Have you had sex with more than one girl at a time?

“Ok,” Susie looked over at me. “So I guess it’s your turn again. Hmm, what is there left to ask?” She put a finger to her lips, contemplating what she could ask.

“Hold on a minute,” I protested. “I already did the truth round.”

Susie just grinned. “Well, I guess you’re going to get another turn, bro. I know what I want to ask.” (dramatic pause) “Have you ever had sex with more than one girl at a time?”

“You mean one girl at a time on the same night or more than one girl at the same time?” I asked innocently.

“I don’t know,” Susie seemed irritated. “Whichever. Just tell us about any kind of experience you’ve had like that.”

“Ok, sis. I get the idea. Actually I think I have a pretty good story about that.” I suddenly came up with a really cool idea, something that would be a really unique twist on a true story.

“Oooh, great,” she replied. “Tell us all about it. And don’t leave out any of the juicy details.”

“Ok, so like I was at this party one night. Although I’m not quite sure you would call it a party. It was just me and four girls. They were all a couple years younger than me and all four of them were really hot. I really couldn’t believe my luck. Well, there was some wine involved and everybody got to feeling a little tipsy and things got kind of loose, you could say.”

I looked around the room to see how the girls were reacting. They were all looking at me kind of curiously like they were wondering where the story was going to go. So I continued.

“Well, one thing led to another and before you knew it everybody was totally naked, including myself. I looked around the room and all four of the girls were beautiful and totally hot. My cock was standing out straight, the sight of these four naked beauties in front of me was giving me a hard on like I had never had before. Up to this point nothing much had really happened, just a little bit of fooling around and stuff, you know. Well, I wanted more than that.”

I took another pause to catch my breath. The anticipation of where I was going with my story had me even more excited. The girls all had questioning looks on their faces like they suspected something was going on.

“This sounds kinda familiar,” Susie broke in. “Are you sure this isn’t all made up?”

“No, no, sis. This is all totally true,” I assured her. “We’re just getting to the good part,” I grinned. Then I resumed my story.

“Well, one of the girls there was a cutie I had had the hots for for the longest time. There was a kind of pause in the activities so I slid over beside her and put my wine glass to her lips. She took a drink as I tipped it up for her. Then I set the glass down and kissed her hard on the lips as I put a hand on her hip.”

As I was saying this, I moved over next to Amy and tipped my glass up to her lips, then set the glass down and gave her a hard kiss and put one hand on her hip. Then I put an arm around her and pulled her up tight against me.

“She seemed comfortable with us being so close together, both of us naked, so I slid my arm down and grabbed her ass with my hand and reached over with my other hand and caressed one of her tits.” My actions mimicked my narration as I grabbed Amy’s ass and tit. She looked at me curiously. I kept going.

“Again, she didn’t seem to object, so I bent down and took her other tit in my mouth and started licking it and sucking on it. I teased her nipple with my tongue which responded by popping out like a hard little eraser.” I paused so I could demonstrate this part of the story and Amy’s nipple did indeed pop out just like I said.

“I slid my hand around from her ass to her warm pussy and slid my fingers back and forth along her wet slit. Then I slid a finger inside as I cupped her warm mound with the palm of my hand. She let out a little gasp of surprise but did nothing to stop me.” I again proceeded to do what I was describing and Amy did in fact let out a little gasp.

“I squeezed her mound with my hand and slid another finger inside her wet cunt. She wiggled her hips around my fingers and moaned quietly. At this point I knew I had her. I kissed her again, a big wet french kiss. As we kissed I slid her down so she was reclining on her back. I reached down and spread her legs with my hands as I positioned myself so my throbbing cock was pointing at her hot pussy.” I slid another finger into Amy’s pussy, which was in fact quite warm, then kissed her hard and slid her into position, lining my hard cock up in front of her hole.

“I thrust my cock into her warm waiting pussy in one quick thrust,” I continued my story as I thrust my cock deep into Amy’s pussy, which was in fact very warm. She let out a small squeal of surprise and pleasure. “She squealed with surprise and pleasure,” I grinned as I began pummeling my enlarged member in and out of her tight tunnel. I was starting to breathe more heavily as was Amy, making it a little difficult for me to continue my narrative.

“Maybe I can just demonstrate what happened next rather than trying to tell you,” I strained to talk. Then I turned my complete attention to Amy who was writhing and moaning below me. I slid my hands down wrapping around her hips and ass and held her tight as I plunged deeper and deeper into her tight juicy cunt. I bent forward and kissed her on the mouth as we fucked each others’ brains out, then moved down and sucked hard on her tits and nipples.

“David! What’s going on?” I heard my sister shout but totally ignored her. Amy was thrashing wildly now and on the brink of cumming. I intended to cum with her and ride the waves of her orgasm with her. She let out a piercing scream as it hit her, triggering my orgasm as I shot rope after rope of thick sticky cum deep into her pussy. We clutched each other tightly as we were overcome by waves of ecstasy. As I was coming back down from our sexual high, I could hear my sister’s voice again.

“Ok, David, you’ve obviously told a true story and well acted out too, I must say,” she conceded. “But you were supposed to be telling us about a time you had sex with more than one girl.”