Waterfall secrets

“Just FYI Gavin, this is what skinny dipping actually looks like,” Heather said as she slowed her front stroke and glided over to the group.

“Oh my god, Heather!” screeched Ashley, laughing and swimming over to give her a hug.

The water was moderately opaque, especially under the shadow of the ledge that the waterfall fell from, so the boys were seeing more of a theoretical version of nudity than a practical one. Still, even the idea was enough to pump a little blood between the boys’ legs.

“Pfft, there’s a difference between skinny dipping on a dare and because you forgot to bring a suit,” Zack teased her.

“We all forgot to bring suits, I’m just making the most of it, darling,” Heather replied with a wink before continuing on. “Have you guys tried out the secret waterfall trick?”

“What secret waterfall trick?” Ashley asked.

“Did you guys ever see that movie ‘A Quiet Place?’ John Krasinski, Emily Blunt, deaf daughter, monsters that are blind but hear sound super well and are lightning fast?”

Gavin replied first, “Yeah, that rings a bell.”

“Okay, well they spend the whole movie having to use sign language and whisper, but there’s a waterfall they travel to where they can scream and shout to each other, but the waterfall drowns out anyone else from hearing it. It’s this big cathartic scene and then the characters converse in a normal voice rather than with sign or whispers for the only time in the movie,” Heather explained.

“Anyways,” she continued, “same principle here. If we swim over to the waterfall, two of us can stay in the water and two of us can go behind the waterfall and we won’t be able to hear each other.”

“Ooh that sounds fun, let’s try it!” Ashley said.

“Yeah, I gotta see this,” said Gavin.

“Okay, you two first then,” Heather said, “but remember, the whole point is that no one else can hear you. Say something juicy; Zack and I will do the same out here in the water, since you can’t hear us either. We’ll all switch and everyone will have a turn with everyone else. But keep it short and no long follow-ups. If you wanna know more, you gotta ask later, where someone might hear you.”

“Makes sense to me!” Ashley said cheerily, then hoisted herself out of the water to stand on the rocks underneath the waterfall. Zack stared unabashedly, watching the water gush down Ashley’s back, admiring the way her ass looked in her tiny panties. Heather took notice of Zack’s stares and nodded, happy that her girl seemed to have her crush in the palm of her hand. By the time she went to look at Gavin, he was already up and under the waterfall. Ah well, she was mostly interested in the front side anyway.

Once Ashley was under the waterfall, Zack turned back to Heather.

“Okay, me first. I thought Ashley invited me up to your cabin because I had a shot with her, but now I feel like I’m in the friend zone.”

Heather nodded and replied, “The friend zone is a state of mind, Zack. It’s up to you.”

Heather had always thought Zack was a pretty confident guy, so this whining about the friend zone was a bit surprising to see. Ashley had invited him up because she wanted him and more to the point, she still did. But she wasn’t going to give him all the answers; if he knew he didn’t have to work for it, she couldn’t be sure that he wouldn’t take advantage of her. She wanted to walk that line between telling him he still had a chance, without telling him it was a guarantee, but she had to err on the side of safety.

Underneath the waterfall, the more nervous pair looked at each other and giggled. Gavin still couldn’t believe he was standing across from one of the hottest girls from his high school, shyly clasping her hands together and with her head to her side, her eyes peeking back at him. He took in her slender body, appreciating how smooth it looked from the water.

“Okay Gavin,” Ashley said, frowning to control her giggles, but failing to contain a smile, “you are all set up to have a lot of fun this week, if you don’t screw it up.”

“I’m starting to get that feeling. Wait, how do I not screw it up?!” he asked, his eyes widening as he comprehended the latter part of the sentence.

“Sorry Gav, no follow ups,” Ashley winked, then motioned that he should hop back in the water.

Gavin slid into the water, seeing his best friend ready to hop out.

“Good luck,” Gavin whispered to him on the way by.

“You too,” Zack tried to mumble back, but he wasn’t sure if Gavin heard him.

“Hi Gavin, glad I got you all alone,” Heather said, slowly treading water towards him.

“Uh yeah, look how that happened,” he mumbled, looking away from the naked woman approaching him.

Heather smiled as she put her arms around his neck and pulled herself close. Christ, I’m so close to it, she thought! It’s a shame they needed their legs to tread; she couldn’t press her pussy onto his stiff cock the way she was pulling their chests together.

“Gavvy, baby, you can look,” she laughed. Oh, I like that laugh, Gavin thought hungrily to himself. Almost as much as he liked feeling how soft her tits were against him. Did she… like him? That was crazy, right?

“Uh wow Heather. Fuck, I wish I had something smarter to say, but I don’t know what I did to deserve this.”

She leaned towards him and whispered in his ear, just for fun, “Just remember it later on. Because I am going to get you naked, soon. That’s a Heather Ravers promise.”

