Lenna

In the end, there really only was one choice. Diana had always been kind to him but... come on. His bombshell of a sister was offering herself up to him! Besides, she herself had blatantly expressed her desire to fuck the shit out of him.

"L-Lenna... will you...?" Arthur began, blushing furiously as a perverse, but loving smile plastered itself onto Lenna's face.

"It'd be an honor, lil bro." Lenna answered simply before slowly manoeuvring Arthur so he was lying down, flat on the floor. He locked eyes apologetically with Diana, but the chubby girl only smiled.

"Psh, who was I kidding. Even if you'd chosen me, I'd have wanted to you lose it to Lenna." The girl answered, warmth evading her voice. Lenna looked at Diana fondly, before reaching over and pressing a chaste kiss to her lips.

"But since you get the honor of deflowering him... I think I should be allowed to get him ready!" Diana quickly said. Lenna smiled, before nodding and moving backwards. Arthur frowned. Getting ready?

He understood what they meant very fast, as Diana dipped her head down between his legs and slowly ran her tongue up and down in asshole.

"Ohhh..." Arthur squealed as Diana's wet muscle gently teased his anus.

Diana giggled against his asshole, slowly pulling him down on her tongue.

"OHHH SHIT!" Arthur moaned as Diana slowly wiggled her tongue inside him, coating his ass in her saliva. He bucked his his hips into her face as she sensually tongued fucked him.

But almost as fast as it started, Diana pulled of his asshole, licking her lips.

"Mmm... you taste really good, Artie!" Diana giggled, before turning to Lenna and winking. She bent down, wrapping her lips around Leanna's rock hard cock, going all the way down twice before pulling off, wiping her mouth.

"There we go. You're all ready for each other!" She exclaimed excitedly, before scurrying out of the way. Lenna crawled forward until she was kneeling over Arthur, allowing his legs to wrap around her strong torso. He shivered in pleasure as he felt her cockhead tease his ass.

Slowly, Lenna eased the tip inside.

"OOOH FUCK!" Arthur cried out as he felt his ass penetrated. It strangely felt like he was shitting.

"MM... god, you're so tight!" Lenna moaned as she closed her eyes, biting her lip in pleasure. Slowly, she eased her hips forward and Arthur groaned as he felt her cock stretch his insides.

"Oh... you're so big, Lenna!" Arthur moaned.

"Halfway there!" She grunted ash she eased more and Arthur gasped with shoch. Halfway only? He already felt like he'd eaten a seven-course meal!

"Do you want it slow, or should I just shove it in?" Lenna asked as she bent down, whispering in his ear.

"Urgh... slow!" Arthur groaned out, rolling his hips in a vain attempt to accomodate the new intrusion, his sphincter already feeling sore.

Lenna groaned ash she pushed three more inches in, causing Arthur back to arch plesurably.

"FFUCK!" He cried out. "Oh god!" He moaned.

"Just... a bit more!" Lenna **** out, before with final push she completely buried herself inside him.

"NNNGH~" Arthur bit his teeth to **** back his cry of pain and pleasure.

"OH, FUCK!" Lenna cried out at the same time, feeling Arthur's insides cling onto her cock.

They both staye dfor a moment, adjusting to each other before Lenna bent down and gently pressed her lips to his, slipping her tongue inside his mouth and soothingly massaging his tongue with hers.

"Mmm..."Arthur moaned as Lenna slowly drew her hips back, before pushing them back in. Arthur's groans were muffled by the kiss as Lenna slowly began to thrust into her little brother, pulling out just three inches at a time before pushing them back in.

"Fuck, you're so good!" Lenna moaned as she pulled off Arthur mouth. She began to slowly thrust with more vigor and Arthur moaned in time with each thrust, feeling his prostate slowly getting hit.

"OHHH!" Arthur cried out as Lenna began pulling out more, now rocking the poor boytoy back and forth with each thrust.

Suddenly, three raps came at the door, and everyone froze.

"Arthur, baby... is everything alright? I've been hearing you moan for quite some time now..." He heard his Mother call out from behind the door. The boy's eyes widened, searching for an excuse.

"I-ah... I'm fine! UNGH~ just fell off the~ OH FUCK~ bed!" He **** out as Lenna continued to thrust into him, mischief in her eyes.

