That's why you're the best

We spend some more time at Troy and Anna's place, eventually having lunch there. After a bit more gossiping, we decide to go our separate ways, but not before Shar grabs Anna's phone number. The ride back home had my mind overflowing with a mix of emotions. I've just left one of the hottest experiences of my life, even if it almost went against what I'd discussed with Shar. Then again, it's not like I'm complaining. Especially with Shar setting the boundaries like that. I know we're going to talk about it once we get back to the dorm, but I couldn't help but wonder how said conversation will go. Is she gonna push me further on this open relationship thing? Or is she going to back off and give me space like she did earlier today?

We both remain silent all the way up to my dorm. Upon opening the door to my room, I wonder if I should break the silence that's driving me crazy. Shar, however, beats me to it, saying "So, that was something, huh?"

"Yeah it sure was." I reply.

"You okay?"

"Y-yeah. I'm fine Shar."

Shar raises an eyebrow. "Did you have a good time?"

"I mean, what guy wouldn't enjoy being with you?"

She lets out a slight chuckle as I feel the color leave my cheeks. "You know that's not what I'm asking, Andrew."

"Well I mean ... I know, but, I guess I didn't mind."

"I thought so."

"And you?"

Shar chuckles. "I think we both know the answer to that."

"Yeah I guess. So is what Troy and Anna have the sort of thing you want?"

All of a sudden, Shar becomes serious, raising an eyebrow before she asks "What, like an open relationship?"

"Well... yeah."

"I mean I wouldn't take it off the table for me."

"Okay."

"What about you?"

"I'm not sure yet, to be honest..."

"That's okay. I know it's a big ask."

"I just... What turns you on so much about sharing?"

Shar gives me a shrug."I dunno, I just like seeing you in action. Plus, it's like a challenge."

"A challenge?"

She bites her lip "Yeah. Like I have to fuck you better than the other woman."

"I don't think that's ever gonna be an issue for you."

"Maybe, but you never know. Plus, people can have interesting ways of doing things."

"Oh yeah?"

"Yeah." Her hand touches my thigh. "Like when Troy was squatting over Anna as he railed her."

"Oh yeah?"

"Yeah."

I decide to spring into action and push Shar down onto her back. She lets out a gasp so I smile and say "So, something like this?"

"I dunno. My clothes are still on."

I pull at the hem of her jeans. "I can change that."

With haste, I yank her jeans off and discard them to the floor, bringing her panties with them. In response, she pulls off her top as I fall down to my knees. As her bra flies across the room, I ask "Bet he doesn't do this like I do."

"You never kno-Oh!"

I go down on Shar, ready to prove to her that I have no equal when it comes to pleasing her. No man had ever practiced the motions my tongue had made. That might not be one-hundred percent true, but I want her to believe it. The rush of sensations already has me growing hard, and all that's left to do is to make sure Shar is nice and wet for the pounding she craves.

"Ohh fuck Andrew... That's it. Eat my pussy." Shar cries.

I obey her order, lashing my tongue against her clit before pressing two fingers inside of her. I know she wants more, but for now, I continue to tease her. Every motion I make has her moaning, which in turn has my cock throbbing. In my mind, I ponder if I should merely tease Shar, or if I should push her over the edge. Right now I've got her at my mercy, even if only for the moment, and I can do what I want with her.

As much as I liked the idea of teasing her, I figured I'm better off making her cum. Making sure she knows I'm the better man. My cock throbs to every moan she makes whilst her body convulses throughout her bliss. My tongue continues to flicker as I fish my hard-on out of my pants. After a few more licks, Shar says "Oh fuck... I need your cock Andrew."

I stand up. "Yeah? How bad do you need my big dick?"

"More than anything." She replies.

"Not many guys have one like I do, do they Shar?"

"Oh you fucking know it."

"Get on all fours for me."

"Mhmm... I like this." Shar assumes the position.

"Yeah, you like being told what to do?"

"Yes."

I move onto the bed and get behind Shar so I can slap my cock against her plump rump. "Beg for this cock then."

"Oh please Andrew. I'll do anything for your fat fucking dick."

Next, I rub my tip against her glistening slit. "Is my dick better than Troy's?"

"Oh, not if you keep teasing me like this. I bet he'd be fucking me by now."

I decide to retort by spanking Shar, who winces. "Well he isn't here now, is he."

I then squat down and press my tip inside of Shar. "Oh please Andrew. Fuck my brains out."

I start my pressing as much of my length inside of her warm, welcoming wetness. Within seconds I find myself plunging as deep as I can inside of Shar. I proceed to thrust with vigor, just like she'd demanded. The sound of our flesh slapping together is only second to Shar's passionate cries. She isn't holding anything back, but to be fair, nor am I. That's what she wants, so that's what she gets.

Shar starts bucking her hips, throwing them at me as I ravage her. In spite of my efforts, she cries out "Oh fuck yeah Troy. Fucking pound my pussy."

In retort, I slap her round ass. "You're such a dirty slut."

"Oh you fucking love it Andrew."

I didn't know if that was exactly true, but it does spur me to fuck her harder, which is exactly what she needs. Her limbs begin to quiver as her climax boils over. Suddenly, she crashes into my mattress, before her body quakes as a climax ripples throughout her body. I, however, am still rock hard and ready to go, so I roll Shar onto her back, right where I want her. She instinctively throws her legs open, granting me access to her tender little slit.

"Ohh Andrew." She coos as I ease myself inside of her once more. We share a tender kiss before I start putting my hips to work, thrusting away with the sort of vigor Shar often demands. Her breasts jiggle as her hands grip the bedsheets underneath her. Is this moment, I have her right where any man would want her, her moans filling my ear and her tight wetness gripping my cock like a vice.

"Fuck yes Andrew. Pound my fucking pussy."

I take her words to heart, plowing with as much power as I can muster. The bed shakes underneath us as Shar screams a tirade of passionate cries. A hand of hers then reaches for her clit, and frantically rubs it. We were both growing more and more **** for release, having spent so much time fucking each other's brains out.

I'm able to give Shar one more body-shaking climax before finally succumbing to my own. What little seed I have left floods her channel before I collapse onto the bed next to her, exhausted by my encore performance.

"Damn Andrew." Shar sighs.

"Did that satisfy you?"

"Abso-fucking-lutely. That's why you're the best babe."

All I'm able to manage is a smile, which is all she can do in reply.