Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by ScribeOfEros_16 ScribeOfEros_16

Is Arthur ready to lose his anal virginity?

Yeah- but to someone different

"Whoa, whoa, whoa!" Arthur heard Diana exclaim from somewhere as he remained paralyzed, not sure whether it was because of shock, fear or pure lust. "Daph! You can't do that! That's ****!" Diana called out.

He heard a grunt of annoyance escape Daphne's lip, but felt her cock rub gently up and down his asscrack.

"Oh come on... we all know he wants it, like a good slut! Ain't that right, Artie baby?" Daphne snapped back, no warmth in her nickname. Arthur squeamishly wiggled around, flopping himself onto his back. His head now lay flat next to Allison's soft cock, on her creamy thighs. He could see Diana resting on her hands, absentmindedly stroking her hard cock while berating Daphne. Lenna was next to her, frowning slightly, clearly unsure of what to make of the situation.

Most imposing of them all was of course, Daphne. She was kneeling right over Arthur's flat body, her black bitchbreaker that had to be at least a foot long resting aggressively on Arthur's shirt, a small puddle of precum dripped down from her urethral opening and onto the grey fabric of Arthur's nightshirt.

"I... You..." Arthur began, collapsing under the weight of Daphne's predatory gaze.

"I think Arthur means to say you're far too big, Daph. And he's right. You shove that weapon of mass destruction up a virgin asshole and Arthur here can say goodbye to ever holding his shit in." Allison answered, matter-of-factly. Arthur gazed up at his knight in shining armor, eyes wide with gratitude.

An angry pout overtakes Daphne's ebony skin, and it's quite scary to be honest. For a brief moment, Arthur worries Daphne isn't going to heed any of their advices, that she's just going to shover herself inside Arthur and tear him apart, overloading him on every front until's he's begging for more and is nothing but her boytoy...

But thankfully (?), it doesn't come to that. Daphne picks up her meat stick, like a spear before standing up.

"It's not fair... everyone talks about how jealous they are of my BBC... but I can't do jack shit with it!" She cries out, her voice breaking. Arthur strangely, almost felt sorry for her?

However, this worry quickly dissipated when he felt Allison gently, slide his head off her thighs, before crawling slightly away, lying on her beg and lifting her legs, exposing her tight, pink asshole. Arthur gaped at how perfect it was. It was a beautiful, rosebud color with small black hair framing it, like a jewel.

"Mmm... now we're talkin'." Daphne growled as she strode over to Allison. She slapped her cock down on the Asian girl's taut stomach.

"Mmm.. fuck me, Daph!" Addison moaned as she began to jerk her cock.

Arthur's eyes were torn away from the sight when he felt two more bodies come up next to him. He looked up to see Diana and Lenna looking down on him, hunger in their eyes.

"So Artie? Who's gonna get your virginity?" Diana asked, her eyes shining. Arthur bit his lip, thinking hard.

"It's okay if you need some time to decide..." Lenna purred, softly placing a hand on his cock. Arthur moaned.

"You can watch them too... see if it inspires something in you!" Diana added on, slowly helping Arthur into a seated position. Arthur leaned back on both the girls as Lenna began to jerk him off. He suddenly gasped as he felt another slick finger slowly trace circles around his virgin asshole.

"Ohhh, FUCK!" Arthur moaned as the double stimulation began. He heard the two girl giggle behind him as they worked him, but Arthur's attention soon became preoccupied by the sight in front of him.

"FUCK YEAH! TAKE IT LIKE A GOOD SLUT!" Daphne growled as she pistoned her cock into Allison's asshole, a clap like thunder sounding each time her ebony crotch collided with Allison creamy buttcheeks.

"MMM~!" Allison moaned as Daphne rearranged her guts. She had her arms locked around her legs, which were flailing weakly in the air. "OH FUCK DAPH!" Allison cried out.

"YEAH! TAKE THAT BLACK COCK IN YOUR SLUTTY ASIAN PUSSY!" Daphne growled, clearly getting off on her dominance and raceplay. Addison groaned as Daphne reached down and violently grabbed her enormous milkers, tweaking Allison's red areolas with a macabre joy.

"NNNGH!" Allison cried out as her cock began to shoot out ropes of cum all over her own body. "FUCKKKK!" Allison cried out as Daphne's prostate **** overwhelmed her senses, giving her one of the best orgasms of her life. Arthur watched with subdued shock as she shot rope after rope of thick white liquid all over herself, coating not only her body but her pristine face and hair, all while Daphne kept relentlessly pounding her ass.

He gasped in shock as Daphne drew a hand back and smacked one of Lenna's tits, causing it to turn red and juggle violently.

"Did I say you could cum, you Asian whore?" She hissed, bending low enough to growl into Lenna's ear. Lenna moaned as Daphne's other hand came down on her ass with a brutal smack, leaving a faint red handprint.

"N-no!" Allison moaned, biting her lip in pleasure in pain.

"No, what, slut?" Daphne growled, roughly biting Allison's ear.

"N-no Mistress!" Allison moaned and Daphne launched one almighty thrust into the Asian girl, exploding inside her.

"Fffuck..." Daphne groaned as she came inside Allison's tight asshole. Slowly, the black domme pulled out, and Arthur gasped in shock as he saw copious amounts of thick cum begin to leak out from Allison's weakly spasming asshole.

"They're not usually this rough..." Diana murmured,and Arthur gasped as he felt her finger probe his anus. He was so caught up in watching Allison and Daphne (who were now lying on the floor side by side, covered in cum and sweat) go at it that he failed to realize Diana had slipped one whole finger inside him.

"Ungh~" Arthur moaned as he responded to Lenna's gently ministrations now on his testicles, slowly rubbing them as she whispered sweet nothings into his ear.

"Well now that you've seen that, Artie... who's going to get the pleasure of taking your cute little virgin asshole?" Lenna asked sweetly, soothingly scratching his scrotum. Arthur groaned in pleasure as he weighed his options.

On one side he had Diana, who had always been sweet and kind to him, even when he was a kid. She had a nice cock too, nice and girthy but she was definitely quite submissive, and he wasn't really sure if he wanted a sub to his first time.

On the other side was Lenna, his sister. Lenna had never been the best sister- when they were young she was awesome, standing to to anyone who bullied him and teaching him how to fight. But on the other hand, as they grew older, they did begin drifting apart and Lenna became a bit meaner, making fun of him, but Arthur knew she had always loved him.

So the decision persisted, with beautiful futagirls staring eagerly at him.

Who does Arthur give his anal virginity to?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)