Beth returns

Our fears of being caught again were quickly assuaged when Beth slipped quickly through the opening and quietly shut the door behind her. We all looked up at her in surprise. Nobody said anything. We were all sitting there naked. After a few moments of silence, Beth spoke up.

“So, like, I started to head home and I felt a little guilty about not coming back with you all,” she explained. “I got to the front door and I could already hear my mom and dad arguing and yelling at each other like they always do. ‘I don’t need this,’ I thought to myself, so I turned around and came back here. What have I missed? I see that everyone’s naked now,” she observed staring at my still hard cock sticking up in my lap. “Is it too late for me to get back in the game?”

“No, of course not,” my sister replied. “It’s just that you have to be naked too. David, do you want to take Beth’s clothes off?”

“I thought you’d never ask,” I grinned. I jumped up from between Amy and Carly and moved to the middle of the room next to Beth. She was still wearing the same top and jeans as she had been wearing earlier in the evening. I reached down and grabbed the bottom of her top and pulled it up over her head, revealing her nice round tits since she wasn’t wearing a bra. Next I unbuttoned and unzipped her skinny jeans. It was a struggle to get them down past her hips and down her legs because they were so tight. But I finally succeeded although I’ll admit I did have to feel up her ass and legs a lot to get them off. That left her in just her panties. I hooked my thumbs on either side of the waistband and made quick work of them too. I stood back up and admired her lovely naked teenage body from close up. Beth looked around at the other girls.

“Ok, I’m naked now,” she stated the obvious. “So we’re all even now, right?”

“Not exactly,” my sister continued to take the lead, which was only fair since it was her birthday after all. “Now you have to let David feel you up all over, wherever and as much as he wants to for as long as he wants to.”

Wow, my sister was definitely looking out for my best interests, I had to admit. Beth looked surprised momentarily then broke into a smile. “Sure, of course, why not?” she laughed. “I know how much he’d like that,” she winked at me. “And I just might like it too.”

That was all the invitation I needed as I wrapped my arms around Beth and pulled her naked body up against mine. For some reason, my hands went straight to her ass, bringing her bare pussy up against my groin. I squeezed both cheeks of her ass with my hands, then let them start roaming all over her hot bod, her back, her shoulders, her neck, then finally around to her breasts. I kneaded her tits with both hands, they had gotten nice and full in the past year. I bent my head forward to kiss one of her nipples when I was interrupted by my sister’s voice from behind me.

“Unh unh,” she called out. “No kissing, licking, whatever with the mouth. I said ‘feel her up’ which means with your hands only…. for now,” she grinned and winked at me.

“Ok, ok,” I replied. “I can play by the rules.” I resumed feeling Beth’s boobs with just my hands, tracing their shape with my fingers, squeezing each of them separately then at the same time, and then teasing her nipples. “I love the way your tits have filled out,” I smiled at her.

“Thanks, I’m glad you like them,” she smiled back and wiggled them for me. “I kind of like them too.”

I gave her round mounds a final squeeze then started working my hands down and feeling the rest of her tight little body. I ran one hand down the smooth skin of her back and traced my fingers around her tight, firm abdomen and belly button with my other hand. Then my back hand found her sweet round ass again and I cupped her pussy and mound with my front hand. I squeezed her ass and cunt with both hands then I slid one finger up into her cunt hole. I was amazed at how wet she was. I played with her little brown hole with my fingers as I slipped a second finger up inside her wonderfully wet pussy. Then I started to push a digit into her asshole. Her eyes widened as I attacked both holes simultaneously, managing to eventually get three fingers all the way into her pussy and two fingers all the way up her ass. Beth’s eyes had rolled back and she making low moaning sounds as I wiggled my fingers inside her.

“Ok, David, I think that’s enough for now,” my sister piped up again.

“Oh my god, Susie,” Beth protested. “You can’t make him stop now! I’m just on the edge!” I could feel her legs trembling as she struggled to stand up as I drove her toward an orgasm. She was holding on to me at the shoulders just to maintain.

“Ok, ok,” my sister relented. “So now David gets to get you off using only his fingers. I don’t think that will take very long,” she laughed.

Beth was moaning louder as I took my fingers out momentarily to help her lie down on the floor. I pushed her ankles back pushing her knees into the air and giving me full access to both of her holes. Then I plunged back in without hesitation, three fingers in front and two in back. I wiggled them around a little then started pushing them all the way in and pulling them back out to the tips. I alternated between plunging my digits into her slippery cunt and pushing deep into her tight asshole. She was rolling her hips and thrusting up to meet me. I could tell she was almost there. I started plunging all my fingers at the same time into both holes, working them fast. She was breathing heavier and heavier. Then her whole body heaved and I felt her warm juices covering my fingers in her pussy as she muffled her screams.

“Oh god, oh my god, David!” she moaned. “You sure know how to make a girl feel good,” she grinned. She lay there for a moment looking around the room. She made eye contact with my sister. “So what else did I miss while I was gone?” she asked her.