The girls return

Victoria and Chloe were both relieved when Heather finally arrived to pick them up. Neither girl had wanted to talk much after they met up at the pharmacy, and they had been standing around in an awkward silence for about fifteen minutes waiting on their ride. They did perk up when they realized they had a new addition to the car and Madison soon had everyone chatting and laughing on the drive back to the cabin. Once they were back, everyone was quick to welcome Madison to the cabin. Gavin was also up and moving again so they all settled into the living room to make plans.

"First up," Heather was in command mode, "we need to rearrange bed assignments again. Unless someone wants to share a bed with Madison, I think Kurt should be a gentleman and give up his bed, so she and I can room together."

"Kurt's a gentleman?" Zack snickered.

"Hey, I can be quite gentlemanly when I want to be." Kurt made a courtly bow before Madison. "My lady, would you do me the pleasure of sharing mine bed?"

Madison giggled and rolled her eyes. Brandon opened his mouth to say something, but Heather cut him off and glared at Kurt. "You can take the couch."

"Fine, fine." Kurt threw his hands up in defeat.

"Good," Heather nodded. "Now, we all came out here to hang together, so tonight let's actually do that."

“I could setup another movie,” Gavin offered.

“No.” Heather immediately countered. “Everyone would just snuggle up and disappear into their rooms. Let’s play an actual game.”

“Strip poker!” Kurt smiled excitedly.

Heather glared at her cousin. “I was thinking something a little more engaging. How about Truth or Dare?” Everyone seemed to think this would work. Heather went into the kitchen and returned with a shot glass and a bottle of 151. “So for this game, if you are uncomfortable with your question or dare, you can take a drink instead. Now Kurt, I know you’re eager, so you can go first.”

“Dare,” Kurt waggled his eyebrows.

“I dare you,” Heather smiled evilly, “to not make any dares that require someone to take off their clothes. Oh and for this one dare you can’t drink to get out of it.”

Kurt’s mouth fell open while everyone else laughed. “Well…fuck.” He sat back down but quickly recovered his spirits once he realized he got to direct the next round. “Chloe, truth or dare?”

“Truth.” Chloe was certain any dare Kurt came up with would still be terrible, even with his no stripping rule.

“Well, we’ve all heard how much fun you’ve been having with Bishop BUT,” Kurt rubbed his hands together eagerly, “if you were going to hook up with someone else, who would it be?”

A mental image of Zack’s mom eating her out at the clinic immediately pooped into Chloe’s mind. She blushed and grabbed the shot Heather had already poured without thinking. She’d never had 151 before and downed it without thinking. Fire burned her throat and she started coughing. “Holy shit, that burns.” Zack gave her a concerned look, but she waved him off and took a few deep breaths. “Note to self, only avoid questions that are truly terrible.” Once her breathing returned to normal, she scanned the room trying to figure out who to ask before finally settling on Gavin. “Alright Gavin, truth or dare?”

Gavin blushed and tried to decide if he trusted Chloe enough. “Uh…dare, I guess.”

Chloe took the 151 and poured a shot. “I dare you to take this shot.”

“Wait. If I try to back out of the dare the punishment is still taking the shot. Is that legal?” Gavin looked panicked. “Zack, Chloe has teamed up with Kurt to try and kill me.” Everyone chuckled and Gavin nervously took the shot glass. He closed his eyes and downed it. His eyes watered but he managed to avoid repeating Chloe’s coughing fit. “I’m going to get you for that, McRose.” Chloe just stuck her tongue out playfully. Gavin blinked a few times and focused on Zack. Maybe I can embarrass Chloe a different way. “Zack, truth or dare?”

Zack didn’t trust the look in Gavin’s eye and was a little surprised to see such a mischievous look in his normally reserved friend. “Uh...truth.”

Gavin smiled, Zack had fallen into his trap. “What’s the craziest sexual thing you’ve done this weekend?”

Zack froze. He realized Gavin was trying to reveal an embarrassing moment between him and Chloe, but all he could think of was helping gangbang Ashley earlier. He was not ready to reveal that to Chloe, and quickly poured himself a shot. Chloe frowned as she noticed how nervous Zack was. Ashley and Brandon had essentially shared a foursome with them. He couldn’t be that embarrassed about their exploits.

Kurt yawned loudly as Zack took his shot. “If everyone is just going to do shots this is going to get old fast.”

Heather hated to agree with Kurt, but he was right. “Okay, no more shots until someone actually fulfills a dare or question.”

“Then you won’t mind going next,” Zack stared at Heather.

She held herself defiantly. “Dare. Do your worst, Bishop.”

