Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 101 by daciasdesire daciasdesire

What does Spencer say?

Try, and find out.

Spencer thought back to all the things Mia had said to him that day. They had to have been hints she was dropping. It was more than just talk, they’d been flirting, Mia wanted Spencer to come onto her. Why else would she mention snogging in the shed and talk about the size of his cock just now. He didn’t think of Dani as he reached out and took Mia’s hand in his. She didn’t shy away from the contact.

“Why don’t you have a feel and tell me.”

Spencer brought Mia’s delicate small hand over and placed it down over his straining bulge. Her fingers spread out and curled around contouring to the thickness of his shaft.

“That’s… very big,” Mia gasped.

Spencer huffed out his breath. It felt incredible having Mia’s hand wrapped around his cock right then. He could feel his ears getting hot from her touch and she wasn’t even moving her hand.

“Think you could take me?” Spencer croaked.

“I don’t know.”

Mia had never experienced anything that large. It was beyond her comprehension and she was still to explore its full dimensions. Bringing her second hand over, Mia used the two of them to size up the full length of Spencer’s cock. Her hands naturally began to stroke tantalisingly along the shaft as Mia cupped and massaged Spencer’s balls when she came to them.

“Oh fuck!” Spencer moaned as Mia practically tugged at his cock through his trousers.

At his words, she looked up into his eyes and with that contact, Spencer leaned forward and kissed Mia. Mia returned it right away, their tongues sliding into the other’s mouths as they passionately made out. Mia cranked the movement of her arm to tug Spencer’s cock urgently. Spencer reached a hand out and gripped the back of Mia’s slender neck as they grazed on each other. His other hand reaching Mia’s tucked knees on the seat and then sliding up and between her legs toward her pussy.

Mia’s parted her knees reflexively but it was as Spencer’s reached the very top of her inner thighs, just below her panties, that Mia froze. Locking down on Spencer and preventing him from travelling any further.

“No, Spencer, we can’t.” Mia broke off the kiss and let go of his prick.

Spencer blinked in shock for a second and then snatched his hand away in fright. His mind raced to Dani and the sudden implications of what he had just done to her. “Mia! My God. I’m so incredibly sorry. I can’t believe I just did that. Oh God, please forgive me.”

“Spencer… I need to go,” Mia was disorientated by her own feelings.

Mia snatched up her discarded shoes and handbag from the bottom of the Maserati and was out of the car and running to the front door of the house in seconds. Spencer’s heart was racing. He was certain that Mia would tell Dani what had just happened and that his relationship would be over the second she found out. Poor Dani had been cheated on by someone she trusted already. It would crush her to go through that a second time. Spencer’s stomach was in his ankles as he pulled out of the driveway and he felt like he was driving home to his funeral.

Inside the house, Mia put her forehead against the door the moment it was shut. Her pulse was racing just like Spencer’s. She’d stopped him just before he’d touched her panties as she didn’t want him to discover right away just how hot and wet her pussy had become. He would think she was easy and lose respect for her right away. She’d only said they couldn’t as a way to slow things down and perhaps move things inside the house. Mia had been thinking of giving herself to Spencer but had wanted him to have to work for it a little bit and not give it up right away in his car like a teenager. She was too old for that sort of behaviour anymore despite how soaking wet it had made her. When Spencer had freaked out and started apologising, Mia had panicked too and ran. She didn’t want Spencer running back to Dani and telling her what they’d done.

Spencer was only a few miles from his house and hadn’t been able to calm himself down yet. Worst-case scenarios were running through his mind. He pulled over to the side of the road and took his phone from his pocket. He had to attempt to salvage the situation before it was too late. He began composing a hurried text to Mia. God, what if she was on the phone with Dani already?

‘Mia, I am so sorry. It was a horrible mistake but I am begging you to keep this between the two of us. Dani doesn’t have to know.’

He hit send and waited, praying for a favourable reply.

