Tolerant

"It doesn't affect me either way" says Nancy. "All the people I would want to recruit are girls anyhow, and girls are the way we build more energy to save the world. Nothing we can get from a guy that we can't get from a girl."

Ashley looks you in the eye for a few seconds. "OK. I get it. You're the key to crazy magical power and you want a harem out of it. As long as you know that you're not in charge of us, I'll accept magical powers and magic dick in exchange for my usual wide variety of dick."

Jill speaks up next. "You have magic. I'm not risking that. Make me one promise: If we need to include more guys to explore some areas of magic, you won't give us an ultimatum over it."

You think about it. You're living a sexual fantasy, you can afford to be fair and reasonable. "As long as your experiments don't cost us more energy than we gain."

"As long as you count my first time as part of that, deal." She actually sticks out her hand and you shake on it. With the rest of these girls in the room, it's so easy to forget that Jill is an innocent.

"Am I getting diamonds?"

Someone hands her the tiny one from earlier. "Keep it" you add, still trying to figure out if someone has said her name at some point. She gets a greedy grin on her face and the metal flower she made seems to liquefy and form a new ring, this time with a diamond. "You make orgasms into diamonds?"

"And I save the world at the same time. That's less than one orgasm worth of diamond."

Her grin grows. It's sort of gross how she's so mercenary, but at least you know where she stands. "Let's work on a big fat 5 carat!"

The last two girls are Gwen and Julie. Gwen is clearly unsure, so you try to sweeten the deal.

"Hey, you don't have to decide now. You can come up with some sort of personal reward later. I can promise that it'll be fucking hot in the meantime."

She still doesn't look decided, but Ashley comes to the rescue again. "He has unlimited dicks that never get soft and apparently he's better with his tongue than that lesbian sex god, Kim."

She smiles and you look at Julie who just waves you off. Hopefully that's a good thing.

"OK. If that's settled then next step is recruitment. We should each figure out who we know."

"Can't we just call all our friends and see who answers?"

"Throw the biggest orgy in national history!"

"No, we need to be careful. This stuff is dangerous, and maybe secret."

"I'm not sure if we need to be that careful really, but we should go one at a time."

The girls seem split, so you can probably take the lead here.