Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by Torel Torel

What's next?

The sister dilemma

The clock finally hit the 2: 00 p.m. mark. John sat in his chair at work, dealing with the final check ups on all of the papers for the upcoming project. He worked at a car factory as a lead engineer and as a fresh twenty two year old, that at first led to some confusion and also even distain among his older colleagues. True, John's dad was the owner and yes he did place his son in this position but John had more that enough skills he deserved to be here. Never did he enact his authority or abused the power of his surname. He studied hard, worked even harder and over time, he earned the respect and trust of his coworkers. Even now, on this, what felt like eternal Friday, the young man stayed longer than he was required and finished what work remained unfinished, even with his mind wondering elsewhere. For the entire duration of the day, his mind would always shift to his girlfriend, Bree. Early in the morning, maybe about half an hour after John got to work, Bree decided to properly tease her boyfriend. He received a three minute video of his girlfriend adorned in the sexiest lingerie he has ever seen, before Bree started stimulating her clit and squeezing her breasts. All the blood at that moment rushed into John's pants as he stared at his phone. You see, Bree was an absolute blonde bombshell. They met in college and it was love at first sight. She had deep blue eyes, a face that did not require a single drop of make up as her sharp cheeks and full lips highlighted her beautiful face. Her figure was slim as she happily spent her time going to the gym and doing yoga while still studying to become a veterinarian. But even with a slim figure, her body knew very well where to store fat. She had amazing C cup breasts and an ass that even big sweatpants could not hide. She really had everything going on. At the start of their relationship, John could hardly believe he could pull such a baddie but here he was. Amazing, beautiful girlfriend, a job he enjoyed and was well paid and unfortunately an erection that could tear through his pants. The video ended with Bree licking her fingers that she just pulled out of her quim as she told John how excited she was for their little date night. Her parents were gone and her house was supposed to be empty. Was, supposed to be. As John finally began to clean up the conference room he was sitting in, he received a text message.

" Hey babe! You know how we were supposed to have the house all to ourselves tonight? "

" Yeah! Looking forward to it. I couldn't stop thinking about that thing you sent me in the morning. You tease! I'm just finishing up at work, I'll go shower at home, pick up some snacks at the store and I'll be right over. "

" Yeaaah... There is a little thing. Mom and dad are not here. Buuut Vanessa is. "

" Vanessa? Wasn't she supposed to have a date tonight or something? "

Vanessa was Bree's younger sister. She was almost the exact opposite from Bree. Rebellious, liked to ditch school to do something more interesting and was pretty much just barely scraping through college. But she wasn't bad or anything at all. In fact, she was a lot of fun. She liked to do harmless pranks, offensive jokes that sometimes pushed the line. She played a lot of video games and made art on her computer. Animations and drawings. The only problem John had with her was the occasional teasing. You see, Vanessa was almost an exact copy of her older sister when it came to their bodies and sex appeal. Slim figure with a nice ass but in addition to that, her tits were just slightly bigger than Bree's and often times she liked to show them off. Especially when John was around. Anytime he would hang out at their house, Vanessa would come out with a tank top that pushed her tits so up that they almost fell out on multiple occasions. She would also often times bend down around John to show off her butt or just seductively but nonchalantly licked a spoon or a fork while eating. It was never quite directly made on John but it always seemed like that. At least to him. And she was real sneaky about it too. Plus, she almost looked exactly like her older sister. If they would stand next to each other, anyone would have put the two and two together and understand these two are sisters. The biggest noticeable difference was the hair and eye color. Vanessa wanted to properly express herself so she died her hair a deep blue color and her eyes were bright green instead of blue.

Now, John leaned back into his chair as three dots popped up in the chat feed.

" Yeah she was but the guy she was supposed to go with canceled last minute. "

" Shit. What a bastard. "

" Yeaaah. I know we were supposed to have a night for ourselves but would you mind if she'd hang out with us? We'll watch a movie, I don't know maybe bring a bottle of wine and after she falls asleep, I will show you in person how the lingerie looks on me. Deal? "

" Hmmm, deal. I will need a lot of hands on testing though. I hope you are ready for that. " Bree followed up with laughing emojis.

