More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 40 by telaviv telaviv telaviv telaviv

What's next?

The fun continues at home.

Out in the hallway, the three of you shoot each other a look. Tibby looks like she wants to start talking right away, but you open your mouth first. "Let's not stand around out here."

Looking down at your pants, the girls can see exactly why you're in a rush to get back to your apartment. Ashley gives you a smirk, while Tibby just smiles brightly. "Then let's go!"

She turns around and starts walking, followed quickly by Ashley. Both sway their hips in an exaggerated manner as they walk, knowing your eyes will be glued to their asses until you get inside. You walk after them, very aware of the tent you're pitching and thankful that the hallway is empty. At the door Ashley pulls a key from somewhere to let everyone in. Without having to discuss it, you all head straight for the bedroom.

"That was fun," Tibby says as she plops down on the bed.

"The fun isn't over," you tell her, already unbuttoning your shirt.

"I sure hope not," Ashley exclaims, squatting in front of you so she can take your pants off. When your hard cock springs out she grabs it and kisses its head. "I'm all worked up and I want this guy inside me."

"That's exactly where he wants to be too," you say while she pulls your pants down your legs. The moment you're free of your clothes Ashley stands, pulling her dress up as she turns to the bed. You watch the bright fabric journey upward, exposing inch after inch of the bunny's skin. Her tan thighs, her booty, then up the length of her back until it's pulled over her head. Ashley is careful not to snag her ears, but the moment they're clear she tosses her dress to the side.

When she reaches the bed Ashley bends at the waist to rest her arms on the mattress. Looking over her shoulder, she shakes her ass invitingly. "What'cha waiting for?"

"Just taking in the view," you tell her with your eyes on her rear. Then you look over at Tibby, who is lying on her back with a hand under her skirt. Since she's keeping herself busy you don't hesitate to get behind Ashley.

Ashley keeps shaking her booty, evading your hands when you try to grab it.

"I thought you were impatient?" you ask her once you've caught her tush.

Ashley grins. "Yeah, but you were enjoying the view. I was just being considerate by making it last longer."

"I bet. So where do you want it?"

"Where do I... oh, you think butt stuff is just always on the menu now? Well I'm not saying no, but right now my kitty needs to be fed."

"I'm good, actually," Tibby says. "We can have lunch later."

Even without seeing her face, you can feel Ashley roll her eyes. While she's not paying attention you take a step forward and bury yourself in her wet cunt.

"Oh!" The bunny falls forward a little before she catches herself. As soon as she's regained her balance, she pushes her hips back until her butt bumps into you. "What are you playing at, mister?"

Grinning, you give her ass a smack. "It's master, not mister."

As you start thrusting into her with more ****, the conversation gives way to lustful moaning from both of you. The observing kitty mews quietly. Her mesh shirt is gone and the fingers of one hand move around beneath her skirt while the other hand finds its way under the fabric of her pink bikini top. You can't see her tail anywhere either.

While she watches you pound away at Ashley, quickly working her up to a gasping orgasm after which she lets herself fall forward onto the bed. "Whoo, I needed that. Now how are we going to take care of you?"

Tibby stops touching herself and sits up. "I think I want to try master's cock up my butt now. Can I ride you to get myself ready?"

"Of course. Get over here!" You sit down on your comfortable chair, and Tibby jumps into your lap.

She's facing you, bikini top touching your chest while her legs hang down on either side of the chair. You grab her ass to pull her in close, then move up to untie her top. It falls away and her soft breasts mash against your body. At the same time, your lips meet. The leather skirt acts as a barrier until Tibby pulls it up, after which you feel the warmth of her pussy against you.

Letting your hands glide back down to her ass, you lift her up until she's hovering over the tip of your cock. When you let go of her the kitty slides down slowly, her tongue leaving your mouth so she can let out a happy sigh as her pussy is filled.

