Wait for his return.

You hear his voice calling out, asking the three of you to wait in his bedroom. The two boys lead you to a nearby door and bring you to a queen sized bed. The walls are decorated with varying posters from video games to movies to quite a few barely clothed models. You sit on the bed's edge, still covering yourself, and wait for Oliver's return.

Eventually he steps inside and closes the door. In his hand are five slips of paper. Presumably, things are written on the bottom but he doesn't allow you to see. He holds them out towards you.

"Pick one, miss. I'm fair. Whatever it says is your fate for this evening. One of them says you're free to go. I'll even let you borrow a shirt. I don't want anybody to say Oliver isn't a nice guy."

Five choices, but you have no idea what any of them do. Did one really say she could go? No strings attached? There's only one way to find out...