" I certainly hope so. I need the expert's opinion. "

John smiled at his phone and placed it into his pocket before getting up from his chair and quickly finishing up everything that he had to do. Then he walked to his car and drove home to properly prepare himself. He shaved both his face and the area down there, showered, brushed his teeth and sprayed himself with the best cologne he had before finding himself back in his car. On the way to his girlfriends house he made a quick stop at the store. The wine was probably the most important thing to take but John also grabbed popcorn, some sweets and other snacks that he knew the girls would like. And just like that, a couple of minutes later, he was getting out of his car with a bag in his hand as he knocked on the door. Bree opened the door with a smile as the two embraced and kissed before John entered the house. As he walked into the living room, Vanessa was seated on the couch. She stood up and greeted him with a smile as the two hugged as well.

" Hey! You doing okay? "

" I'm good, yeah. That piece of shit can go fuck himself if he's going to bail at the last second. I'm more sorry for ruining your night. I told Bree she doesn't have to do this for me. You know I would get out of your hair, go to like a friend's house or something I dunno. "

" I don't mind at all. Listen, we'll watch a movie or do something. I don't know but you're right. Fuck that guy! "

At this point Bree walked into the room and hooked her arms against John's left arm. Both sisters went for similar home pajama outfits. Bree had long loose pants with a short sleeved T-shirt while Vanessa decided to go for a more... revealing outfit. As she usually does. Booty shorts with long knee high socks and a tank top that left nothing to imagination. The top of her breasts was in perfect view and as she scrunched her shoulders up and squished her boobs together, the pair of her lovely mounds looked even better. But as John raised the bag in the air the girls immediately rushed to dig in. They giggled amongst each other and thanked him for bringing the snacks as the wine was put into the fridge to cool off. The trio then decided to spread out some board games before preparing snacks and the **** as they loaded up a movie on Netflix. Bree went to the kitchen to prepare the popcorn as John was left with Vanessa alone in the living room. They were already a glass of wine in and dirty thoughts formed in the girl's head. She deliberately bent over in front of John to pick up her phone from the ground as the booty shorts perfectly hugged her butt. John loudly gulped his saliva as Vanessa bit down on her lip and went to sit on the other side of the couch.

In the middle of the movie, as most snacks and popcorn was already finished, the wine bottle and glasses empty, Bree was hooked onto John. The pair sat on the rightmost side of the couch with Bree kissing John's cheek and neck as Vanessa sat on the opposite side. She occasionally looked at what her older sister was doing as the wine really, really got into her head. She was also prepared to spend a night with her boyfriend and those feelings have now caught up with her. The pair tried to be quiet but Bree was sometimes exhaling a little too loud as Vanessa found it really hard to focus on the movie. Instead, her hand went below the blanket that covered her legs as she quietly and sneakily began rubbing her pussy. John had accidentally looked over and saw the girl playing with herself as the two locked eyes. Vanessa bit down on her lip as the blanket was very obviously moving in a suspicious way which John immediately understood. He didn't know whether to say or do something so instead he just watched as his girlfriend continued to kiss his cheek and neck. Vanessa then looked down and pulled on her tank top, revealing her amazing tits as John opened her eyes in amazement. He continued watching the girl toy with herself, squeezing her own tits until Bree stopped kissing him. All three quickly went back to watching the movie as the tension was high as ever and heartbeats of all of them were high. As the movie ended, Vanessa was laying on the couch sleeping as Bree and John quickly made their way into her room. But Vanessa wasn't sleeping. She waited until the two left and after a couple of minutes she made her way to their room.

Bree had her sexy underwear underneath her pajamas but she had absolutely no care about that. She threw her boyfriend on the bed before quickly discarding each clothing until she stood naked in front of him. Her pussy was dripping as the girl could not contain how cock hungry she was. Bree pulled down John's pants and immediately started sucking his cock. That was when John saw the door slowly open. Vanessa appeared between the door frame, her tits out of her tank top as she continued to play with herself. John didn't know where to look. His amazing girlfriend on her knees, sucking his cock, or her sexy younger blue haired sister masturbating at the door. He pushed Bree's head lower as she gagged which made Vanessa quietly moan as she had her mouth wide open.

As John held his girlfriend's head at the base of his cock, Vanessa beckoned him to come to her with her finger. Then she quietly closed the door and vanished. John sat there, contemplating what to do. Stay with his girlfriend and enjoy the night with her or go and join her younger sister?

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)