Yes

“Do I get to take off my blindfold first?” I asked.

“No, not yet. Not until you guess who was who,” my sister replied.

I sighed. “Ok, let me see…. I think I’ll start with number three. Obviously she’s the winner, she’s the only one who came. So I think number three is Susie.”

I waited for my pick to be confirmed. “You have to pick all three before we say if you’re right or not,” Susie told me.

“Ok,” I accepted her rules. “So I think the first girl was Carly. Second girl was Amy. And I pick Amy for the tastiest pussy. So take off my blindfold now and tell me how I did.”

I felt someone move up next to me and untie my blindfold. The site of my naked sister standing next to me and grinning greeted me. I couldn’t help but notice her mound and small thatch of hair was glistening with her juices.

“Looks like I was right about you, Susie,” I grinned.

“Yeah, you got me. Guess I can’t hide anything from my big bro,” she laughed. “But I have to say, you sure know how to eat you some pussy.”

“So what about the others? How did I do?” I was anxious to know. Although it dawned on me that there was no way I would know if they were really telling me the truth of not.

“Actually, bro, you totally nailed it,” Susie told me. “Looks like we have to declare you to be the ‘pussy expert’.”

I looked over at the other two girls and they were blushing slightly but then started giggling again. Normally, all the giggling would bother me but since I was still hoping to fuck at least one, if not all of them, it was almost music to my ears.

Feeling lucky, I jumped over onto the bean bags between Amy and Carly with my sister on the other side.

“So what’s next?” I asked in an innocent voice as I began to caress both Amy’s and Carly’s thighs. In my mind we were past the truths or dares and I just wanted to fuck.

I was about to push my luck a little further when we all turned our heads toward the door to Susie’s room, watching the doorknob turn and the door being pushed open.