Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Lilyflier Lilyflier

What's next?

The girlfriend arrives as a third party

Hannah was intimidating at one point. With a nose ring, dark hair, a skinniness that can only be achieved by inhuman amounts of exercise, and visible abs. She's exactly the sort of girl you'd have been too nervous to talk to, even if she didn't ride motorcycles and do martial arts as a hobby. But, over the years you discovered that she's more shy than scary. She doesn't talk much, and when she does she's bad enough at it that she either accidentally comes across as aggressive or constantly pauses while talking.

With a knock, you breathed a sigh of relief that she had arrived, believing that soon you could figure this situation out with her help. "Hey, Hannah." You awkwardly greeted her, a little embarrassed to be "caught" alone with Ashley in their home.

"Hey, uhm, how are you doing?" She asked, apparently sincerely, and slipped her shoes off and set some things down on the kitchen table.

"Not so great, I'm not thrilled at either possibility in this scenario. Either me or Ashley is acting very strangely here and the explanations for why can hardly be good." You reflected on the situation, the events leading up to it, trying to find any memory of doing something that might lead you to have a major lapse of judgement or some probable explanation for Ashley's seemingly strange behavior, but unfortunately none came to mind.

"I'm sorry, I uh..well, my memories align with Ashley's here. We've always wanted to make you happy, everyone here understands no matter what that entails. Even if it involves getting naked in public or having a threesome or something else, we're here to make you happy no matter what."

You took a deep breath, trying to come to terms with your own plausible insanity. "Sorry, did you say a threesome?"

"Yeah, of course. You can bend me or Ashley over the counter and do what you want with us, or give us instructions and watch us do your bidding to one another, or have us give your cooperative fellatio. Whatever you want. That's how it's always been."

You gulp, trying to hide your erection in case this is some kind of elaborate prank. "This seems like...such a specific set of memories for me to have forgotten. Is there anything that happened to me that would explain me forgetting about this?"

Hannah shakes her head solemnly "Nothing comes to mind unfortunately." she inadvertantly briefly glances at your erection and moves her eyes to your feet, trying to wordlessly pass it off as her eyes wandering. But you know that you've failed to hide it. "If you've really forgotten...maybe we can try to jog your memory? We could do things that the three of us would normally do. I mean...I know it's probably jarring to feel like you're suddenly in a completely different world, so I understand if you're not ready for that, but it's always an option."

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)