When Tibby's thighs are firmly pressed against yours, she puts her hands on your shoulders and starts bouncing her body excitedly. This time it's you who doesn't last long, the eroticism of what happened in your neighbor's playroom is still affecting you and fucking Ashley brought you close to the brink. After half a minute you hold the squirming Tibby down so you can cum deep inside her.

"Don't worry, I've got another one in me," you tell her when you've recovered enough to notice her disappointed look. "If you're ready...?"

Your pet nods happily and gives you a peck on the lips. "Let me just turn around."

You let go of her and she raises her hips, letting your cock slip out of her so she can scoot back. Then she spins around, moving her legs so they're between yours, and reverses until her booty presses against your crotch. You lift her up again, your cock nestled between her cheeks. You carefully lower her until it presses against her rear entrance, where you pause for a second before continuing.

When you enter her Tibby clenches with a squeak, but a second later she breathes out and relaxes so you can resume her descent. You take it slow, but she's relaxed enough that you can penetrate her ass at a steady rate without hurting her. When you're all the way inside Tibby, which she acknowledges with a satisfied groan, you stop and enjoy the sensation of her asshole squeezing the base of your shaft for the first time. While you let her adjust, you run your hands up her sides and play with her breasts a little.

"I'm so full," Tibby says quietly, her voice tinged with astonishment. "Should I start moving now?"

"Mm-hmm. Just take it slow at first."

You keep your hands where they are, letting her dictate the pace while you stabilize her body. Tibby pulls up her legs to kneel on the chair on either side of your thighs, then lifts herself up an inch at a time before resting back onto your lap. She moves around like this for a minute, making little sounds of surprise or arousal as your shaft rubs against her insides.

When she's satisfied with this exploration, she shifts her legs again so her feet are planted on the chair and her knees point up. "Put your hands on my butt John, I'm ready to go!"

Grinning, you do just that. With one cheek in each hand, you start moving her body slowly up and down to start fucking her butt. Almost immediately she begins to squeak and moan and you don't hesitate to pick up the pace, but you're prepared to stop the moment you hear the sound of discomfort. A sound that never comes, even as Tibby starts bouncing up to your full length before letting herself crash down on you. With how often she wears her plug tail, you shouldn't surprised she can take you like this.

After a while Ashley sits on the edge of the bed in front of your chair. She watches with the same amazement as Tibby the first time you had anal sex with Ashley. Then she reaches out to touch Tibby's pussy while you fill her ass. The cat's moans immediately sound more excited, and she bounces even faster than before. Her own hands take over where yours left off, squeezing her breasts as she bounces along.

With her hands playing with her boobs, Ashley's fingers on her clit, and your dick ramming her ass it doesn't take long for Tibby to reach her first climax.

You have to hold her steady when her legs get wobbly, but only moments later she's bouncing away again. It seems the first orgasm only made her more sensitive, since after just a few more thrusts she's already building up for another. Then Ashley gets on her knees in front of the chair and while still rubbing Tibby's clit with one hand, shoves two fingers of the other into her vag.

Tibby gasps in surprise, and so do you. You can actually feel it when Ashley's fingers curl to press against the tissues between one orifice and the other. But that sensation is nothing compared to what Tibby must be going through, as her moans turn into a scream and she cums again.

Of course this increases your pleasure too, since her contracting muscles practically milk your shaft into her ass and **** you to cum as well.

When Ashley stops moving her fingers Tibby just sits on your lap for a while, basking in the afterglow of two anal orgasms.

"Fuck that was hot," Ashley says before pretending to pout. "But hang on, she got two loads and I get none? That's no fair."

"Well.. the loads are still there if you want them," you laugh. "You just have to convince Tibby to share."

"On second thought, I think I'll content myself with what I lapped up over at Annabelle's."

Tibby giggles as she pulls herself up. "Good, because I have to use the bathroom more than anything. Plus there was mention of me getting fed, but we should all clean up first. Join me in the shower in five minutes?"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)