The house next door where a family of thieves live

Krampus doesn't need to move far to find more people needing punishment. In fact, he only needs to move next door to find another group of sinners. This time its a full family: A father, a mother, and an older daughter. Peering at them through the windows of the house he watched them go about their Christmas eve. Father was dozing off watching a scary movie with a killer Santa in the living room. Mother meanwhile was washing away her stresses of the day in the shower. Finally, daughter had long fallen asleep, dreaming about the expensive things she would surely be getting for Christmas.

It seemed a cozy picture but Krampus knew better. He knew the stench of sin and hypocrisy when he smelt it.

For each member of the family prided themselves on thievery. Pops was an embezzler funneling money out of his client's accounts into his wallet. Mama was swindling from an orphanage she was representing as a lawyer. And the darling daughter was stealing from both of them when they weren't looking. Which was often.

Thieves every one of them. So now it was time for a little Christmas scare intervention.

But first, he would have to prepare. As the years have come and gone, Krampus has found it hard to keep his current look without causing problems. In fact, he found that some freaks actually liked the 7-foot-tall goat man look. So he had to take up enchantments to disguise himself as people's worst fears. Now...which one to use?