More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 21 by ShaddragSD ShaddragSD

The princess bride

The conquering prince? Or the brutish monster...

Bianca stops in the middle of the bed, both of you know what's going to happen here. "Please, be gentle with me." she says to you softly as you clamber on to the bed behind her and place your palms on her hips. You don't even give it a moment's consideration. Instead, you grab the back of her head by her hair and pull her head towards you.

"That is not for you to ask. You're a lesbian, that means you need to be punished for being gay and that you don't get to choose what happens to you." You lean forward closer to her so you can speak in her ear for the next part. "I get to decide what happens to you. And I've decided that you're going to be a good bitch for me and be used for my pleasure however I like."

After that, there were no more sounds of complaint from Bianca as her head sagged forward and she seemed to accept her fate at your hands. "Do what you will then," she whispers back hoarsely and you straighten up away from her again. That's exactly what you plan to do.

Your cock hadn't been cleaned from Bianca's earlier attempt at a blowjob, so it is still wet with her spit and some amount of your spunk. You move a hand down the curve of Biana's ass illuminated by the window light behind you and slightly to the side. Your fingers find her entrance and feel a slight amount of moisture there, enough that you feel confident in lining up your cock with her pussy before placing both your hands on her waist to thrust forward. Bianca also tenses herself, feeling your explorations and the tip of your cock as it presses up against her most sensitive spot. Perhaps there was a very tiny whimper from her, but she stifled it almost as soon as it came.

You push your hips forward hard, expecting to slide into warm gooey wetness. Instead, your blunt cockhead slides between her pussy lips and glides along the outside of her cunt before bouncing off the end and thumping on the underside of her belly. Your inexperience shows as you pull back and line yourself back up again, this time aiming your cock with one hand and fitting the tip of your head inside her nether lips before pushing forward again. This time, you succeed and your cock is enveloped with the warmth and wetness of a woman's pussy for the first time in your life.

Bianca is tight, at least tight for you. It's reasonable for you to expect that lesbians you meet in the future will all be tight by most measures, but for your first time you have no idea what to compare the experience to and can only savour the exquisite pressure wrapping around your member inside Bianca. Sinking deeper into her, you can feel every inch where the pressure of her inner walls pushes back against your cock, and you end up having to fight for the last few inches before pulling back out again for a moment, before plunging back in and sinking deeper into Bianca's depths.


In the corner of your bedroom, Lucy listens with despair and trepidation as you fuck her girlfriend's pussy and take her first time. It's hard for Lucy to focus and think straight at the moment, there's so much going on around her that she is having a difficult time sorting her mind out. Your instructions were for her to fuck herself on the dildo in her ass. The suction cup was stuck to the chair she was on, so she could bounce her ass up and down on it. But you also told her that she wasn't allowed to cum, and against her best efforts and desires, Lucy had found herself edging closer and closer to a cliff of pleasure. It felt wrong to her if she were to tip over that edge. Your instructions were clear to her and she knew she had to obey them because she was gay, but she also felt a deeper lingering sense of guilt if she were to cum at the instructions of a straight man lusting over her. One who was also at this moment fucking her beautiful girlfriend of six years since they met in highschool.

Smeared across her face was your first orgasm of the night, a sticky mix of cum that you'd **** Bianca to take inside her mouth and lick off the floor, only to spit back out over Lucy's face. It was impossible to make out any blushing under the glistening mess coating her face, but having your cum and Bianca's saliva spit across her face was the most degrading and humiliating thing Lucy had ever experienced. She felt like a floormat, worthless and thrown to the side.

To add insult to injury, the coating of semen was drying in a crusty layer across her eyelids, gluing them together and preventing her from seeing the room properly. The best Lucy could manage was a blurred image of both of your profiles fucking on the bed and hearing the sounds in the room rise in volume as you increased the speed of your hips and they clapped against Bianca's asscheeks, along with the utterly heart-wrenching sounds to Lucy of Bianca's moans. She knew those sounds, recognised those moans, was familiar with them from all their nights spent together rolling around in bed with each other. Hearing them coming from Bianca's mouth and knowing that it was because a man was fucking Bianca with his cock punched a deep thorn of pain inside Lucy unlike anything else she'd experienced.

Lowering her head since she couldn't see anything properly out of her eyes anyways, she choked back sobs as she heard the loud sounds of your hand spanking Bianca and shouting at her to go "Harder!"

As if she was the one you were giving the instruction to instead of her girlfriend you were fucking, Lucy raised her ass up a little higher and threw her hips down on the dildo a little bit harder. Just like Bianca was doing on your cock.

In the darkness we play our game of shadows

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)