Tibby takes Ashley's place.

Your kitty nods rapidly, a devious glint in her eyes.

The whisper voice continues. "Good. Get naked too."

Tibby's clothes fly off in record time, and yours join them on the floor. "Now come here, on my lap."

You sit down where you just were, and Tibby wastes no time sitting on you. She's as aroused as you are from watching Ashley squirm, so you just position your cock under her and slide right in. Tibby doesn't hold back a groan as you fill her pussy, and Ashley must have heard it. She looks over from the kitchen and her jaw drops as she sees what you're doing. Clutching an arm full of snacks to her chest, she runs back to the couch. "Hey! You can't do that while I'm suffering like this."

"Oh yeah? Watch me," Tibby taunts, already starting to grind on you. "Besides, you did the same thing yesterday."

"That was not the same!" Ashley exclaims. "You were sitting on his face at the time, not being **** to edge yourself."

Tibby doesn't respond, instead bouncing her hips to fuck you with fast, shallow thrusts. You gasp, not prepared for the pace she's setting. But you still have the presence of mind to tell that Ashley isn't enjoying this as much as Tibby did when it was her turn. Let alone as much as she's enjoying it right now.

Maybe it's time to end her punishment, but you want her to edge just a little longer. Through your groans, you manage to tell her to put down the snacks and sit on the table. "If you can touch yourself until we're done, without cumming, I'll let you stop edging early."

"Fine, but you're both jerks." Relief evident in her voice, Ashley dumps the snacks on the table and perches herself on its edge. Staring right at Tibby, who is cupping her own breasts as she grinds on your dick, Ashley spreads her legs and slides her hands up her thighs. It looks like she's trying to pace herself so she'll last until you cum, but when she reaches her needy cunt she can't help slipping her fingers in deep.

Ashley's mouth opens to let out a little "oh fuck" the first time she touches her sensitive pussy, and she strokes her insides a few times before forcing herself to pull out. "Ohhh, you better cum soon John, there's no way I can hold back while watching this."

To be honest, you can already feel your orgasm approaching. It's just a matter of time with the way Tibby is riding you, and being able to watch Ashley finger herself help too. Tibby must feel the same way since her grinding gets even more intense. She mews loudly as your cock rubs against her inner walls, and the sound is accompanied by your groans and Ashley's subdued moans.

Grabbing Tibby's butt, you start lifting her in time with her own movements to add even more **** to her bouncing. You bottom out with every thrust, and when you gently bite her shoulder she lets out a surprised squeal, her pussy gripping you tightly as she cums. That sets you off as well, and you pull her down as you fill her pussy with your seed.

Tibby gasps and squirms for a while before settling in to snuggle against you, your arms coming up to wrap around her sides. Looking over her shoulder, you can see that Ashley is right on the edge as well.