Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by norker151 norker151

What's next?

Talking

John had been having a good time at the party, he got to fuck and blow into the always willing and beautiful Caitlin and there were lots of people at the party to talk and drink with. He was just saying hello to Paul and Paul's new girlfriend while Caitlin finished swallowing and then licked his cock clean before she grabbed her rum and coke to wash it all down. After she had done that, she stood up and grabbed John 's face for a deep kiss before starting to fix her clothes. Once she was presentable again Caitlin started to walk away from the group.

Ashley couldn't help but be a bit snarky "So you just do THAT to your girlfriend in the middle of someone else's house?"

John pulled up his pants and shrugged. "Well first off Caitlin is married to George, not me." he points to the man currently with his arm around Caitlin "Second, it's just what I do... you seem to be the only one here who objects and you JUST met me. Sooo why not just be cool"

Ashley scoffs and is going to say something else but Paul cuts her off and starts to drag her away "Talk later man," he says.

John salutes with his drink and then gets up to go grab some snacks.

Ashley ended up talking to Sarah as the night wore on, Paul was off with some of his buddies talking about the recent game and she wasn't into sports. Ashley had met Sarah before the party so she felt comfortable with her.

"Did you see that guy earlier fucking someone's wife?" Ashley asked with a scoff.

"Oh, do you mean John ?"

"Yeah, what's up with that? Is it something about the three of them?" Ashley prodded about.

"No haha, definitely not. George isn't into that I hear" Sarah giggled. "That's just how John is... He is just a free spirit I think. Doing what nature guides him to do"

Ashley looked Sarah up and down. She didn't look like a hippy or a witch, but it wasn't always easy to tell. Sarah had Jet black hair, a decent rack and ass. If Caitlin was a 9\10, then Sarah was an 8\10.

"You sound like you envy him," Ashley said with a hint of disgust.

"Nah he just never has any drama about him. It's interesting and yet completely normal" She said as she swayed to the music. "You know you are getting pretty riled up over a guy you just met" she smirked

"What?... no... fuck no... he isn't my type, I doubt he can be many people's type" Ashley said quickly

"Hrmm as the guys say... maybe you complain a little too loudly" Sarah teased and then sighed "I need a smoke...you got any weed?"

"Sorry no, I don't have any" Ashley shook her head.

"Maybe I'll ask John, he usually has some... " she looked around. "Hrmm I dont see him but at least I see Erin "

Ashley got curious "Whats Erin got to do with finding John ?"

Sarah chuckled "Sometimes at these parties John will disappear with Erin. I dunno if they go smoke together or what,.. but it happens at least once a party"

"No offence but he doesn't sound like a decent guy" Ashley pouted

Sarah gave her some side-eye. "All Judgements and no proof....Also, you haven't even had the John Special"

"What the hell is the John Special?" Ashley asked

Sarah smirked again. "It's a little thing that John does for all new people added to our friend group, means you are one of us"

"Bullshit" Ashley spit "Paul would have told me"

Sarah shrugs "Then go ask him"

With a huff, Ashley walks off to the other room where Paul and a bunch of guys are talking and shouting. She pushed her way in and grabbed him by the arm

"Is a John Special a real thing?" She asks

Paul looks down at her and she can see the gears change in his head as he switches from 'guy mode' to 'boyfriend mode' "Yeah hun, it's a real thing... I didn't tell you as I didn't know if you wanted to join the friend group yet"

Does she want to join or be standoff-ish

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)