Zack pondered for a moment and tried to think of something that would be very difficult for Heather. “I dare you to…hmm…make out with Kurt.”

“Dude,” Gavin gasped, “her cousin?”

Heather looked at Zack for a second, debating whether or not to feign disgust. She caught Madison winking at her and thought she saw a small smile on Victoria’s face. “If you think that’s supposed to scare me, Bishop...” Heather spun and practically launched herself onto Kurt’s lap. She grabbed his face and planted a fierce kiss right on his lips. Either he was acting as well, or just plain surprised at Heather’s fierceness. Kurt’s eyes went wide. He blinked a few times as Heather finished the kiss and climbed off him. Heather sat back in her own spot and made a point of seeming unbothered by the variety of stares from around the room. She did stare back at Zack though. “That was your worst?” Ashley leaned over and high fived her friend. “Come on Victoria, let’s show the boys how this is done.”

“Truth.” Victoria blushed. She wasn’t nearly as outgoing as the other girl.

“Fine,” Heather sighed but then smiled as he had an idea. “Have you ever fooled around with another girl?”

Victoria blinked as Heather stared at her. Heather knew the answer to this question, but clearly wanted everyone else to know as well. Victoria managed to squeak out a yes causing all the guys to give her interested stares. She especially noted Gavin’s interest in her answer. Maybe Heather was right about him. She quickly tried to move everyone’s thinking. “Ashley, have you fooled around with another girl?”

“Pretty sure you’re supposed to let me pick truth or dare,” Ashley laughed. “But to answer your question, let’s see.” She began holding up fingers. “Hannah taught me how to kiss.”

“Really?” Brandon couldn’t stop the grin on his face as he pictured his girlfriend and her older sister kissing.

Ashley elbowed Brandon and resumed listing. “Heather and I have played around a few times. Sharon Miller cornered me one time in the school shower. And Chloe and I were quite intimate just last night.”

Kurt’s grin was even bigger than Brandon’s as he leaned over to high five him. “Dude, your girlfriend rocks.”

“So Brandon,” Ashley snuggled up close to him as she prepared her question, “if you could hook up with another girl in this room, who would it be?”

“I stand corrected,” Kurt laughed. “She’s evil. Abort mission. ABORT!”

Brandon rolled his eyes at Kurt and pondered the question. He knew Ashley was asking because of the deal she’d made earlier. His mind was still picturing the idea of Ashley and her older sister, but Hannah wasn’t here.

His eyes fell on Madison smirking at him and he quickly jerked them away. Not today, brain. He’d long had an attraction for his sister. Growing up together he’d often caught her in a state of undress and couldn’t deny how attractive she was. But she’s my sister. Of course, Hannah is Ashley’s sister. And Heather just made out with her cousin.

“Earth to Brandon,” Ashley waved a hand in front of his face. “Any time, babe.”

“Oh...uh…Chloe...I guess.” Brandon shook his head to clear his thoughts. He shrugged at Zack, not wanting to hurt his friend’s feeling but he wasn’t about to say Madison.

Chloe smiled at the compliment but looked to Zack to make sure he wasn’t getting upset. Zack once again pictured Ashley getting gangbanged earlier. As he tried to clear the image, it morphed into a vision of Chloe trapped between the three boys. He closed his eyes for a second and opened them to find Chloe frowning at him.

The room felt a little awkward, especially when Brandon realized the only person who hadn’t been asked was Madison. “Well Mads, what’s it gonna be?”

“Can’t have all you chickens bringing the game down,” Madison winked at Heather, “I’ll take a dare.”

“Why don’t you make out with Ashley?” The words were out of his mouth before Brandon realized it.

Madison eyed her brother quizzically. You want me to make out with your girlfriend? What are you up to, brother? Still she wasn’t going to chicken out after her boast. She stood up and Ashley joined her. The two girls embraced in the middle of the room. Not to be outdone by Heather’s earlier performance, they brought their arms up around each other passionately.

“She’s back to being great again,” Kurt whispered to Brandon, nodding at Ashley.

Brandon just watched his girlfriend and forbidden desire make out. He felt his cock hardening and shifted, not wanting anyone to notice. Ashley and Madison were really getting into it. Their hands slid up and down each other’s back and it was obvious that there was tongue involved. Victoria had to admit, it was a pretty erotic sight. She wondered what Gavin would think if she made out with another girl in front of him. When the girls finally ended their kiss, they were both flush with excitement. Heather and Kurt clapped their approval and the others quickly joined them.

Madison sat back down and looked at Brandon. “Truth, brother, did you enjoy the show?” She eyed the bulge in his pants.

Brandon stammered sheepishly and poured a shot of 151 causing everyone to laugh.