Yet another truth

Amy thought about it for a minute. She was trying to think up something new and different. Finally, an idea occurred to her.

“Ok, Susie. Tell the truth. What’s your weirdest fetish and have you ever had fetish sex?”

“Wow, that really came out of left field, Amy,” Susie looked almost shocked. “Why do you think I even have a fetish? And just exactly constitutes a fetish?”

“Um, I don’t know,” she answered. “Just tell us something kinky you’ve done and we’ll tell you if it’s a fetish or not. Maybe like BDSM? Have you ever done anything like that?”

“Ok, you got me, I guess,” Susie grinned. “I have had this thing about being submissive, you know, tied up and fucked, things like that. And I actually did try it one time.”

“Oh, do tell us all about it,” Amy grinned back. “And don’t spare us any of the gory details.”

Susie looked around the room and sighed. “Well, I guess we’re all learning a lot about each other tonight. Never thought I’d be telling anyone about this.” She paused collecting herself. I looked around the room at the four girls and thought about how hot it was having them tell sexy stories about themselves while sitting around naked. I wasn’t sure how it could get any better than this, outside of getting to fuck all of them. I wondered if that was going to happen tonight too.

“So, there was this one guy I went out with, only a couple of times,” Susie began. “But this was during a time when I had really gotten caught up in BDSM stuff and looked at a lot of sites on the web that were into that sort of thing. The boys I had gone out with before this had all been kind of reserved, afraid to take the first step or try anything out of the ordinary. So I had sort of been in charge all the time. I always wondered what it would be like for the guy to be in charge, so I had looked up stuff about domination. Some of the hardcore stuff kind of turned me off but a lot of the basic stuff turned me on.”

She paused to catch her breath.

“So it was during that time that this one guy asked me out. I had only seen him around, didn’t know much about him. But I noticed he seemed very confident and sure of himself, not like some of the wimpy boys I had known. So we went out to dinner and stuff and ended up back at his place. During dinner some of the conversation had turned to what kind of sex we liked and it was clear he liked being the dominant partner. So we had sex that night but it was pretty vanilla. He did call me names some and slapped my ass or whatever but that was about it. While we were lying there after sex we talked some more about our likes and dislikes. He brought up the subject of domination and submission and confirmed that he liked to be the dominant one. So I admitted I had been getting turned on by the idea of being a submissive to a dominant guy.”

Susie paused again and looked around the room. Everyone was waiting for her story to get to the good part.

“So we agreed that on our next date we would try some light bondage and domination. We also agreed that he wouldn’t tell me exactly what he was going to do but promised he wouldn’t do anything that would hurt me. So about a week later we had dinner again and went back to his house. As soon as we got in the front door, his entire character changed. I guess he was doing like a roleplay.”

“’All right, bitch, get your ass into the bedroom right now,’ he ordered me then grabbed my arm and pulled me roughly toward the bedroom door. He pushed me into the room and threw me down on the bed. ‘First I’m going to blindfold you,’ he told me and proceeded to do just that. I couldn’t see a thing now but had to rely on my other senses. I admit I was starting to get aroused.”

“I didn’t know what to expect next. Then I felt him grab my wrists and pull them together behind my back. He tied them together with a rope. Then I think he used another rope to tie my bound wrists to the headboard. He pushed up my top and started squeezing my tits – hard. ‘You like this, slut, don’t you,’ he growled. I felt my jeans being unbuttoned and unzipped and pulled off roughly. My panties he simply ripped off. Then he attacked my pussy with his hands and fingers, again not being very gentle at all. ‘Whose pussy is this?’ he asked roughly. ‘It’s my pussy, isn’t that right, slut?’ Of course, being blindfolded and gagged I was unable to answer him. And the weird thing was, I was both scared and aroused at the same time.”

She paused again, looking around at her friends but avoiding eye contact with me. I looked around and I could tell the other three girls were hanging on her every word and also looked somewhat aroused.

“I thought he was going to fuck me next, but instead I felt him grab one of my legs and tie a rope around my ankle which he apparently tied to the bedpost. Then he did the same with the other ankle. I was completely helpless, unable to move at all. I could only lie there and wonder what was coming next. Suddenly I felt his cock ram hard into my pussy with no warning. It hurt and excited me at the same time.”

“’You’re my bitch now, bitch,’ he shouted redundantly. He fucked me hard without any apparent consideration of my needs or feelings. I was only able to move my hips slightly in response to his rough thrusts. My mind was totally confused and basically shut down. All of my being was centered on my pussy. ‘Take my load, bitch,’ he shouted again, as I felt his hot cum being pumped out deep in my pussy. Since I was totally focused on our coupling, my body responded by cumming too. My orgasm rolled over me but I still couldn’t move and had to just lie there and let it run its course.”

Susie stopped and seemed to be catching her breath. I looked around and all three of the other girls had their hands on their pussies. And I realized I had unconsciously been stroking my cock the whole time.

Amy broke the silence. “God, that was hot, Susie,” she practically moaned. “So what happened next?”

“Well, nothing really,” Susie responded. “He untied me and took off the blindfold and gag. He asked me how it was but I didn’t really know what to say. I guess after that experience my curiosity was satisfied. I never saw him again and never did anything like that again. But I can’t say I regret trying it.”

I still had my rigid rod in a tight grip, while I looked at my sister somewhat in astonishment. I never would have imagined her doing anything like that. “Wow, sis, I never would have thought….” I remarked. “I always thought you were so young and innocent.”

“So maybe you don’t know me as well as you think,” she stuck out her tongue at me. “But I think it’s your turn now, after hearing all of our hot stories.”