Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by Throwaway69 Throwaway69

Do what she says or take it further?

Take it further

I put my tongue against her ass and start licking around her asshole intentionally avoid it.

"Quit playing around and put it in me." Cassidy says.

I stick my tongue right on her asshole and dart my tongue in and out.

"No silly, I meant with real lube." She giggles

I put down the butt plug and grab the bottle of lube. I slide down my pants and boxers and squirt a bunch of lube of my dick. I stick the tip of my cock against her asshole.

She encourages me. "Your doing good, just take it slow." She must have no idea that it's my dick about to enter her ass.

I push the tip in, and it feels amazing. So much tighter than I imagined. I slowly insert the rest of my cock into her ass. "Ugh" I groan.

Cassidy curiously says, "Um, is it not all the way in yet?" She reaches around and grabs the base of my cock. "Oh my god! What are you doing?" She doesn't pull away though.

I start to panic that I took it a step to far. "I'm so sorry, I don't know what I was thinking. I'm so sorry!" I start to pull out of her and she grabs the back of my thigh and pulls me back in.

"I didn't say to pull out." She turns her head to face me and she is smiling ear to ear. She starts backing up onto me to get deeper.

I didn't need to be told twice. I start going faster and faster. I reach my hand around and start rubbing her clit while ass fucking her.

She says in between moans. "Oh fuck this feels so good. You better not cum yet." She moves my hand and sticks two of my fingers into her pussy while she rubs her clit. "Fuck fuck fuck fuck fuuuuuucccccckkkkkkk!!!!!!" I feel her asshole clench around me when she came. I start to pull out again when she stops me. "Where do you think your going? I want you cum inside me all day." She winks

I ram my cock back into her asshole as hard as I can. I start fucking her asshole with reckless abandon. As I'm getting closer and closer to an orgasm I slap her ass multiple times and **** her.

"Fuck I'm about the cum!" I unload rope after rope of cum into her ass.

Cassidy turns to me, "Grab the plug and put it in my ass as soon as you pull out so I don't loose a drop of your cum."

I pick up the plug and put lube on it, I pull out my dick and pop the butt plug in there as soon as I could but a few drops manage to slip out.

"Did you loose any?" She asks.

"No no, of course not." I lie

"Okay awesome, so your reward is something special." She spins herself around and her face is an inch away from my cock. And then she puts her mouth around the tip of my penis and sucks the tip. I put my hands on the back of her head and pulls her farther in. She cleans my cock of my cum and the lube. "Your cum taste so good." As she puts her clothes back on.

I put my pants and boxers back on and go into the kitchen to grab something to eat.

What to do next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)