"Okay, baby. Come to my room is you need anything!" Andrea called back.

"Shhure- UNHH~" Arthur called back, moaning in pleasure as Lenna pistoned her cock with increasing vigor into him.

"L-Lenna..." Arthur began, before being silenced by a finger to his lips.

"Hush, lil bro. We can't have you making any noise now..." Lenna answered back, before bending her torso over Arthur and enticingly cupping her breasts. Arthur eyes widened as he understood what she meant.

Not needing more encouragement, Arthur eagerly latched onto one of his sister's rosy nipples, gently sucking.

"Mmm... that's it... good boy!" Lenna moaned as she began to pump harder into her brother, hammering his prostate.

"GUH!" Arthur gasped as he felt his balls stir.

"G-gonna cum!" He moaned as Lenna smiled, wrapping her hand around his cock and pistoning in and out of her boytoy with renewed vigor, stretching the limits of his ass.

Lenna growled and let out a particularly powerful thrust that hammered into his porstate with godly ****. Arthur yelled wildly into his sister's palm as his cock shot up and fired out ropes of cum into Lenna' waiting palm.

"Mmm..." Lenna murmured, licking his baby batter off her fingers. "Yummy!"

"Now... I have to make you cum!" Arthur answered, holding his legs up and moaning as Lenna began to fuck him with determination in his eyes "Not long now!" She moaned.

Suddenly, with a groan Arthur felt her cock twitch before he felt a wamrth blossom in his stomach.

"Fucckkkk..." Lenna moaned as she came deep inside her brother's ass, thrusting while shooting rope after rope of cum into him.

Slowly, she pulled her cock out of Arthur, and the boy gasped and the sudden emptiness he felt in his bowles, combined with the rapidly cooling cum that was steadily leaking out of him. Lenna collapsed onto the floot next to him, turning her head and smiling lazily at him.

"Love you, lil bro." She murmured, cradling his head. Arthur smiled, warmth blossoming in him. He turned his head to the side to see Diana pulling herself of Allison cock, cum dripping out of her asshole and covering Allison's cock.

"God... we should probably sleep now! It's like... two in the morning." He heard Daphne groan.

Slowly, the five of them trundled onto Arthur's bed. Somehow, they managed to fit a dude and four extremely large futas onto a two person bed with only a few creaks and one or two cracks. The sheets were very quickly stained wet from sweat and cum. Every time Arthur moved he rubbed against someone's cum- either Lenna's, which was still leaking out of his asshole or one of the other's girls' cum which was still rubbed onto their body like a moisturizer. Of course, this meant incredibly close proximity and Arthur found himself sandwiched in the middle of two girls while he was **** to lie down sideways.

Behind him was Lenna, her boobs pressing into his back like a soothing pillow and one of her legs wrapped protectively around him. Everytime Arthur shifted, he felt Lenna's soft cock rub against his back, and he was certain there was a large smear of her cum dripping down his back into his asscrack, also filled with her cum.

"Lenna? What if you get hard in the night?" Arthur asked, understandably worried. His sister giggled lazily.

"Doubt I will... my balls have been COMPLETELY drained! But if I do... you'll help me, won't you?" She asked weetly, sensually licking Arthur's ear. A shiver travelled down Arthur's spine as he thought of going down on her.

"Well, I do have school tomorrow but... I'll make an exception for you!" Arthur answered.

In front of him was Allison. He was eye level with her two impressive breasts, covered in someone's cum. He looked up, deep into Allison's deep brown eyes, and the Asian girl's face broke into a warm smile. She lifted her hand a brushed it through Arthur's hair, pulling it back and showing a small globule of her cum. She smiled, lifting it to her mouth and sucking.

"Hey... I wanted that!" Arthur said playfully. Allison chuckled lightly, before bending her head down and pulling Arthur in for a loving kiss, where she playfully snowballed her cum from her own mouth into his.

"Mmm..." Arthur murmured as he swallowed, before looking back at Allison. His heart fluttered and he felt butterflies in his stomach. Oh shit...

Arthur hadn't crushed on a girl in a long time, but when it did, it hit hard. Arthur remembered those torturous nights in middle school when he was crushing on his best friend Kathy. He always hated himself for never manning up.

But here he was, with another hot futagirl next to him, and to be fair he had been crushing on Allison ever since... well, ever since Lenna brought her home.