Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by magictcg magictcg

Can you make him stop?

The truth shall set you free

"Stop! Wait!" you cry out desperately as Jake continues to thrust inside your virgin pussy. "I'm Daniel! I'm literally Daniel! This is a curse—I woke up like this this morning!"

Your words hang in the air for a moment as the three men freeze, exchanging confused glances. Jake slows his thrusting but doesn't withdraw completely.

"What the fuck did you just say?" Tyler asks, his hand still roughly gripping your breast.

"I'm Daniel," you repeat, tears streaming down your face. "Your friend. We've known each other since middle school. I'm under some kind of family curse. It turned me into... this." You gesture at your transformed body with your eyes, since your arms are still pinned.

For a brief, hopeful moment, you think they might believe you. Then Marcos bursts out laughing.

"That's the best you could come up with?" he snorts. "A curse? Seriously?"

Jake shakes his head, a cruel smile playing on his lips. "Nice try, sweetheart. But Daniel's a total bro. You're just some slut he brought home."

"No! Ask me anything—something only Daniel would know!" you plead, **** to prove your identity.

"Fine," Tyler says with a smirk. "What happened at Jason's party last summer that only the four of us know about?"

You grasp at the memory through the haze of arousal clouding your mind. "We... we took turns with that drunk girl from Westlake High. In Jason's parents' bedroom. You recorded it and threatened to share it if she told anyone."

The room goes silent. The three men stare at you, their expressions shifting from disbelief to something darker.

"How the fuck do you know about that?" Jake growls, gripping your hips painfully tight. His cock throbs inside you, seeming to grow even harder.

"Because I'm Daniel! I was there! Please, you have to believe me—" your voice breaks as Jake suddenly resumes thrusting, harder and more brutal than before.

"If you are Daniel," Jake snarls, his face twisted with rage, "then this just got a whole lot more interesting."

Tyler leans down, pinching your nipple cruelly. "You know what? Let's say we believe you. You know what that makes this? Fucking justice."

"Remember Samantha?" Marcos adds, his hand moving to grip your throat lightly. "How you said she was just a cum dumpster? How many times did she beg you to stop?"

Your heart sinks as you realize your confession has only made things worse. Your friends—the people you thought had your back—are now seeing this as **** for all the times you objectified and used women together.

"You made us all like this," Jake grunts, his pace increasing. "You were always the ringleader. Always pushing us to go further. To treat girls like they were nothing."

His cock hammers into your pussy, stretching you painfully as your body continues to betray you with waves of unwanted pleasure. Each thrust sends jolts of electricity through your core, making your walls clench around him despite your mental objections.

"So now you get to feel what it's like," Tyler whispers, his breath hot against your ear. "To be nothing but a hole for us to fill."

Jake's rhythm becomes erratic, his breathing heavy. "I'm going to cum inside you, 'Daniel.' I'm going to fill your pussy up and make you take it. Just like you always said girls were made for."

"No! Please!" you sob, struggling uselessly against their hold. "You don't understand what will happen if—"

But Jake isn't listening anymore. With a guttural groan, he slams deep inside you and holds himself there, his cock pulsing as he empties his seed directly into your womb. The sensation of his hot cum flooding your insides makes your body convulse in a traitorous orgasm, your pussy milking him for every drop.

"Fuck," Jake pants, slowly withdrawing his softening cock. A mixture of cum and virginal blood trickles from your abused entrance. "You're right. That definitely felt like virgin pussy."

Marcos is already unbuckling his belt. "My turn with our old friend Daniel."

As he positions himself between your legs, you feel Jake's cum warm inside you, and a strange tingling sensation begins to spread throughout your body. The curse grows stronger, more permanent with each passing second.

You just took one load but two more await you

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)