“Yeah, about that! Why did you stop me last night?” Gavin’s curiosity was finally the key to unlocking his power of speech for full sentences.

“That’s one you’re going to have to find out later,” she laughed and released the hold on his shoulders, swimming away from him. “Now be a gentlemen and go back in the waterfall. I can’t get out, I’m naked under here, don’t you know?”

A coquettish smile ran across her lips. She might be the one naked and pressing her flesh into his, but she had him right where she wanted.

Meanwhile, Zack was staring at Ashley, trying desperately not to think about how he was in the friend zone and apparently had only himself to blame. He could fix this! He just needed the right words and he needed them now.

“Ashley, you look so hot in your underwear. Fuck, I can’t believe we’ve known each other for so long and I’ve never done anything about it! I should have asked you out years ago. I know this could get weird with our families and maybe we keep it a secret for a little because of that, but I think we get on really well and even if you say no, I just need you to know that I think you’re really pretty.” He hoped this wasn’t fucking it up. The fact that she wasn’t looking him in the eye was making him nervous

For her part, Ashley had been a bit of a ways into the pool when Zack dove in, so she took the time to appreciate his barely clothed body now. God, was there anything hotter than seeing your crush in wet boxers underneath a waterfall?! She watched a rivulet of water trail down from a tight chest, trickling through a six pack she wanted to put her lips all over, down towards the forbidden area, kindly guided by what Heather called “cum gutters”.

Ah fuck. She’d was so distracted looking at him, all she heard was “—think you’re really pretty.” Time to fake it.

“Aw thanks Zack, I think you’re pretty too!” she said, then gave an awkward smile and held up a peace sign before she cannonballed into the water.

Well, thought Zack, that’s a no. Fuck, I thought she liked me. Guess something happened between yesterday afternoon and today to fuck it up. Was it the truth or dare? She made out with Kurt, was she going to go for him now? It couldn’t be Gavin, could it?

Gavin and Ashley traded places for the last secrecy exchange.

“Hey dude,” Gavin greeted Zack.

“’Sup dude,” Zack replied.

“I don’t even know, man. First Ashley tells me I’m going to have a lot of fun this weekend if I don’t screw it up. Now Heather just told me she’s going to get me naked. That’s not even getting into me not knowing you lost your virginity last year, plus Chloe is all hot now and she danced on Kurt and flashed him. I’m just so confused, man.”

Zack had just had his heart broken, but he knew Gavin needed his help to, as Ashley had said, not screw it up, so he put his personal feelings aside for the benefit of his friends, like he had done so many times before.

“Look dude, Heather seems to like you. Ashley too, hell maybe even Chloe. I dunno if it’s serious, but if I were you, I’d enjoy living in the moment with all the hotties. Next time one of the girls says something like, ‘I’m going to get you naked’, kiss her, man!”

“Whoa, I thought the whole reason we were here this week is because Ashley specifically invited you? I’m not going to go for your girl, like I’d even get her.”

“I just asked her out and it was a no. Then she jumped in the water. Maybe she invited me to get to you?”

“I dunno man, that’s wild. I mean, I won’t go for her, bro code.”

“I don’t own her, Gavin, especially after she just said no. If you both want to do stuff, you should.”

“I really dunno man. Besides, it sounds like Heather is a sure thing and she’s super hot. Did you know she games?”

“L-O-L you would care about that. Nah, I didn’t know. But that’s good that you care about more than just how hot they are.

“I mean they are super hot though. I knew Heather and Ashley were (although seeing this much this close is like whoa), but Chloe, wow!”

“Yeah, our friend is coming out of her shell in a big way. Alright, let’s get back in the water, I’ve never spent this much time talking to another dude in his boxers.”

Just as the male best friends were sorting things out, so too were the women.

“Gah, I think I just screwed things up with Zack,” Ashley said.

“Oh why, pray tell?” Heather cocked an eyebrow.

“I was staring at his body in those boxers and I wasn’t paying attention to what he said, so all I caught was that he told me I was pretty, so I said he was pretty too and ran off.”

“Stellar performance, girl. He just told me he was worried about being in the friend zone. I told him it was a state of mind, sounds like he listened and did something about it. I’m sure he’ll try to stick his tongue down your throat or ask you out soon or something.”

“Eww, Heather, why’ve you gotta be so gross!”

“I said or ask you out!”

“Ugh, you’re so gross.”

“You love me.”

“I do. Okay, what about our Gavin situation? I told him he was going to have a fun week if he didn’t screw it up, what did you do?”

“Ooh, so I shimmied over to him and pulled myself close so our chests were touching, then I told him I was going to get him naked soon!”

“Girl! Oh my god, he better get the hint after that!”

“I know. I feel like I’ve already broken so many of my rules about going first with him. If this fucker doesn’t take the hint soon—”

“—it’s just going to make you even hornier?” Ashley finished her friend’s sentence and stuck her tongue out, grinning.

“I mean yeah, but don’t tell him that!”