Mia was in the kitchen drinking a cold glass of water to cool off when she heard the chime from her phone. Please be Spencer, Mia thought as she ran for her phone and read the text. With an absolute sense of relief, Mia dropped into a kitchen chair. Spencer wasn’t going to split the beans. Mia was safe. It took her several attempts to come up with the right thing to say back. Deleting and retyping the message over and over.

Spencer could see Mia writing. The typing bubble disappeared and reappeared several times. Spencer could only imagine the horror of what Mia was sending him as it took an increasingly long time to receive her reply. Eventually, it came.

‘I agree. It was a mistake. I will keep this to myself and expect you to do the same.’

Spencer breathed a deep sigh. Safe!

‘Should we talk about this some time?’

‘I don’t think that’s a good idea right now.’

‘Not now. Of course. Later?’

‘I don’t know. I need time to think.'

‘Take all the time you need to think. I’m sorry once again.’

‘Please let’s just forget this for now.’

‘You’re right. Good night, Mia.’

‘Good night, Spencer.’

In truth, Mia didn’t trust herself to talk to Spencer right then without inviting him to come over and then she really didn’t trust herself. Touching Spencer’s big cock was like opening a Pandora’s box for her. With everything Dani had said about Spencer, feeling that gigantic pole between his legs had been the key to unlocking a curiosity that would take a long time to get out of her mind. Walking up the stairs to her bedroom, Mia felt like she could imagine Spencer’s hardness inside her body already and it made her ache the plenty with longing.


At home, either Dani or Spencer’s mom had seen to the dishes. The kitchen area was returned to its immaculate condition and everyone was in the living room area with Amy providing her grandparents with a reenactment of various plays from her most recent softball game. Spencer went quickly to the kitchen and fetched him another beer from the fridge. He needed it to calm himself right then. Beer in hand he joined the rest of them in the lounge, sitting in an armchair next to Dani. He felt a compulsion to keep a little distance between them.

Later when everyone was going to bed, Spencer took a quick shower, to wash his sins off perhaps, before he was ready to join Danielle in bed. Dani had been reading a book as she waited for Spencer but when he got in bed, she put it down and turned to him.

“Did Mia say anything to you in the car on the way home?” Dani asked.

“No. Why?” Spencer answered trying not to come across too defensively.

Dani’s forehead furrowed. Oh shit! Mia had told her after all and Dani was just waiting until they were in private to have a fight and dump him, Spencer thought to himself.

“Good. I asked her not to say anything until I’d had a chance to speak with you,” Dani began.

Optimistically Spencer realised it wasn’t about Mia and him but something else. It came as an instantaneous relief.

“A position is opening up in Boston as a Regional Manager at the bank. It’s only temporary but Mia has offered it to me.”

“Oh wow!” Spencer breathed. He was in the clear. It wasn’t about him at all. “That’s a really big opportunity. You’d be fantastic at it.”

“Do you really think so?” Dani asked.

“Of course! You’ve been killing it at your job already, Mia’s said so herself. Why should this be any different.”

“Mia said it’s only for a month and I’ll be able to fly back with her on weekends. The money would come in handy too. It’s not until January so I have a little bit of time to decide.”

“I’m not sure what there is not to like?”

“I’ll be away from you and Amy during the week.”

“We’ve been apart for longer and got through it. Will you be able to go without me for a few days at a time?”

Dani laughed and punched Spencer in the arm before pulling herself tight into him for a hug and a kiss. “So, were going to do this?”

“It’s up to you but I think, yeah,” Spencer confirmed.

For the first time in her life, Dani thought that she really might have everything. A handsome, loving and dependable man and a career that was just starting to go places. The world was hers for the taking.

And so was Spencer.

Pressing forward, Dani bowled Spencer onto his back as she climbed over and mounted at the same time. She kissed him ravenously and reach down between them for his cock finding it hard as she’d expected. She reached into his pyjama bottoms and stroked Spencer's prick, making him moan into her mouth. Dani used her other hand to start pulling Spencer’s pants down.

