Try just being honest

I try to control the situation. "Susie, I swear I have a good explanation for this, but you have to close the door behind you"

She glares. Now I know for sure that I hadn't been used my ring since we left the ice cream parlor until we went into her bathroom, because she was not complying with what I asked her to do. Should I try to **** her? I probably should have done that earlier, now she was going to offer resistance if she felt something overtaking her body. I breathe a sigh of relief when she finally nods and closes the door behind her.

"How illegal?" She whispers to us, completely serious. I honestly don't blame her for having her mind go there immediately, the reality of the situation was way weirder.

"Not illegal, actually. Well, I don't think it's illegal, at least. Anyway, you're gonna have to trust me on this, but look at the mirror and say a color." Not sure if this was the best way to show her my powers, but that was what first occurred to me and so it would be what I go with.

"Are you really going to let her know you have powers?" Regina asks me in a whisper, and fair enough, not perhaps my smartest reaction to a crisis, but I'm committed to it now. I nod as I look at Susie contemplate for a moment before she decides to might as well see what was the cause of this madness.

"Purple" She says, and so I concentrate for a second in changing her dreads to that color. She screams in awe as she looks at that. "I have a magic mirror?" She seems really confused as to how we found that before she did.

"Almost. I have a magic ring." I bring it to her attention by bringing my hand closer to her face. "Since this morning, I think. Didn't bother to look at the clock when I got it." I shrug.

"It was pretty early in the day, I'm sure it was during the morning." Regina offers her input.

Susie takes a moment to look carefully at her. We make jokes about her being blatant in checking out my friend, but Susie rolls her eyes at me. "You created yourself a girlfriend?"

Regina, the lovely person who loves me deeply that she is, falls to the ground in laughter, leaving me looking horribly guilty of a crime that I haven't committed. It's almost tempting me to go with it.