Chapter 59
by
thosearemysecret
Does Maggie allow it?
Yes
Maggie's overcome with happiness and lust. "Yes," she says and closes her eyes again. Parting her lips slightly to prepare for a passionate kiss from Tanya. Suddenly, Tanya grabs Maggie's hips and twists her around. She pushes the girl back onto her bed so she falls backward. Her eyes open as she giggles. Maggie certainly wasn't expecting such an assertive Tanya. As she hits the bed she watches as Tanya surprisingly slides downward. She tugs down Maggie's skirt and panties all the way to her feet. Whipping them off and throwing them across the room. Tanya aggressively pushes Maggie's legs apart and, Maggie still caught up in the whirlwind, barely gets out a "what are you..." before Tanya buries her face between Maggie's thighs.
Tanya moans into Maggie. Using her tongue to push apart her folds. Feeling the girl's wet nest nuzzling against her cheeks and chin.
Maggie gasps. This was not what she was expecting. If she was lucky she was hoping for a little making out before having Tanya help her with the costume. She releases a broken moan from deep in her throat as Tanya's tongue teases at her clit. "T-Tanya..." she says writhing on her bed.
Tanya is in heaven. Ever since the strip club, she kept having thoughts about being in this exact spot. Content between Maggie's legs and eating her out. Whoever the man was that said she loved it was absolutely right. Even though it was confusing. She wasn't really into girls, but she was so very much into Maggie's pussy. As she groans and laps and sucks she wonders if that's even a thing. She'd heard of guys who give each other blow jobs but claim not to be gay. Is this a similar thing? Could she even be straight and like pussy? And why did she only crave Maggie's pussy? Tanya's thoughts slow when she feels Maggie's hands in her hair. They grip and tug expressing happiness. Tanya smiles as she devours Maggie. They're best friends, so it only makes sense that she do things like this to help her? Wasn't Maggie a lesbian? Is this how straight girls help their sheltered and shy gay friends? There were rumors about Bethany. Did Whitney do this for Bethany?
"Fuck, yes" Maggie exclaims and tugs on Tanya's hair again. "Y-you're so good at this, T-Tanya. Oh my god." She holds Tanya's face tightly against her vagina. No, this wasn't what she expected. She expected a kiss, but she'd take this. She'd forget that their first time was on a stage in front of dozens of filthy men. This would be canon. Alone with Tanya in her bedroom. The first girl to ever go down on her. Tanya Wegner. Tanya Wegner. Her body starts to quiver. Her muscles clenching and unclenching. "T-T-Tanya I-I'm..." she can't get the words out. It all feels so good. Her dreams coming true. And she orgasms. Her hand quickly slaps over her mouth to contain the nearly screaming orgasm. She has to push Tanya away to get her to stop. "T-too much, p-please, I love it but..."
Suddenly there's a knock on the door followed by Maggie's Dad asking "I was going to toss a frozen pie in the oven. Do you girls think you'd like some pie?"
Maggie, trying to control her panting, can't help but laugh. "Yes, Dad, I definitely think we'd like some pie."
"Got it. Forty minutes. And I'd love to see those costumes you're working so hard on in there."
As Maggie's Dad walks away Maggie gazes adoringly down at Tanya still kneeling between her legs. "Unless you've already had enough pie?"
Tanya has a big glistening grin on her face. She shakes her head. "I don't think I can ever get enough, Mags."
Maggie is over the moon. She didn't even command Tanya to desire her. She was becoming convinced it could be a natural affection that was somehow unlocked due to their time together. She pats the bed, "I owe you, but we don't have time for that now. We should put some work into our costumes, which, by the way, Dad is NOT going to see." She pulls out a bag and hands it to Tanya. "Yours is fairly easy. I picked up the appropriate purple wig to go with the bikini, so we don't need to work on yours. You can try it on at home. I need you to help make some adjustments on mine." Maggie pauses for a moment and considers asking Tanya to turn around while she changes, but she's already sitting bottomless on the bed, so what's the point?
She starts by slipping into light blue lingerie that nearly matches what Sayaka had on under her referee-looking outfit. "I went to a nice lingerie shop after school and was able to find this. I was going by memory, but was surprised by how well it matched." She poses next to the screen comparing herself to Sayaka.
"Will the vibrator fit in those panties?" Tanya asks innocently. They were going for accuracy after all.
"The...vibrator?"
"Yes, remember when they met Sayaka in her store she secretly had her panties holding a vibrator inside her and two strings of anal beads?" Tanya reverses the video until it gets to that scene.
Maggie is blushing. "Um, that comes way before you, er, Rei shows up in the bikini, so we...we should start from there."
She then reverses a few frames to show the full referee costume. "This is where it gets complicated. I went over to the sporting goods store and was able to find this referee skirt and top, but, obviously, they aren't costume accurate. I'm going to take some measurements and have you mark off spots for me, so I can spend the next four days trying to get this worked out before Anime Cosplay Con."
And that's what they do. Maggie tells Tanya what to mark and Tanya makes the mark using tailor's chalk. Both of the girls are humming with arousal the entire time. It hits Tanya especially hard whenever she's on her knees working on Maggie's skirt. She's pretty sure she could spend hours between her best friend's legs eating her out. It's a confusing feeling.
Forty minutes pass and Maggie's Dad calls them out for pie. The girls take turns cleaning up in the bathroom before sitting down.
"I thought you were going to show me your costumes?" Mr. Mendelssohn asks.
Tanya starts to get up to put on her costume, but Maggie grabs her hand and tells her to finish her pie. It quickly overrules Mr. Mendelssohn's request. She leaves her hand holding Tanya's on top of the table. "Nope, Dad, sorry, they aren't finished. Besides, they'd bore you. We're doing an obscure modern cartoon not something from the 80s you'd recognize."
"You need to give me a little more credit, sweetie. I might not know the material, but I'm sure I can be a great judge." His eyes fall on his daughter holding her friend's hand. Maggie quickly pulls it away and uses it to push her hair back.
She shrugs. "Too much work to do, but maybe I can have Kyle take some pictures on Saturday to show you." She was definitely not planning on having Kyle take any photos on Saturday.
"Fine, fine," he says and finishes his pie. "Well, I'm heading to the workshop to tinker with my secret project."
"Oh come on, Dad," Maggie laughs with a mouthful of pie, "you've been 'working'" she makes air quotes when she says 'working' "on that 57 Chevy for a decade now."
"Making something perfect takes time and patience, Maggie. I'll be taking you and your friends on long drives before the end of the year." He says and ducks out the door heading to the garage.
Tanya and Maggie finish up their pieces of pie. maggie, reluctantly, notes that it's getting late and that maybe Tanya should start heading home. "But before you do..." she says and wraps her arms around Tanya. Maggie looks her friend in the eyes and whispers, "thank you for tonight."
Tanya can't help but whisper back "anytime, Maggie. It's so worth it." As she does, Maggie moves her face forward and places her lips on Tanya's lips.
Does Tanya kiss her back?
"Yes"
A girl cannot refuse any request made of her
Updated on Jun 18, 2026
by madmaniac
Created on Mar 20, 2006
by madmaniac
- 9,403 Likes
- 5,897,855 Views
- 2,281 Favorites
- 1,617 Bookmarks
- 637 Chapters
- 86 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.
Jump to comments

Comments