“What are you doing?” Spencer whispered as Dani lined herself up on top of him.

She pulled the panties she’d worn to bed that night aside and ran the fat head of Spencer’s cock along her wet slit. “I want you so bad.”

“The noise,” Spencer reminded her just as he felt his cock start to be swallowed up by Dani’s hot pussy.

“I’ll be quiet,” Dani promised.

She did her very best to keep that promise. Spreading her knees out and lowering herself onto the flagpole below. “Urrgh,” she grunted as Dani’s pussy was once again stretched out to breaking point. She could feel the blissful pressure of such a big cock pushing up into her stomach it seemed. Her clit came alight as her petals were spread out tight and the sensitive nubbin was exposed. Bouncing, Dani concentrated on just staying silent. Along the bottom three inches of Spencer’s dick, she slid, her lover’s thrust throwing her up into the air as she greasily slithered back down. It was feeling incredible as always. Jammed packed from within, Dani could feel the beginnings of what was promising to be a very large and powerful orgasm approaching. Dani could feel the heat rising. It was getting hot in their bedroom. Her nightie felt too tight and constricting. She wanted it off and gone. Pulling it up over her head Dani leaned backwards and pressed her pelvis forward until she was naked. The extra angle etched Spencer’s tip into her cervix. She collapsed forwards, tits smothered against Spencer’s chest. Spencer grabbed Dani’s arse and pounded her cunt from below. Each slam of motion rasped Dani’s clit against Spencer’s thatched pubes. The fuse was lit and Dani erupted.

Spencer gasped as his girlfriend came. The unworldly pleasure throbbing through him from her gripping pussy was counterpoised by a circle of pain in the exact spot Dani had bitten down on Spencer’s shoulder to keep herself from screaming as she orgasmed. Spencer gritted his teeth as for a full minute Dani’s jaw locked down harder and harder on his goose-bumped flesh. He was sure she would be drawing blood when she let go.

To Spencer's relief, Dani finally let go and remained panting rapidly on top of him. Against all odds, she hadn’t screamed once.

“Get on top, finish me off,” Dani told Spencer now that she was back in control of her responses.

Lifting Dani off him, Spencer switched places with her. As he stretched out and prepared to re-enter again, it wasn’t Dani’s petite redheaded body below him in Spencer’s mind's eye. Instead, he had been picturing Mia as Dani had been on top fucking him. Right now, Spencer imagined that it was Mia’s lithe, slender Indian body that he was about to surge into. Spencer’s cock found home and he thought of fucking Mia. It was Mia’s body below him responding to his movement, her scent of arousal that was invading his nose, her gasps coming to Spencer’s ears and Mia’s taste in Spencer’s mouth as he kissed Dani.

It drove the animal in Spencer wild. As hard as he dared, he rammed his cock into Dani. The slaps coming from her arse and thighs were as loud and rhythmic as a percussion drum.

Dani's head swam as Spencer gave the rough and dirty fucking she’d been craving. She was virtually speechless from just how hard she was being used mercilessly. She loved it. Fuck if she wasn’t going to come again though. There was no way she could stop from shouting this time Dani knew. She was cock drunk and practically out of her senses. She said the only thing that could keep her quiet as her peak came crashing down again. “I’m close. **** me!”

Spencer’s hand closed tight around Mia’s imaginary neck and he busted instantly.

Stars shot through Dani’s eyes as her orgasm and lack of oxygen combined. Completely consumed by orgasm she would never know just how close she might have come to passing out. Her own climax and then pulsing shooting cock inside her were the only two things that existed in the universe as far as Dani knew.

Spencer shuddered as his cock pulsed one final time. The ultimate squirt of cum joining its brothers inside Danielle’s repainted pussy wall. As his orgasm died, his vision cleared. The veil lifted and it was once again Dani well tussled ruddy locks below him and her delicate pale throat he was clutching. Spencer relaxed his grip and Dani took in a sudden gasping breath of precious air. Well-contented moans sounded conclusively.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)