The worst surprise

“Let’s go to the gymnasium!” Eve quickly yelled.

“O-okay, why are you suddenly so enthusiastic?” Sam raised a eyebrow.

“Oh, I think I know.” Smirked Robin. “Because Jake has his basketball training there.”

“Who’s Jake?”

“Just this guy who I have an eye on. He makes me laugh, is confident and a great listener. Plus, his abs are godlike.”

“And you want him to see you… like this?” Robin circled an open hand towards Eve.

“No! I’d die if he saw me like this. But I don’t think he’ll still be there at this time. That gymnasium just reminds me of him, so that’s why I want to go.”

“Eh, it’s just as good a place as any. Let’s go!”

“Stupid Jake! Why does Eve fall for a guy like him?!” Mumbled a naked Andrew, watching over the trio from around a corner. “I swear, I’ll- God, why does everything itch so much?” Looking back, he noticed what kind of bush he was just hiding at.

“Poison ivy?!” As if on cue, the burning became suddenly a lot more intense. “I-I have to wash this off quickly!” Taking a shortcut, Andrew sprinted towards the gymnasium. He practically flew towards the man’s locker room. But before he entered the showers, he almost tripped over something. Looking down, he saw a silver lining.

Eve’s sneakers and socks.

Muttering a quick “yes”, he quickly entered the shower, trying to was his itch away.

“Nothing so far, guys.” Said Sam, as she came out from under the bleachers.

“Think they hid something in the locker room again?” Asked Eve.

“Could be, let’s che-“ Robin interrupted herself when she walked closer towards the doors. “I think I hear someone showering in the men’s locker room.

The three slowly opened the door, trying not to disturb whoever was showering, when Eve saw her sneakers. “Finally! Something I can wear. Wait here.” Eve slowly sneaked towards her shoes, when curiosity took over. Who was showering in here? Was it Jake? She slowly took a peek…

…And stared right at Andrew, who was intensely scrubbing his ass.

“Oh, dear God in heaven!” Eve gagged at the sight, which caught the attention of Andrew. The two stared each other in the eyes, and then the shoes, and then each other again.