into them and just tackle one prompt after an other going off my first idea. Trying to weave them together from the beginning was considerably more tricky.

I had some more plans for the story. Was considering having Anya go back and talk to each of the girls a second time for more depth. I also considered giving both Anya's version of all the sex events in her timeline, as well as an overview of her "new" memories. I definitely would have done more with the Prom orgy. The idea there was to never actually have anyone tell the whole story at once, but have people give out bits and drabs of this crazy night that kept getting interrupted.

As for the prompts, here is what Hypno, Severus, and Johans came up with:

Severus

Level 1: When he spent over an hour worshiping every inch of my naked body with just his hands making me orgasm without touching my pussy

Level 1: When we dared each other to streak through the halls of Sunnydale High

Level 2: When I gave him a secret blowjob in The Bronze

Level 3: When we convinced a female teacher to join us in a threesome

Level 3: When we saved a girl and she demanded to be allowed to thank us in her own way, which was joining us for a night and morning after of sex

Hypno

Level 1: When he gave me posthypnotic suggestions to cum on command, it was so hot I just couldn’t help myself.

Level 1: When he decided whether or not I was allowed underwear, it was so hot I was leaking all the time in anticipation.

Level 2: When I deepthroated him he was so girthy without all the tasty precum for lube there was no way I was getting him all the way down.

Level 2: When he ate me out it was so amazing, his cock isn’t the only thing that's extraordinary in length.

Level 3: He was so commanding with me and the other three girls, loved the way he keep us all involved and cumming to keep our minds off the danger.

Johans

Level 1: When we made out on the rooftop with the 4th of July fireworks in the background, he was so romantic, but not at all cheesy. I found that really charming.

Level 2: When he was supposed to be a lookout on the walkie-talkie with her patrolling and I jacked him off, he endured the whole night shift and when it was over, released a huge load. That was a spectacle.

Level 2: When I gave him a blowjob on a long bus ride and our destination was getting closer so I really had to up my headgame to have him release my lunch for me before we got off the bus.

Level 3: The foursome, definitely the foursome. He had the idea to invite an additional girl, which really intrigued me. So we went to the club and I thought it was my job to wheel the additional girl in. I left him at the table to pick up the cutie on the other side of the club, but when I returned he already had a small flock of party girls swarming around him. He subtly pointed at one of them. Long story short, I got my pick and he got his, we brought them all back to our place and had a foursome.

Level 3: When the voyeur joined us. We were in the middle of sex, when he was about to put me into doggy and aimed at my backdoor, we heard a shuffle outside. He put on a bathrobe and went looking, protective as he is. He came back with a woman that had been watching us, obviously looking disheveled. She blurted out how we were the hottest couple around and that anal sealed the deal on that. She begged us to be included and we humored her and included her in our nights experiments.