Truth or dare with your girls.

After everyone takes a quick shower (one at a time, in order to actually get cleaned), you all put on your pajamas and sit and lay on the mattresses, talking and simply enjoying each other’s company. You get some snacks for everyone as well. Cookies, mostly.

“Hahaha! I haven’t been in a sleepover since I was 19.” Emma laughs.

“This is actually my first.” Sophia admits, shyly.

“I promise you they’re not all like this one.” Megan tells her with a big grin.

Emily nods in agreement. “Yep. This was a wild one. And it’s not even over yet.”

“Remember we need to go to school tomorrow.” You tell them. You might be able to get by just sleeping four hours, but they can’t. And the trait is way too expensive to give it to everyone. Maybe you should save your points for that?

“Yeah, but it’s only 10:00 pm.” Emily argues. “Let’s do something fun!”

“Like what?” Sophia voices your own thoughts.

“Let’s play truth or dare!” Megan offers excitedly. “It’ll help us know each other better.”

Doesn’t sound like the most exciting idea, but you agree. Finding out how Emily and Megan were hiding their attraction towards Emma and Sophia is what influences your decision.

You all get in a circle and since the only bottle you have around is full of juice, you end up using a six-sided dice you had lying around, with the rules being the following:

1) Is You

2) Is Emma

3) Is Emily

4) Is Megan

5) Is Sophia

6) Is a Reroll.

Megan throws the dice on a bowl and you all see it land on 2.

“Emma, truth or dare?” Megan asks.

“Truth.” Emma answers confidently.

Megan takes a deep breath and asks. “How did you feel about us kissing?”

Wow. Starting with the big questions from the get-go.

“I don’t know.” Emma ponders. “We were all really horny, so I can’t answer clearly. At that moment, though, I liked it. It was new.” She smiles. “Wouldn’t mind doing it again.”

Megan and even Emily seem relieved and genuinely happy with that answer.

Emma takes her turn and rolls the dice. It lands on a 5.

“Sophia, truth or dare.”

“Truth.” She answers with a deep breath.

“Where would you draw the line concerning what you’d allow David to do to you?”

Okay, this game might actually be pretty interesting.

Sophia blushes, but thinks hard about it. “Probably… anything that hurts too much.” She answers. "I… think I’d be okay with spanking, maybe even fuzzy handcuffs. I don’t think I could go beyond that, though.”

“Oh! Handcuffs sound kind of fun!” Megan giggles.

Huh. Good to know.

Sophia rolls. It lands on a 1.

“David, truth or dare?”

You kind of what to say dare simply because you’ve already revealed your biggest secret to them, but they might also have other things to ask that you’re unaware of. Also, you’ve only been with Sophia for about a day, so you’ll let her ask what she wants.

“Truth.”

“Do you have a specific limit on how many girls you’ll end up with? If so, what’s that number?”

…

Letting the captain of the debate team ask a question. Brilliant, Walker.

Man, you’ve been pushing that thought aside for a while. You always knew you needed a limit, but what was that limit.

Okay, the four girls here are staying, plus Mia and probably Jessica, so you’re at 6 minimum. Katherine is also into you, and you’d be lying to yourself if you said you weren’t into her, too. She can be rude at times, but you feel you get where she’s coming from, so it ends up being a little endearing. That’s 7. Any other girls that come to mind at this moment?

…

Dammit. Olivia Hughes comes to mind. She has a big crush on you, is incredibly hot, and Jessica says she’s been trying to change. Purely based on looks, yeah, you want to be with her. But if she hasn’t changed then there’s no point.

Aside from her… You subconsciously look at Emily, and remember that her sister has a growing lust score for you. Ms. Miller is one of the hottest teachers in the school, rivaling Emma and Mia. She was also one of the teachers who supported you on getting a decent place to live.

“Urgh… uh… Ten?” You end up answering, unsure of yourself.

The four girls think about that number of a few moments.

“I thought you’d want more.” Emily admits.

“Ten is still a lot though.” Megan says. “But if that a lifelong limit, then I guess it’s not that many.”

“Only relative to the amount of women he’ll meet. Still, good to know you do have a self-imposed limit.” Sophia nods.

“I agree. Too many and you won’t get to really know them. Don’t bite more than you can chew, love.” Emma adds.

So they’re okay with ten? You agree ten is still a lot. Man, having a five-way really puts things into perspective.

Your turn to roll. Great, now you have a song stuck on your head. Al least it’s good. Oh, that’s a 2 again.

“Emma, truth or dare?” You ask.

“There’s been too many truths, so dare.” She eyes you challengingly.

“Okay. Then I want you to kiss Emily.” You tell her, making her raise her eyebrow. “Go as far as you’re comfortable with.”

“Alright, fine.” She giggles. She probably saw this coming. The one that didn’t see this coming was Emily, who looks nervous. Megan rubs her shoulders, telling her to just leave everything to Emma.

The teacher closes in, face to face with her blonde student. Of course, your angel has a reassuring, calming smile that could put a raging lion at ease.

Their lips meet in a soft kiss, and Emma seems more comfortable kissing a girl now than she did before. She holds Emily by the waist, and she reciprocates. Emma gets daring and adds a little tongue, licking Emily’s lips. The blonde takes this as encouragement and slips a bit of her own. Before long, they both sharing a tender, but full on French kiss.

