Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by reaper13 reaper13

Which guy do the twins find?

They find Kinkade

Glenna starts her search for her next victim and I follow her. While she is searching, I have my thoughts occupied by the supposed apology sex with Fionn that Glenna suggested. I am sure that he was looking forward to losing his virginity at Samhain. That may very well be ruined now. Gosh, I feel so bad about that. I guess I could always help him lose his virginity tomorrow, like Glenna said. I don’t think I would be brave enough to go and talk to him, though. But suppose I did?

Sadly, I can’t think too much about it, because Glenna grabs me by the arm and says, “There, it’s Kinkade.” While pointing at him. Looks like she has found her next toy.

She raises her hand and starts waving at Kinkade while yelling, “Heeeey!! Kinkade!! Over here!!”

Seriously. That’s the second time she is yelling. There’s more than one guy in the forest tonight, Glenna. Fortunately, it was indeed only Kinkade.

As soon as he sees us, he starts walking towards us. Another poor guy willingly stepping into Glenna’s trap. Though when Kinkade stands before us, I am getting a bit of a blush. He is a lot more muscled than Fionn is. Not only that, but he also has a bigger penis. I wonder if maybe that’s because Kinkade spends a lot of time working with the cattle.

Please log in to view the image

“Good evening, Kinkade.” My sister says seductively. “I see that you still have to find a girl for tonight. Any chance you’re willing to have two at once?”

Glenna makes sure to make herself extra presentable by standing with her legs wide, allowing Kinkade to have a good look at her pussy. I am barely brave enough to just stand nude in front of a guy, let alone with my legs wide open. So, I just try and strike a sensual pose instead of one that is sexy.

Please log in to view the image

With both of us presenting ourselves to Kinkade like this, I assumed he would stare his eyes out at us just like Fionn did. Except Kinkade is a lot more reserved. He is not doing it as blatantly as Fionn did. I guess it must have been because it was Fionn’s first Samhain. I am happy Kinkade doesn’t stare as much. He makes me feel more at ease. But then Kinkade’s dick starts to grow and turn upright and become hard and I realize that behind his eyes, he must be thinking very dirty things about me and my sister. Knowing that Kinkade is having naughty thoughts of my sister and me quickly makes me shy again.

Kinkade smiles and answers Glenna’s question by shrugging and saying, “Sure. I think I can take you two on.”

Glenna doesn’t wait any longer and quickly hangs onto Kinkade’s right arm, like she did to Fionn. If it worked on Fionn last time, I guess it’ll work now on Kinkade as well. So, I hug Kinkade’s left arm, bring my hand to his dick, just like Glenna, and we start jacking it off.

As I make my hand slide up and down Kinkade’s shaft, I can’t help but compare it to Fionn’s. Kinkade’s dick is both longer and thicker and I stare at it with mouth agape.

“Have you ever had 2 girls touching your dick at the same time, Kinkade?” Glenna asks him. “Feels good, doesn’t it?”

I am so engrossed in staring at Kinkade’s dick that I don’t even notice Glenna saying something. Instead, I absentmindedly say, “It’s so big.”

Kinkade turns his face to me and asks, “You think so? Yeah, I guess I am pretty lucky with a size like that. You can totally ride it first if you’re interested.”

Oh shit. Did I really say that out loud? Crap, now he will expect an answer. I get all nervous say, “W-well... it s-sure is bigger than I've ever seen before...”

“Alright, thanks Glenys.” Kinkade says. “Here is a thank you for letting me know.”

He then pulls his arm from my grasp, which he does very easily, and places his now free hand behind my head. Once Kinkade has me where I can no longer get away, he pulls my head towards his and forces his lips onto mine. I am too surprised at the sudden kiss that I don’t know how to respond. I look at Glenna for guidance, but all she does is open her mouth and stick her tongue out as if she’s kissing someone. I guess that means she wants me to kiss him back. Alright then.

I close my eyes and open my mouth for Kinkade and allow his tongue inside my mouth. His tongue quickly finds mine and he caresses my tongue with his. It feels nice. Kinkade is actually a pretty good kisser. I take a deep breath and let a small moan escape me. Before I know it, I am actively kissing Kinkade back. I feel his hand move away from my head and slide down to grope my butt. Ah, Kinkade is making me wet.

Just as I was getting really into it, Kinkade breaks the kiss. I open my eyes and see Glenna is standing in front of him with her hands on his head. So, it is she who made him break the kiss. Then she tells Kinkade, “Don’t forget about me.” After which she opens her mouth and starts kissing him.

I watch how my sister kisses Kinkade while I continue jacking him off. His right hand goes down to her butt and squeezes hers while his left hand continues squeezing my butt, making both of us moan.

My lust makes me bolder than usual and I say, “Feels good, huh, Kinkade. Groping the butts of two girls at the same time. Imagine what else we could be doing for you.”

How does Kinkade respond?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)