“Was I good?” Emma asks.

“Very.” Emily says, tasting her own lips.

“This is actually pretty fun.” Emma admits, grinning excitedly and returns to her spot. She rolls the dice and it lands on a 3.

“Hey, what do you know? Emily, truth or dare?”

“Truth.”

“What would you say if your sister had her eye on David?”

THIS WOMAN IS A MIND READER! A MIND READER I TELL YOU.

Emily blinks. “If Julia had her eye on- Oh my God!” Her eyes widen and she covers her mouth with her hands. “No wonder she’s been asking about him so much lately!”

“Yeah, she’s been asking the other teachers how he’s doing in other classes and if he’s still getting bullied. I think she might be into you.” Emma tells you.

Wait, she’s been asking about you?

“David, check your phone thing!” Emily demands.

Weird to be checking a person’s score on another’s behalf, but hey.

-Miller, Julia-
Affection Score: 33. (+2)
Lust Score: 20 (+4)

You tell them, adding that the last time you saw her lust score was at 16 and that you honestly have no idea where it came from.

“So she just wants to do it, then?” Sophia asks.

“It’s probably more that she thinks he’s cute, and I don’t blame her.” Emma nods to herself. “So? What do you think?” She asks Emily.

“I don’t know.” She ponders. “Julia has had boyfriends before. Nothing very serious, but definitely not on the level of our mom. If she does have her eye on David, I’d have to warn her what she’s getting into. Though I guess it’d be nice to have her here. I’d get to spend more time with her.” She frowns at the skeptical looks everyone gives her. “What? Contrary to popular belief, I like my sister!” She keeps thinking about it of a few moments, but doesn’t say anything else. She just rolls the dice.

And it’s a 4.

“Megan, truth or dare?”

“Truth!”

So many truths. But then again, you bet most of the usual dares would fall flat between you since you’ve already done so much.

“Who in the school would you like David to date so that you could get your hands on her?”

So now you’re the proxy for the bisexual girls to be with other girls? Huh. Points for making the best out of this situation.

Megan purses her lips and looks nervously to everyone. No, she’s just avoiding having to look at Emily.

“… Ms. Miller.” She finally answers.

“Wha-? Seriously?”

The wheels on the bus go round and round, round and round, round and round!

“What? Can you blame me? I’ve know you since middle school, Em! That means I’ve known your sister for just as long, and she’s freaking sexy!” Megan defends herself.

They all look at you curiously.

“Will you be going after Ms. Miller then?” Sophia asks.

“Don’t make it sound like I’m some sort of predator.” You frown. “But… maybe? I’d have to get to know her first, of course.”

“You’d like her a lot.” Emily sighs. “Just… promise not to compare us too much. I know she’s sexier than me.”

“Oh don’t give me that!” You frown. You reach your hand and grab her wrist, pulling her towards you. With a yelp, she comes to you and you have her sit on your lap with her back against your chest, wrapping your arms around her waist as you kiss her neck. “I told you before I can’t resist you.”

She giggles. “Okay, sorry. My inferiority complex is showing.” She leans back against you and gets comfortable. “Can I stay here for a while?”

“Sure.” You answer, holding your girlfriend.

It’s Megan’s turn to roll the dice. She gets a four, so she rerolls only to get a six… and a six again, making everyone laugh. Finally, the dice lands on 1.

“David, truth or dare?”

“Dare.” You answer, trying to keep things interesting.

Megan’s eyes glitter with mischief. “I dare you to send Ms. Owens a sexy text.”

Your back runs cold as everyone else goes “Uuuuh”. You really underestimated Megan, the little trickster.

“Urgh! Fine!” You get your phone, but stare at the blank message screen for a full minute. “I don’t know what to write.” You admit painfully.

“Just tell her you want to bed her already!” Emma encourages, though she does so with an annoyed frown. Is she mad that it hasn’t happened already?

“Can’t it be something more subtle?”

“Then tell her you want to subtly bed her!” Emma repeats.

“Ok, I’m not listening to your suggestions anymore. Anyone else?”

“Isn’t your date this Saturday?” Sophia reminds you.

That gives you an idea. On your lap, Emily sees what you’re typing and reads it out loud for everyone.

“I happened to see you leaving a lingerie store the other day. Our date is this Saturday and you said you wanted to make it a weekend. Should I get my hopes up?”

“Oh boy!” Emma laughs.

“Not what I had in mind, but it’ll do.” Megan approves.

Aaand sent.

Everything suddenly gets very quiet. No one speaks a word. Their eyes are stuck to your phone.

Buzz.

“Read it!” They order in unison, making you flinch and almost making you drop the phone.

“I don’t know why you’d want to see an old lady in her underwear. They’re not even good. They’re missing a lot of fabric.” You read out loud, audibly swallowing.

“Oops! Someone’s waking up!” Emily laughs, most certainly feeling your boner on her butt.

“Sorry. The mental images are too strong.”

“Oh I don’t mind.” Emily grins, slowly grinding her ass on your hardening cock. “Let’s keep playing.”

The game doesn’t last that much longer before you decide to go to sleep. True, going for another round of sex is tempting, but there’s school tomorrow. You can’t just succumb to every tempting opportunity before you. There will be more opportunities… hopefully.